Most Valuable & Rarest Cards of 2025 Finest Football Nightmare Fuel
Every card in 2025 Finest Football Nightmare Fuel, ranked by market value, with live prices, trends and real sold comps.
Cards in Set15
Market Value (PSA 10)$255
Market Value (Raw NM)$512
Avg 30d Change—
Top CardTrey Hendrickson
#CardConditionPriceRaw Price30d %RarityTrend
1
Trey Hendrickson #NF-2PSA 10$255$37——2Micah Parsons #NF-5Near Mint$250$250——3Myles Garrett #NF-3Near Mint$225$225——4Troy Polamalu #NF-14Raw————5Lawrence Taylor #NF-11Raw————6Sauce Gardner #NF-10Raw————7Ray Lewis #NF-13Raw————8Reggie White #NF-12Raw————9Pat Surtain II #NF-9Raw————10Maxx Crosby #NF-6Raw————11Fred Warner #NF-8Raw————12Chris Jones #NF-1Raw————13T.J. Watt #NF-7Raw————14Aidan Hutchinson #NF-4Raw————15Brian Urlacher #NF-15Raw————