Most Valuable Casey Stengel Cards

Every Casey Stengel card in the catalog, ranked by market value, with live prices, trends and real sold comps.

Casey Stengel Cards234

Market Value (PSA 10)$60,048

Market Value (Raw NM)$2,217

Avg 30d Change-17.16%

Top CardCasey Stengel

#CardConditionPriceRaw Price30d %RarityPrice · 30d %Trend

Casey Stengel #141 1940 Play Ball Baseball

Casey Stengel #1411940 Play Ball BaseballPSA 10$25,409$75——2

Casey Stengel #217 1950 Bowman Baseball

Casey Stengel #2171950 Bowman BaseballPSA 10$8,898$32——3

Casey Stengel #217 1952 Bowman Baseball

Casey Stengel #2171952 Bowman BaseballPSA 10$7,064$26——4

Casey Stengel #181 1951 Bowman Baseball

Casey Stengel #1811951 Bowman BaseballPSA 10$5,627$22——5

Casey Stengel #1 1953 Red Man Tobacco Baseball

Casey Stengel #11953 Red Man Tobacco BaseballPSA 10$3,154$13——6

Casey Stengel #227 1960 Topps Baseball

Casey Stengel #2271960 Topps BaseballPSA 10$2,142$8——7

Casey Stengel #552 1959 Topps Baseball

Casey Stengel #5521959 Topps BaseballPSA 10$2,076$11——8

Casey Stengel #233 1963 Topps Baseball

Casey Stengel #2331963 Topps BaseballPSA 10$1,260$7——9

Casey Stengel #187 1965 Topps Baseball

Casey Stengel #1871965 Topps BaseballPSA 10$1,071$6——10

Casey Stengel #29 1962 Topps Baseball

Casey Stengel #291962 Topps BaseballPSA 10$1,063$6——11

Casey Stengel #324 1964 Topps Baseball

Casey Stengel #3241964 Topps BaseballPSA 10$735$4——12

Casey Stengel #FSCS-CS 2024 Topps Five Star Baseball Cut Signatures

Casey Stengel #FSCS-CS2024 Topps Five Star Baseball Cut SignaturesNear Mint$388$388——13

Casey Stengel #ICS-CS 2025 Topps Diamond Icons Immortal Cut Signature Baseball

Casey Stengel #ICS-CS2025 Topps Diamond Icons Immortal Cut Signature BaseballNear Mint$351$351——14

Casey Stengel #29 1962 Venezuela Topps Baseball

Casey Stengel #291962 Venezuela Topps BaseballNear Mint$297$297——15

Casey Stengel #RJ-CS 2001 Topps Tribute Game Worn Jersey Baseball

Casey Stengel #RJ-CS2001 Topps Tribute Game Worn Jersey BaseballPSA 10$247$13——16

Casey Stengel #J-CS 2001 Sp Legendary Cuts Game Jersey Baseball

Casey Stengel #J-CS2001 Sp Legendary Cuts Game Jersey BaseballPSA 10$239$13——17

Casey Stengel #CC-CS 2024 Topps Tribute Cooperstown Cuts Cut Signature Baseball

Casey Stengel #CC-CS2024 Topps Tribute Cooperstown Cuts Cut Signature BaseballNear Mint$211$211——18

Casey Stengel #55NW-20 2025 Topps Chrome Platinum Baseball 1955 Cards That Never Were

Casey Stengel #55NW-202025 Topps Chrome Platinum Baseball 1955 Cards That Never WerePSA 10$169$29——19

Casey Stengel #LMJ-CS 2001 Upper Deck Legends of New York Baseball Game-Worn Jerseys

Casey Stengel #LMJ-CS2001 Upper Deck Legends of New York Baseball Game-Worn JerseysPSA 10$162$8——20

Casey Stengel #29 1962 Topps Venezuelan Baseball

Casey Stengel #291962 Topps Venezuelan BaseballPSA 8$130$7——21

Casey Stengel #113 1919-21 W514 Baseball

Casey Stengel #1131919-21 W514 BaseballNear Mint$129$129——22

Casey Stengel #325 1991 Topps Archives 1953 Baseball

Casey Stengel #3251991 Topps Archives 1953 BaseballPSA 10$97$2——23

Casey Stengel #218 1989 Pacific Legends Baseball

Casey Stengel #2181989 Pacific Legends BaseballPSA 10$92$1——24

Casey Stengel #55WS-7 2025 Topps Chrome Platinum 1955 World Series Baseball

Casey Stengel #55WS-72025 Topps Chrome Platinum 1955 World Series BaseballPSA 10$81$11——25

Casey Stengel #37 1991 Conlon Collection Baseball

Casey Stengel #371991 Conlon Collection BaseballPSA 10$71$1——26

Casey Stengel #10 2021 Panini Immaculate Collection Baseball

Casey Stengel #102021 Panini Immaculate Collection BaseballNear Mint$70$70——27

Casey Stengel #86 2024 Topps Spotlight Baseball

Casey Stengel #862024 Topps Spotlight BaseballNear Mint$70$70——28

Casey Stengel #39 1953 Bowman B & W Baseball

Casey Stengel #391953 Bowman B & W BaseballNear Mint$61$61——29

Casey Stengel #202 2001 Topps Archives Baseball

Casey Stengel #2022001 Topps Archives BaseballPSA 10$61$2——30

Casey Stengel #28 2022 Panini National Treasures Baseball

Casey Stengel #282022 Panini National Treasures BaseballNear Mint$60$60——31

Casey Stengel #376 2021 Topps Project 70 Baseball

Casey Stengel #3762021 Topps Project 70 BaseballNear Mint$57$57——32

Casey Stengel #90 2001 SP Legendary Cuts Baseball

Casey Stengel #902001 SP Legendary Cuts BaseballPSA 10$50$1——33

Casey Stengel #103 1981 Perez Steele HOF Postcard Baseball

Casey Stengel #1031981 Perez Steele HOF Postcard BaseballPSA 10$50$7——34

Casey Stengel #37 1983 Donruss Hall Of Fame Heroes Baseball

Casey Stengel #371983 Donruss Hall Of Fame Heroes BaseballPSA 10$46$1——35

Casey Stengel #20 1980 Laughlin Famous Feats Baseball

Casey Stengel #201980 Laughlin Famous Feats BaseballPSA 10$34$2——36

Casey Stengel #150-71 2019 Topps Update 150 Years of Professional Baseball

Casey Stengel #150-712019 Topps Update 150 Years of Professional BaseballPSA 10$32$4——37

Casey Stengel #103 1980 Baseball Immortals

Casey Stengel #1031980 Baseball ImmortalsPSA 10$30$2——38

Casey Stengel #13 1977 Tcma Renata Galasso Baseball

Casey Stengel #131977 Tcma Renata Galasso BaseballPSA 9$28$1——39

Casey Stengel #40 1990 Swell Baseball Greats

Casey Stengel #401990 Swell Baseball GreatsPSA 10$25$1——40

Casey Stengel #187 1965 O-Pee-Chee Baseball

Casey Stengel #1871965 O-Pee-Chee BaseballNear Mint$21$21——41

Casey Stengel #80 2000 Upper Deck Yankees Legends Baseball

Casey Stengel #802000 Upper Deck Yankees Legends BaseballPSA 10$20$2——42

Casey Stengel #RJ-CS 2001 Topps Tribute Baseball Game Worn Relics

Casey Stengel #RJ-CS2001 Topps Tribute Baseball Game Worn RelicsNear Mint$19$19——43

Casey Stengel #93 1950 R423 Baseball

Casey Stengel #931950 R423 BaseballNear Mint$18$18——44

Casey Stengel #62 2013 Panini Cooperstown Baseball

Casey Stengel #622013 Panini Cooperstown BaseballNear Mint$18$18——45

Casey Stengel #324 1964 Venezuela Topps Baseball

Casey Stengel #3241964 Venezuela Topps BaseballNear Mint$15$15——46

Casey Stengel #388 2019 Topps Allen & Ginter Baseball

Casey Stengel #3882019 Topps Allen & Ginter BaseballNear Mint$14$14——47

Casey Stengel #6 2013 Panini Cooperstown Pennants Baseball

Casey Stengel #62013 Panini Cooperstown Pennants BaseballNear Mint$12$12——48

Casey Stengel #1 1952 Red Man Tobacco Baseball

Casey Stengel #11952 Red Man Tobacco BaseballNear Mint$11$11——49

Casey Stengel #CM-CS 2007 Upper Deck Sweet Spot Classic Classic Memorabilia Baseball

Casey Stengel #CM-CS2007 Upper Deck Sweet Spot Classic Classic Memorabilia BaseballNear Mint$10$10——50Casey Stengel #BA-462008 Donruss Threads Baseball Americana Materials PositionNear Mint$9$9——51

Casey Stengel #64 2000 Upper Deck Yankees Legends Baseball

Casey Stengel #642000 Upper Deck Yankees Legends BaseballPSA 10$9$1——52

Casey Stengel #20 1972 Laughlin Great Feats Baseball

Casey Stengel #201972 Laughlin Great Feats BaseballNear Mint$8$8——53

Casey Stengel #100 2022 Topps Project 100 Baseball

Casey Stengel #1002022 Topps Project 100 BaseballNear Mint$6$6——54

Casey Stengel #35 2014 Panini Golden Age Baseball

Casey Stengel #352014 Panini Golden Age BaseballNear Mint$6$6——55Casey Stengel #BA-462008 Donruss Threads Baseball AmericanaNear Mint$4$4-17.16%—56Casey Stengel #331986 Conlon BaseballNear Mint$3$3——57

Casey Stengel #180 2006 Sp Legendary Cuts Baseball

Casey Stengel #1802006 Sp Legendary Cuts BaseballNear Mint$3$3——58

Casey Stengel #1330 1995 Conlon Collection Baseball

Casey Stengel #13301995 Conlon Collection BaseballNear Mint$3$3——59

Casey Stengel #LC16 1994 Ted Williams Baseball Gene Locklear Collection

Casey Stengel #LC161994 Ted Williams Baseball Gene Locklear CollectionNear Mint$3$3——60

Casey Stengel #154 2007 Sp Legendary Cuts Baseball

Casey Stengel #1542007 Sp Legendary Cuts BaseballNear Mint$3$3——61

Casey Stengel #192 2001 Upper Deck Legends of New York Baseball

Casey Stengel #1922001 Upper Deck Legends of New York BaseballNear Mint$3$3——62

Casey Stengel #REV-3 2019 Topps Baseball Revolution of the Game

Casey Stengel #REV-32019 Topps Baseball Revolution of the GameNear Mint$2$2——63

Casey Stengel #55 2007 Sp Legendary Cuts Baseball

Casey Stengel #552007 Sp Legendary Cuts BaseballNear Mint$2$2——64

Casey Stengel #LC16 1994 Ted Williams Co Locklear Baseball

Casey Stengel #LC161994 Ted Williams Co Locklear BaseballNear Mint$2$2——65

Casey Stengel #10 2002 SP Legendary Cuts Baseball

Casey Stengel #102002 SP Legendary Cuts BaseballNear Mint$2$2——66

Casey Stengel #12 2001 Upper Deck Legends Of Ny Baseball

Casey Stengel #122001 Upper Deck Legends Of Ny BaseballNear Mint$2$2——67

Casey Stengel #130 1989 Swell Baseball Greats

Casey Stengel #1301989 Swell Baseball GreatsNear Mint$1$1——68

Casey Stengel #42 1983 Tcma 1942 Play Ball Baseball

Casey Stengel #421983 Tcma 1942 Play Ball BaseballNear Mint$1$1——69

Casey Stengel #829 1993 Conlon Collection Baseball

Casey Stengel #8291993 Conlon Collection BaseballNear Mint$1$1——70

Casey Stengel #558 1992 Conlon Collection Baseball

Casey Stengel #5581992 Conlon Collection BaseballNear Mint$1$1——71

Casey Stengel #5 1992 Conlon Collection Baseball

Casey Stengel #51992 Conlon Collection BaseballNear Mint$1$1——72

Casey Stengel #136 1991 Swell Greats Baseball

Casey Stengel #1361991 Swell Greats BaseballNear Mint$1$1——73

Casey Stengel #13 2005 Upper Deck Sweet Spot Classic Baseball

Casey Stengel #132005 Upper Deck Sweet Spot Classic BaseballNear Mint$1$1——74

Casey Stengel #57 1994 Upper Deck American Epic Baseball

Casey Stengel #571994 Upper Deck American Epic BaseballNear Mint$1$1——75

Casey Stengel #LC16 1994 Ted Williams Co Baseball

Casey Stengel #LC161994 Ted Williams Co BaseballNear Mint$0$0——76

Casey Stengel #47 1981 Cramer Legends Baseball

Casey Stengel #471981 Cramer Legends BaseballNear Mint$0$0——77Casey Stengel #CS-CS2017 Topps Diamond Icons Baseball Cut SignaturesRaw————78Casey Stengel #CSR-CS2019 Topps Luminaries Baseball Cut Signature RelicsRaw————79Casey Stengel #1002023 Topps Project 100 BaseballRaw————80Casey Stengel #DCS-CS2017 Topps Dynasty Baseball Cut SignaturesRaw————81

Casey Stengel #13 2001 Upper Deck Legends of New York Baseball

Casey Stengel #132001 Upper Deck Legends of New York BaseballRaw————82

Casey Stengel #22 2001 Upper Deck Legends of New York Baseball

Casey Stengel #222001 Upper Deck Legends of New York BaseballRaw————83

Casey Stengel #97 2001 Upper Deck Legends of New York Baseball

Casey Stengel #972001 Upper Deck Legends of New York BaseballRaw————84Casey Stengel #CUT-CS2022 Topps Luminaries Baseball Cut SignaturesRaw————85Casey Stengel #CS-CS2017 Topps Luminaries Baseball Cut SignaturesRaw————86Casey Stengel #CS-CST2023 Topps Sterling Baseball Cut SignaturesRaw————87Casey Stengel #CSRBC-CS2023 Topps Transcendent Collection Baseball Cut Signature Relic BookRaw————88Casey Stengel #PC-CS12020-21 Leaf Pearl Hockey Pearl Cuts Cut SignaturesRaw————89Casey Stengel #171989 Sportflics Mini The Unforgetables BaseballRaw————90Casey Stengel #ICS-CS2022 Topps Diamond Icons Baseball Immortal Cut SignaturesRaw————91Casey Stengel #CST2002 SP Legendary Cuts Baseball AutographsRaw————92Casey Stengel #ICS-CS2024 Topps Diamond Icons Baseball Immortal Cut SignaturesRaw————93Casey Stengel #112014 Panini Classics Baseball Classic CutsRaw————94Casey Stengel #C-CS2001 SP Legendary Cuts Baseball Cut AutographsRaw————95Casey Stengel #J-CS2001 SP Legendary Cuts Baseball Game-Used Jerseys/UniformsRaw————96Casey Stengel #CUT-CS2023 Topps Luminaries Baseball Cut SignaturesRaw————97Casey Stengel #DCS-CS2023 Topps Definitive Collection Baseball Cut SignaturesRaw————98Casey Stengel #42014 Panini Immaculate Collection Baseball Accolades MaterialsRaw————99Casey Stengel #3241964 Topps Venezuelan BaseballRaw————100Casey Stengel #CS-CST2022 Topps Sterling Baseball Cut SignaturesRaw————

Sets with Casey Stengel cards

Casey Stengel appears in 223 sets. Open one for the most valuable cards in it.