Most Valuable Andy Pettitte Cards
Every Andy Pettitte card in the catalog, ranked by market value, with live prices, trends and real sold comps.
Andy Pettitte Cards1000
Market Value (PSA 10)$10,414
Market Value (Raw NM)$12,511
Avg 30d Change+0.46%
Top CardAndy Pettitte
#CardConditionPriceRaw Price30d %RarityTrend
1Andy Pettitte #CLA-APE2026 Topps Chrome Baseball Chrome Legend AutographsNear Mint$2,475$2,475——2
Andy Pettitte #3332001 Topps Chrome BaseballPSA 10$557$48——3
Andy Pettitte #WSCA-AP2026 Topps Chrome Baseball World Series Champions AutographsPSA 10$556$102——4
Andy Pettitte #31998 Bowman Chrome BaseballPSA 10$389$42——5
Andy Pettitte #CPA-AP2025 Topps Chrome Platinum Autograph BaseballPSA 10$372$200——6
Andy Pettitte #OA-APE2025 Topps Archives Baseball Topps Originals AutographsPSA 10$361$79——7
Andy Pettitte #91A-PET2026 Topps Baseball 1991 Topps AutographsPSA 10$340$165——8
Andy Pettitte #GOG-AP2025 Topps Gilded Collection Gallery Of Gold Autograph BaseballNear Mint$339$339——9
Andy Pettitte #PA-AP2021 Topps Chrome Platinum Anniversary Baseball AutographsNear Mint$333$333——10
Andy Pettitte #TTAR-AP32024 Topps Triple Threads Baseball Autograph RelicPSA 10$315$275——11
Andy Pettitte #TTAR-AP12022 Topps Triple Threads Baseball Autograph RelicsNear Mint$300$300——12
Andy Pettitte #SCA-AP2024 Topps Cosmic Chrome Baseball Star Command AutographsNear Mint$299$299——13
Andy Pettitte #3222003 Topps Chrome BaseballPSA 10$299$150——14
Andy Pettitte #MA-AP2023 Topps Allen & Ginter Baseball Framed Mini AutographsNear Mint$299$299——15
Andy Pettitte #TTAR-AP12024 Topps Triple Threads Baseball Autograph RelicPSA 10$280$80——16
Andy Pettitte #MOM-AP2024 Topps Luminaries Baseball Masters of the Mound AutographsPSA 10$272$70——17
Andy Pettitte #PPAR-AP2025 Topps Pristine Pieces Autograph Relics BaseballPSA 10$272$83——18
Andy Pettitte #1761995 Upper Deck Minor League BaseballPSA 10$260$2——19
Andy Pettitte #AA-652023 Topps Update Baseball All AcesNear Mint$250$250——20
Andy Pettitte #FSS-AP2025 Topps Five Star Silver Signature BaseballPSA 10$241$100——21
Andy Pettitte #TSAR-API2025 Topps Sterling Splendor Jumbo Patch Autograph BaseballNear Mint$202$202——22
Andy Pettitte #TSAR-APT2025 Topps Sterling Splendor Jumbo Patch Autograph BaseballNear Mint$200$200——23
Andy Pettitte #BC2-AP2018 Topps Brooklyn Collection Autographs BaseballNear Mint$195$195——24
Andy Pettitte #TAIC-AP2025 Topps Transcendent Icons Chrome Autograph BaseballPSA 10$195$150——25
Andy Pettitte #DAP-APE22024 Topps Dynasty BaseballNear Mint$191$191——26
Andy Pettitte #FMA-AP2025 Topps Finest Moments Autograph BaseballPSA 10$175$48——27
Andy Pettitte #1171993 Classic Best Gold BaseballPSA 10$175$2——28Andy Pettitte #DCAI-AP2018 Topps Definitive Collection Baseball Inscription CollectionNear Mint$175$175——29
Andy Pettitte #CBA-APE2024 Topps Chrome Black Baseball AutographsNear Mint$175$175——30
Andy Pettitte #DAP-APE12024 Topps Dynasty BaseballNear Mint$173$173——31
Andy Pettitte #6232002 Topps Chrome BaseballNear Mint$166$166——32
Andy Pettitte #1221997 Upper Deck BaseballPSA 10$150$2——33Andy Pettitte #TFAP-AP2025 Topps Baseball Autograph PatchNear Mint$148$148——34
Andy Pettitte #TFAP-AP2025 Topps Flagship Autograph Patch BaseballNear Mint$147$147——35
Andy Pettitte #642004 Topps Chrome BaseballPSA 10$145$13——36
Andy Pettitte #432000 Topps Subway Series BaseballPSA 8$140$2——37Andy Pettitte #TTAR-AP22021 Topps Triple Threads Baseball Autograph RelicsNear Mint$138$138——38
Andy Pettitte #T1OA-AP2026 Topps Tier One Baseball Tier One Operators AutographsPSA 10$131$22——39
Andy Pettitte #GCH-AP2024 Topps Gilded Collection Baseball Gilded ChampionsPSA 8$120$73——40
Andy Pettitte #TTAR-AP22024 Topps Triple Threads Baseball Autograph RelicNear Mint$119$119——41
Andy Pettitte #TTAR-AP22022 Topps Triple Threads Baseball Autograph RelicsNear Mint$116$116——42Andy Pettitte #85-A2023 Topps Black & White Baseball AutographsSGC 10$115$40——43
Andy Pettitte #241998 Donruss Elite BaseballNear Mint$115$115——44
Andy Pettitte #TA-APE2024 Topps Tribute Baseball AutographsPSA 10$111$67——45
Andy Pettitte #T1A-AP2023 Topps Tier One Baseball AutographsNear Mint$110$110——46
Andy Pettitte #ASA-AP2003 Upper Deck Baseball AL All-Star SwatchesPSA 10$100$5——47
Andy Pettitte #4931994 Bowman BaseballPSA 10$100$2——48
Andy Pettitte #642004 Topps BaseballNear Mint$100$100——49
Andy Pettitte #632013 Panini Prizm BaseballPSA 10$100$4——50
Andy Pettitte #932005 Donruss Classics BaseballNear Mint$100$100——51
Andy Pettitte #2141992 Fleer Excel BaseballPSA 10$99$2——52
Andy Pettitte #MOMAR-AP2024 Topps Luminaries Baseball Masters of the Mound Autograph RelicsNear Mint$98$98——53
Andy Pettitte #DCA-AP2022 Topps Definitive Collection Baseball AutographsPSA 9$98$39——54
Andy Pettitte #MMJPA-AP2024 Topps Museum Collection Baseball Momentous Material Jumbo Patch AutographsNear Mint$98$98——55
Andy Pettitte #721997 Bowman Chrome International BaseballPSA 9$96$48——56
Andy Pettitte #4972003 Topps BaseballPSA 10$95$29——57Andy Pettitte #85A2022 Topps Black & White Baseball AutographsNear Mint$95$95——58
Andy Pettitte #1852025 Topps Allen & Ginter BaseballNear Mint$94$94——59
Andy Pettitte #432003 Bowman Chrome BaseballPSA 10$92$5——60
Andy Pettitte #2871995 Flair BaseballPSA 10$91$2——61
Andy Pettitte #4361996 Stadium Club BaseballPSA 10$90$2——62
Andy Pettitte #911996 Select Certified BaseballNear Mint$90$90——63
Andy Pettitte #N43A-APE2024 Topps Allen & Ginter N43 Boxloader Autograph BaseballNear Mint$90$90——64
Andy Pettitte #31998 Bowman Chrome International BaseballPSA 9$90$20——65
Andy Pettitte #2871997 Finest Embossed BaseballNear Mint$89$89——66
Andy Pettitte #TTAR-AP32022 Topps Triple Threads Baseball Autograph RelicsNear Mint$87$87——67
Andy Pettitte #5062013 Topps BaseballPSA 10$85$8——68
Andy Pettitte #FSA-AP2022 Topps Five Star Baseball AutographsPSA 10$85$30——69
Andy Pettitte #961995 Select Certified BaseballPSA 10$80$6——70Andy Pettitte #85A2022 Topps Black And White BaseballNear Mint$80$80——71
Andy Pettitte #852022 Topps Black & White BaseballNear Mint$80$80——72
Andy Pettitte #1121999 Flair Showcase BaseballPSA 10$78$2——73
Andy Pettitte #921996 Metal Universe BaseballPSA 10$76$2——74
Andy Pettitte #1382023 Topps Archives Signature Series Retired Player Edition BaseballNear Mint$68$68——75
Andy Pettitte #DIA-AP2024 Topps Diamond Icons Baseball Diamond Icons AutographsNear Mint$68$68——76
Andy Pettitte #431998 Flair Showcase BaseballPSA 9$66$6——77
Andy Pettitte #852023 Topps Black & White BaseballPSA 10$65$20——78
Andy Pettitte #741996 Panini Donruss BaseballPSA 10$65$1——79
Andy Pettitte #281994 Classic BaseballPSA 10$63$2——80
Andy Pettitte #DR-AP2022 Topps Tribute Baseball Dual RelicsNear Mint$63$63——81
Andy Pettitte #4332001 Topps BaseballPSA 10$63$1——82
Andy Pettitte #1221996 Finest BaseballPSA 10$62$6——83
Andy Pettitte #1941996 Fleer BaseballPSA 10$60$2——84
Andy Pettitte #1202024 Topps Allen & Ginter X BaseballNear Mint$60$60——85
Andy Pettitte #1491997 Circa BaseballNear Mint$60$60——86
Andy Pettitte #1682022 Topps Pristine BaseballPSA 10$60$26——87
Andy Pettitte #8272025 Topps Living Set BaseballPSA 10$60$8——88
Andy Pettitte #GOG-AP2023 Topps Gilded Collection Baseball Gallery of Gold AutographsNear Mint$59$59——89
Andy Pettitte #55RA-AP2022 Topps Clearly Authentic Baseball 1955 Reimagining AutographsNear Mint$58$58——90
Andy Pettitte #89BR-APE2024 Topps 1989 Relic BaseballPSA 10$58$10——91
Andy Pettitte #MLMA2-AP2024 Topps Major League Material Autograph BaseballNear Mint$57$57——92
Andy Pettitte #TTAR-AP22020 Topps Triple Threads Baseball Autograph RelicsNear Mint$55$55——93
Andy Pettitte #392020 Topps Allen & Ginter BaseballNear Mint$53$53——94
Andy Pettitte #1751998 Ultra BaseballPSA 10$53$1——95Andy Pettitte #FOF-22024 Leaf Bronx Legacy Baseball Fabric of the FranchiseNear Mint$53$53——96
Andy Pettitte #DCA-AP2023 Topps Definitive Collection Baseball AutographsNear Mint$52$52——97
Andy Pettitte #DIA-AP2025 Topps Diamond Icons Diamond Icons Autograph BaseballNear Mint$52$52——98
Andy Pettitte #MFR-AP2025 Topps Allen & Ginter Baseball Allen & Ginter Mini Framed RelicsPSA 10$51$5——99
Andy Pettitte #FSA-AP2016 Topps Five Star Baseball AutographsNear Mint$50$50——100
Andy Pettitte #AP2018 Topps Finest Hour Autographs BaseballNear Mint$50$50——Sets with Andy Pettitte cards
Andy Pettitte appears in 829 sets. Open one for the most valuable cards in it.
- 2008 Upper Deck Baseball Yankee Stadium Legacy75 cards
- 2016 Topps Dynasty Baseball Autograph Patches12 cards
- 2011 Topps Baseball In the Name8 cards
- 1997 Upper Deck Baseball5 cards
- 2007 Upper Deck Baseball4 cards
- 2012 Topps Triple Threads Baseball Relic Autographs4 cards
- 2018 Topps Triple Threads Baseball Autograph Relics4 cards
- 2000 Topps Subway Series Baseball3 cards
- 2001 Topps Heritage Baseball3 cards
- 2007 Fleer Baseball3 cards
- 2012 Topps Triple Threads Baseball Unity Relics3 cards
- 2013 Topps Triple Threads Baseball Unity Relics3 cards
- 2018 Topps Dynasty Baseball Autographed Patches3 cards
- 2020 Topps Triple Threads Baseball Autograph Relics3 cards
- 2021 Topps Dynasty Baseball Autographed Patches3 cards
- 2022 Topps Triple Threads Baseball Autograph Relics3 cards
- 2024 Topps Triple Threads Baseball Autograph Relic3 cards
- 1996 Panini Donruss Baseball2 cards
- 1996 Score Baseball2 cards
- 1996 Ultra Baseball2 cards
- 1997 Donruss Baseball2 cards
- 1997 Fleer Baseball2 cards
- 1997 Leaf Baseball2 cards
- 1997 Panini Donruss Baseball2 cards
- 1997 Score Baseball2 cards
- 1997 Sports Illustrated Baseball2 cards
- 1998 Donruss Collections Baseball Donruss Preferred Collections2 cards
- 1998 Donruss Preferred Baseball2 cards
- 1998 Fleer Tradition Baseball2 cards
- 1998 Pinnacle Snapshots Baseball2 cards
- 2001 Fleer Platinum Baseball2 cards
- 2002 Upper Deck 40-Man Baseball2 cards
- 2004 Topps Baseball2 cards
- 2004 Upper Deck Vintage Baseball2 cards
- 2005 Topps Heritage Baseball2 cards
- 2006 Topps Allen & Ginter Framed Relics Baseball2 cards
- 2009 SP Authentic Baseball2 cards
- 2009 Topps Unique MLB Logo Patch2 cards
- 2009 Upper Deck Baseball2 cards
- 2010 Upper Deck Baseball2 cards