Most Valuable & Rarest Cards of 2024 Finest Football Mystery Finest
Every card in 2024 Finest Football Mystery Finest, ranked by market value, with live prices, trends and real sold comps.
Cards in Set100
Market Value (PSA 10)$780
Market Value (Raw NM)$2,475
Avg 30d Change—
Top CardWalter Payton
#CardConditionPriceRaw Price30d %RarityTrend
1Walter Payton #MYST-28PSA 9.5$1,649$26——2
J.J. Watt #MYST-33PSA 9.5$769$13——3
Malik Nabers #MYST-23Near Mint$525$525——4
Tim Tebow #MYST-5Near Mint$475$475——5
Michael Pratt #MYST-17Near Mint$300$300——6
Jalen McMillan #MYST-26PSA 10$210$20——7
Rob Gronkowski #MYST-31Near Mint$200$200——8
Jayden Daniels #MYST-16Near Mint$186$186——9
Caleb Williams #MYST-16Near Mint$183$183——10
Peyton Manning #MYST-7Near Mint$103$103——11
Kamari Lassiter #MYST-19Near Mint$100$100——12
Xavier Worthy #MYST-24Near Mint$87$87——13
Dan Pastorini #MYST-6PSA 10$63$9——14
Adonai Mitchell #MYST-20Near Mint$50$50——15
Drew Bledsoe #MYST-10Near Mint$46$46——16
Don Majkowski #MYST-6Near Mint$25$25——17
Devin Hester #MYST-32Near Mint$25$25——18
Brian Dawkins #MYST-31PSA 9.5$23$8——19
Adrian Peterson #MYST-30Near Mint$20$20——20
Roman Wilson #MYST-25Near Mint$17$17——21
Johnny Wilson #MYST-25Near Mint$15$15——22
Kurt Warner #MYST-1Near Mint$13$13——23
Bob Griese #MYST-8PSA 9$10———24
Danny White #MYST-3Near Mint$9$9——25Marshall Faulk #MYST-30Near Mint$7$7——26
Troy Polamalu #MYST-9Near Mint$5$5——27
Jermaine Burton #MYST-26Near Mint$5$5——28
Dan Fouts #MYST-13Near Mint$3$3——29
Ron Jaworski #MYST-12Near Mint$2$2——30
Doug Williams #MYST-15Near Mint$1$1——31Lenny Moore #MYST-28Raw————32Drew Brees #MYST-1Raw————33Jim Kelly #MYST-2Raw————34Jim McMahon #MYST-2Raw————35Terrell Owens #MYST-3Raw————36Troy Aikman #MYST-4Raw————37Craig Morton #MYST-4Raw————38John Elway #MYST-5Raw————39Randall Cunningham #MYST-9Raw————40Tom Brady #MYST-10Raw————41Tom Brady #MYST-10Raw————42Archie Manning #MYST-11Raw————43Charlie Batch #MYST-12Raw————44Terry Bradshaw #MYST-13Raw————45Steve Young #MYST-14Raw————46Mark Rypien #MYST-15Raw————47Drake Maye #MYST-16Raw————48Xavier Legette #MYST-20Raw————49Ladd McConkey #MYST-21Raw————50Ja'Lynn Polk #MYST-21Raw————51Ricky Pearsall #MYST-21Raw————52Malik Washington #MYST-22Raw————53Anthony Gould #MYST-22Raw————54Ennis Rakestraw Jr. #MYST-23Raw————55Keon Coleman #MYST-24Raw————56Brenden Rice #MYST-26Raw————57Jacob Cowing #MYST-27Raw————58Jamaal Charles #MYST-30Raw————59Jerome Bettis #MYST-31Raw————60Barry Sanders #MYST-29Raw————61Eli Manning #MYST-11Raw————62Lawrence Taylor #MYST-33Raw————63Brad Johnson #MYST-14Raw————64Calen Bullock #MYST-20Raw————65Jeff Garcia #MYST-13Raw————66Edgerrin Cooper #MYST-19Raw————67Marvin Harrison Jr. #MYST-23Raw————68Spencer Rattler #MYST-17Raw————69Doug Flutie #MYST-2Raw————70Roger Staubach #MYST-4Raw————71Warren Moon #MYST-7Raw————72Brett Favre #MYST-5Raw————73Donovan McNabb #MYST-12Raw————74Bruce Smith #MYST-32Raw————75Rob Gronkowski #MYST-7Raw————76Daunte Culpepper #MYST-9Raw————77Phil Simms #MYST-11Raw————78Earl Campbell #MYST-29Raw————79Bo Nix #MYST-17Raw————80Malachi Corley #MYST-25Raw————81Michael Vick #MYST-1Raw————82Jason Sehorn #MYST-33Raw————83Boomer Esiason #MYST-3Raw————84Devontez Walker #MYST-27Raw————85Sam Hartman #MYST-18Raw————86Jim Everett #MYST-8Raw————87Michael Hall Jr. #MYST-19Raw————88DeMarco Murray #MYST-28Raw————89T'Vondre Sweat #MYST-18Raw————90Cedric Gray #MYST-18Raw————91Ainias Smith #MYST-27Raw————92Lynn Dickey #MYST-6Raw————93Luke McCaffrey #MYST-22Raw————94Dan Marino #MYST-8Raw————95Joe Montana #MYST-14Raw————96Joe Theismann #MYST-15Raw————97Ray Lewis #MYST-32Raw————98Steve Grogan #MYST-10Raw————99Troy Franklin #MYST-24Raw————100Emmitt Smith #MYST-29Raw————