Most Valuable Christy Mathewson Cards
Every Christy Mathewson card in the catalog, ranked by market value, with live prices, trends and real sold comps.
Christy Mathewson Cards304
Market Value (PSA 10)$79,360
Market Value (Raw NM)$59,804
Avg 30d Change+1.59%
Top CardChristy Mathewson
#CardConditionPriceRaw Price30d %RarityTrend
1Christy Mathewson #881915 Cracker Jack BaseballPSA 9$102,300$2,522——2
Christy Mathewson #1751940 Play Ball BaseballPSA 10$72,373$214——3Christy Mathewson #881914 Cracker Jack BaseballNear Mint$51,600$51,600——4
Christy Mathewson #42014 Panini Golden Age Baseball Fan CrazePSA 4$3,558$2——5
Christy Mathewson #112019 Topps Transcendent Collection BaseballPSA 2$2,100$2——6
Christy Mathewson #591961 Fleer BaseballPSA 10$1,039$4——7
Christy Mathewson #21960 Fleer BaseballPSA 10$805$4——8
Christy Mathewson #721919-21 W514 BaseballPSA 1.5$790$405——9
Christy Mathewson #41963 Bazooka All Time Greats BaseballPSA 9$600$24——10
Christy Mathewson #AA-142026 Topps Series 2 All Aces BaseballPSA 10$571$117——11
Christy Mathewson #182024 Panini Flawless Baseball Triple CrownPSA 10$521$294——12
Christy Mathewson #102022 Topps Pristine BaseballPSA 6$485$40——13
Christy Mathewson #1511967 Venezuela Topps BaseballNear Mint$470$470——14
Christy Mathewson #4982025 Topps Chrome Platinum BaseballPSA 10$382$125——15
Christy Mathewson #72025 Topps Allen & Ginter BaseballPSA 10$362$250——16
Christy Mathewson #241920 W516 1 BaseballNear Mint$328$328——17
Christy Mathewson #232023 Topps Pristine BaseballNear Mint$250$250——18
Christy Mathewson #22018 Panini Flawless BaseballPSA 10$250$3——19
Christy Mathewson #72025 Topps Allen & Ginter X Baseball MiniPSA 10$250$3——20
Christy Mathewson #AA-352023 Topps Baseball All AcesPSA 10$245$38——21
Christy Mathewson #271921 W516 2 2 BaseballNear Mint$244$244——22
Christy Mathewson #141994 Upper Deck American Epic BaseballPSA 10$230$1——23
Christy Mathewson #1752025 Panini Select BaseballNear Mint$213$213——24Christy Mathewson #402025 Panini Impeccable Baseball Cooperstown LogoNear Mint$200$200——25Christy Mathewson #101935 Schutter Johnson BaseballNear Mint$190$190——26
Christy Mathewson #302021 Panini Flawless BaseballNear Mint$180$180——27
Christy Mathewson #241961 Golden Press BaseballPSA 10$161$11——28
Christy Mathewson #6662023 Topps Living BaseballPSA 10$154$7——29
Christy Mathewson #762025 Topps Gilded Collection BaseballPSA 10$146$118——31
Christy Mathewson #102024 Panini Flawless Baseball Triple CrownNear Mint$143$143——32
Christy Mathewson #1812024 Topps Triple Threads BaseballNear Mint$114$114——33
Christy Mathewson #31980 Perez Steele HOF Postcard BaseballPSA 10$108$7——34
Christy Mathewson #172020 Panini Diamond Kings BaseballPSA 10$103$21——35
Christy Mathewson #242019 Panini Flawless BaseballPSA 9$103$8——36
Christy Mathewson #71999 Upper Deck Century Legends BaseballNear Mint$100$100——37
Christy Mathewson #212022 Panini Flawless BaseballPSA 8$100$63——38
Christy Mathewson #AT-272024 Topps Update Baseball Autumn TalesNear Mint$99$99——39
Christy Mathewson #LPR-522009 Topps Baseball Legends Commemorative PatchesPSA 7$88$26——40
Christy Mathewson #571991 Conlon Collection BaseballPSA 10$85$1——41
Christy Mathewson #1942023 Stadium Club BaseballNear Mint$85$85——42
Christy Mathewson #31983 Donruss Hall Of Fame Heroes BaseballPSA 10$82$1——43
Christy Mathewson #562024 Topps Gilded Collection BaseballPSA 10$81$80——44
Christy Mathewson #182011 Topps Gypsy Queen BaseballNear Mint$75$75——45
Christy Mathewson #732024 Panini National Treasures BaseballNear Mint$73$73——46
Christy Mathewson #802010 Topps BaseballPSA 10$72$8——47
Christy Mathewson #712024 Panini Flawless BaseballNear Mint$65$65——48
Christy Mathewson #51980 Laughlin 300400500 BaseballPSA 9$60$4——49
Christy Mathewson #92025 Topps Tier One BaseballPSA 10$60$43——50
Christy Mathewson #1022011 Topps BaseballPSA 10$59$7——51
Christy Mathewson #792025 Panini Flawless BaseballNear Mint$55$55——52
Christy Mathewson #681950 R423 BaseballNear Mint$50$50——53
Christy Mathewson #1692024 Topps Stadium Club BaseballNear Mint$50$50——54
Christy Mathewson #891993 Upper Deck All Time Heroes BaseballPSA 10$50$2——55
Christy Mathewson #482001 Fleer Greats BaseballPSA 10$50$0——56
Christy Mathewson #BT82001 Topps Before Topps BaseballPSA 10$50$2——57
Christy Mathewson #182001 Upper Deck Hall of Famers BaseballPSA 10$47$1——58
Christy Mathewson #LGCB-CZM2009 Topps Baseball Legends of the Game Career BestPSA 10$43$2——59
Christy Mathewson #662025 Panini National Treasures BaseballPSA 10$42$18——60
Christy Mathewson #122002 SP Legendary Cuts BaseballPSA 9.5$42$2——61
Christy Mathewson #432023 Topps Gilded Collection BaseballNear Mint$41$41——62
Christy Mathewson #251972 Laughlin Great Feats BaseballPSA 9$40$10——63
Christy Mathewson #9101993 Conlon Collection BaseballPSA 9$40$1——64
Christy Mathewson #3311993 Conlon Collection BaseballPSA 9$40$2——65
Christy Mathewson #4082010 Topps Heritage BaseballPSA 9$40$2——66
Christy Mathewson #992010 Topps 206 BaseballNear Mint$40$40——67
Christy Mathewson #42012 Panini Cooperstown BaseballPSA 10$38$2——68
Christy Mathewson #GOG-232024 Topps Baseball Grand GamersPSA 10$35$15——69
Christy Mathewson #WC-382025 Topps Allen & Ginter Baseball Wicked CurvesPSA 10$34$1——70
Christy Mathewson #DGDC-642022 Topps Update Baseball Diamond Greats Die-CutsPSA 10$33$12——71
Christy Mathewson #1482021 Topps Archives BaseballPSA 10$32$20——72
Christy Mathewson #292019 Stadium Club BaseballPSA 10$32$24——73
Christy Mathewson #1652019 Topps Archives BaseballPSA 10$31$14——74
Christy Mathewson #1041994 Upper Deck All-Time Heroes BaseballPSA 10$30$1——75
Christy Mathewson #32022 Topps Brooklyn Collection BaseballNear Mint$29$29——76
Christy Mathewson #SS-52023 Topps Allen & Ginter Baseball Spotless SpansPSA 10$27$1——77
Christy Mathewson #31972 Fleer Famous Feats BaseballPSA 9$25$4——78
Christy Mathewson (Legend Variation) #US1022022 Topps Update BaseballPSA 10$25$3——79
Christy Mathewson #32014 Panini Hall of Fame 75th Year Anniversary Baseball CrusadesPSA 9$25$8——80Christy Mathewson #LM-832010 Topps Update MLB Logoman PatchNear Mint$25$25——81
Christy Mathewson #UH1862009 Topps Updates & Highlights BaseballPSA 10$23$6——82
Christy Mathewson #552001 Upper Deck Legends of New York BaseballModerately Played$19$2——83
Christy Mathewson #1292025 Panini Prizm BaseballNear Mint$19$19——84
Christy Mathewson #152010 Topps Tribute BaseballNear Mint$18$18——85
Christy Mathewson (Portrait) #NNO1909 T206 BaseballPSA 5.5$17$16——86
Christy Mathewson #RC-CM2023 Topps Allen & Ginter Baseball Rip CardsNear Mint$15$15——87
Christy Mathewson #142025 Panini Three and Two Baseball Timeless MomentsNear Mint$15$15——88
Christy Mathewson #912025 Panini Impeccable BaseballNear Mint$15$15——89
Christy Mathewson #162021 Panini Diamond Kings BaseballNear Mint$15$15——90
Christy Mathewson #1642001 Upper Deck Legends of New York BaseballNear Mint$14$14——91
Christy Mathewson #42011 Topps Marquee BaseballNear Mint$12$12——92Christy Mathewson #GR-112009 Topps Baseball Legends Chrome Gold RefractorNear Mint$11$11——93
Christy Mathewson #122014 Panini Golden Age BaseballNear Mint$10$10——94
Christy Mathewson #GS-42019 Topps 150 Years of Professional Baseball - Greatest SeasonsNear Mint$10$10——95
Christy Mathewson #1952009 Topps BaseballNear Mint$9$9——96
Christy Mathewson #22009 Topps Tribute BaseballNear Mint$8$8——97
Christy Mathewson #392025 Panini Three and Two BaseballNear Mint$8$8——98
Christy Mathewson #1812006 Sp Legendary Cuts BaseballNear Mint$8$8——99
Christy Mathewson #42013 Panini Cooperstown BaseballNear Mint$5$5——100
Christy Mathewson #1662007 Sp Legendary Cuts BaseballNear Mint$5$5——Sets with Christy Mathewson cards
Christy Mathewson appears in 237 sets. Open one for the most valuable cards in it.
- 2006 Upper Deck Baseball First Class Legends20 cards
- 2009 Topps Baseball Legendary Letters Commemorative Patch9 cards
- 2001 Upper Deck Legends of New York Baseball8 cards
- 2009 Topps Updates & Highlights Baseball Legends of the Game Team Letter Name Patch8 cards
- 2009 Topps Baseball Legends of the Game Nickname Letter Patch6 cards
- 2001 Upper Deck Legends Of Ny Baseball5 cards
- 1909 T206 Baseball3 cards
- 1986 Conlon Baseball3 cards
- 1993 Conlon Collection Baseball3 cards
- 1994 Upper Deck All-Time Heroes Baseball3 cards
- 2001 Upper Deck Hall of Famers Baseball2 cards
- 2007 Sp Legendary Cuts Baseball2 cards
- 2009 Topps 206 Baseball2 cards
- 2009 Topps Updates & Highlights Baseball2 cards
- 2010 Topps National Chicle Baseball2 cards
- 2012 Panini Cooperstown Baseball2 cards
- 2018 Panini Flawless Baseball2 cards
- 2019 Topps 150 Years of Professional Baseball - Greatest Moments2 cards
- 2024 Panini Flawless Baseball Triple Crown2 cards
- 1904 Allegheny Card Company Baseball1 card
- 1911 Turkey Red Cabinets T3 & T9 Baseball1 card
- 1914 Cracker Jack Baseball1 card
- 1915 Cracker Jack Baseball1 card
- 1919-21 W514 Baseball1 card
- 1920 W516 1 Baseball1 card
- 1921 W516 2 2 Baseball1 card
- 1935 Schutter Johnson Baseball1 card
- 1940 Play Ball Baseball1 card
- 1948 Topps Magic Photo Baseball Hall Of Fame1 card
- 1950 R423 Baseball1 card
- 1960 Fleer Baseball1 card
- 1960 Fleer Baseball Greats1 card
- 1961 Fleer Baseball1 card
- 1961 Fleer Baseball Greats1 card
- 1961 Golden Press Baseball1 card
- 1963 Bazooka All Time Greats Baseball1 card
- 1967 Topps Venezuelan Baseball1 card
- 1967 Venezuela Topps Baseball1 card
- 1972 Fleer Famous Feats Baseball1 card
- 1972 Laughlin Great Feats Baseball1 card