Most Valuable & Rarest Cards of 2025 Panini Rookies & Stars Football
Every card in 2025 Panini Rookies & Stars Football, ranked by market value, with live prices, trends and real sold comps.
Cards in Set200
Market Value (PSA 10)$9,057
Market Value (Raw NM)$13,397
Avg 30d Change-37.18%
Top CardPatrick Mahomes II
#CardConditionPriceRaw Price30d %RarityTrend
1
Patrick Mahomes II #7Near Mint$1,288$1,288——2
Ben Roethlisberger #63PSA 10$750$129——3
John Elway #6PSA 10$577$137——4
Terrance Ferguson #182Near Mint$575$575——5
Justin Jefferson #75PSA 10$564$124——6
Shedeur Sanders #177BGS 8.5$525$124——7
Colston Loveland #114PSA 8$500$60——8
Harold Fannin Jr. #126PSA 10$403$89——9
Marvin Harrison Jr. #15PSA 9$360$50——10
Kyle Hamilton #53Near Mint$350$350——11
Ashton Jeanty #106PSA 10$350$80——12
Kyle McCord #151Near Mint$350$350——13
Myles Garrett #58PSA 9.5$325$100——14
Brian Dawkins #47PSA 10$303$97——15
Justin Herbert #1PSA 10$300$110——16
Cam Ward #111PSA 10$295$85——17
Baker Mayfield #98Near Mint$285$285——18
Kam Chancellor #25PSA 10$283$115——19
Calvin Johnson #70Near Mint$275$275——20
Trevor Lawrence #84Near Mint$250$250——21
Bhayshul Tuten #109Near Mint$250$250——22
Maxwell Hairston #159Near Mint$250$250——23
Sam Darnold #24PSA 10$250$150——24
Brock Purdy #20Near Mint$228$228——25
RJ Harvey #173Near Mint$210$210——26
Lamar Jackson #51PSA 10$210$5——27
Josh Allen #26Near Mint$200$200——28
Josh Jacobs #72PSA 10$199$45——29
Peyton Manning #82Near Mint$184$184——30
Art Monk #50Near Mint$170$170——31
Phil Simms #43Near Mint$165$165——32
Randy Moss #76Near Mint$158$158——33
Quinn Ewers #170PSA 10$154$45——34
Michael Penix Jr. #89Lightly Played$150$150——35
Jaydon Blue #139PSA 10$150$125——36
T.J. Watt #62Near Mint$150$150——37
Courtland Sutton #5BGS 9.5$150$75——38
Bo Nix #4PSA 10$150$100——39
Pat Bryant #168Near Mint$150$150——40
Jaxson Dart #137Near Mint$148$148——41
Tyler Shough #194Near Mint$145$145——42
Tre Harris #187Near Mint$140$140——43
Elijah Arroyo #123Near Mint$140$140——44
Jim Harbaugh #3PSA 10$136$38——45
Tory Horton #185PSA 10$136$52——46
Joe Montana #22Near Mint$135$135——47
Mason Taylor #157Near Mint$126$126——48
Drew Brees #97Near Mint$125$125——49
George Kittle #21Near Mint$123$123——50
Cam Skattebo #110Near Mint$116$116——51
Caleb Williams #64PSA 10$115$33——52
Derrick Henry #52Near Mint$106$106——53
Trevor Etienne #189Near Mint$105$105——54
Deebo Samuel #49PSA 10$104$43——55
Devin Hester #66Near Mint$103$103——56
Michael Vick #91PSA 9$103$75——57
Micah Parsons #39Near Mint$100$100——58
Mike Evans #99Near Mint$100$100——59
Isaac TeSlaa #127Near Mint$100$100——60
Joe Burrow #55Near Mint$100$100——61
Tyler Warren #195Near Mint$100$100——62
Christian Gonzalez #33PSA 10$99$10——63
Will Howard #197Near Mint$88$88——64
Julius Peppers #94Near Mint$85$85——65
Alvin Kamara #95Near Mint$85$85——66
Thurman Thomas #28Near Mint$85$85——67
Luther Burden III #154Near Mint$85$85——68
Chris Olave #96Near Mint$81$81——69
Dak Prescott #38PSA 10$80$8——70
Nic Scourton #162Near Mint$80$80——71
Derrick Harmon #116PSA 10$77$25——72
Ray Lewis #54Near Mint$76$76——73
Michael Irvin #40Near Mint$75$75——74
J.J. McCarthy #74Near Mint$75$75——75
Bijan Robinson #90PSA 10$72$45——76
Jayden Daniels #48PSA 10$72$16——77
Jaxon Smith-Njigba #23PSA 10$72$10——78
Xavier Watts #200PSA 10$72$40——79
Xavier Legette #93PSA 9$69$18——80
Puka Nacua #18PSA 10$68$20——81
Tetairoa McMillan #183Near Mint$65$65——82
Elic Ayomanor #122Near Mint$65$65——83
Grey Zabel #125Near Mint$65$65——84
Jalen Royals #133PSA 10$60$40——85
TreVeyon Henderson #188Near Mint$60$60——86
Fred Taylor #85Near Mint$60$60——87
Sterling Sharpe #73PSA 10$59$57——88
Mike Alstott #100Near Mint$57$57——89
Chimere Dike #113PSA 10$56$20——90
Jarquez Hunter #136PSA 10$55$20——91
Marcus Allen #13Near Mint$55$55——92
Aidan Hutchinson #68Near Mint$55$55——93
Dillon Gabriel #117Near Mint$53$53——94
Riley Leonard #172Near Mint$52$52——95
Jaylen Waddle #30Near Mint$50$50——96
Armand Membou #105Near Mint$50$50——97
Drake Maye #32Near Mint$50$50——98
Mykel Williams #161Near Mint$50$50——99
DK Metcalf #61PSA 9$49$4——100
Ja'Marr Chase #56PSA 10$47$4——