Most Valuable Cy Young Cards
Every Cy Young card in the catalog, ranked by market value, with live prices, trends and real sold comps.
Cy Young Cards275
Market Value (PSA 10)$15,968
Market Value (Raw NM)$12,198
Avg 30d Change+3.10%
Top CardCy Young (Bare Hand)
#CardConditionPriceRaw Price30d %RarityTrend
1Cy Young (Bare Hand) #NNOv1909 T206 BaseballSGC 5$8,500———2
Cy Young #T1CS-CY2023 Topps Tier One Baseball Cut SignaturesNear Mint$6,393$6,393——3
Cy Young #61963 Bazooka All Time Greats BaseballPSA 10$5,264$31——4
Cy Young #471960 Fleer BaseballPSA 10$3,827$20——5
Cy Young #CS-CY2024 Topps Allen & Ginter Cut Signature BaseballNear Mint$2,851$2,851——6
Cy Young #1531961 Fleer BaseballPSA 10$2,609$22——7
Cy Young (Portrait) #NNO1909 T206 BaseballPSA 1.5$2,500$1——8
Cy Young #331961 Golden Press BaseballPSA 10$2,091$11——9
Cy Young #1501967 Venezuela Topps BaseballNear Mint$1,795$1,795——10
Cy Young #2512025 Topps Chrome Platinum BaseballPSA 10$331$100——11
Cy Young #3542008 Topps Allen & Ginter BaseballNear Mint$250$250——12
Cy Young #121970 Rold Gold Pretzels BaseballPSA 10$180$10——13
Cy Young #341996 Danbury Mint 22kt Gold BaseballPSA 10$160$5——14
Cy Young #4722022 Topps Heritage BaseballPSA 10$121$30——15
Cy Young #1802002 Topps 206 BaseballPSA 10$120$2——16
Cy Young #3482025 Topps Allen & Ginter BaseballPSA 10$106$70——17Cy Young #471960 Fleer Baseball GreatsPSA 8$103$20——18
Cy Young #CY1999 SP Signature Edition Baseball Legendary CutsPSA 8$103$40——19
Cy Young #441985 Woolworth BaseballPSA 9$90$2——20
Cy Young #191975 Fleer Pioneers Of BaseballPSA 10$77$2——21Cy Young #1531961 Fleer Baseball GreatsCGC 8$75———22
Cy Young #131980 Perez Steele HOF Postcard BaseballPSA 10$67$6——23
Cy Young #422026 Topps Tribute BaseballNear Mint$65$65——24
Cy Young #16K1948 Topps Magic Photo Baseball Hall Of FameNear Mint$64$64——25
Cy Young #72001 Fleer Greats Of The Game Retrospection Collection BaseballPSA 10$60$2——26
Cy Young #792010 Topps Tribute BaseballPSA 10$54$5——27
Cy Young #3062002 Topps 206 BaseballPSA 10$53$2——28
Cy Young #542001 Upper Deck Hall of Famers BaseballPSA 10$53$1——29
Cy Young #862001 Upper Deck Hall of Famers BaseballPSA 10$48$1——30
Cy Young #72014 Panini Hall of Fame 75th Year Anniversary Baseball Diamond KingsNear Mint$45$45——31
Cy Young #42002 Fleer Greats BaseballPSA 10$45$2——32
Cy Young #111972 Fleer Famous Feats BaseballPSA 9$45$4——33
Cy Young #442010 Topps Tribute BaseballPSA 7$41$14——34
Cy Young #131980 Baseball ImmortalsPSA 9$40$2——35
Cy Young #21995 Upper Deck Sonic Heroes Of BaseballPSA 10$40$2——36
Cy Young #271983 Donruss Hall Of Fame Heroes BaseballPSA 10$40$1——37
Cy Young #1051994 Upper Deck All-Time Heroes BaseballPSA 10$39$2——38
Cy Young #LGCB-CY2009 Topps Baseball Legends of the Game Career BestPSA 10$38$1——39
Cy Young #1062011 Topps Lineage BaseballPSA 10$36$2——40
Cy Young #1642011 Topps Gypsy Queen BaseballPSA 10$36$3——41
Cy Young #2912010 Topps National Chicle BaseballPSA 10$35$6——42
Cy Young #VLC-272010 Topps Vintage Legends Collection BaseballPSA 10$35$2——43
Cy Young #232001 Upper Deck Hall of Famers BaseballTHE FINAL AUTHORITY 10$33$1——44
Cy Young #SS-62023 Topps Allen & Ginter Baseball Spotless SpansPSA 10$32$1——45
Cy Young #PAG-142022 Topps Allen & Ginter Baseball Pitching a GemPSA 10$31$2——46
Cy Young #311984 Donruss Champions BaseballPSA 10$30$2——47
Cy Young #2402010 Topps National Chicle BaseballPSA 10$30$1——48
Cy Young #602009 Topps BaseballPSA 10$29$9——49
Cy Young #1291993 Upper Deck All Time Heroes BaseballPSA 10$27$3——50
Cy Young #62001 Fleer Greats BaseballPSA 10$27$2——51
Cy Young #1212021 Topps Archives BaseballNear Mint$25$25——52
Cy Young #122001 Fleer Boston Red Sox 100th Anniversary BaseballPSA 10$25$2——53
Cy Young #502010 Topps BaseballPSA 9$25$8——54
Cy Young #172014 Panini Golden Age Baseball Darby Chocolate 3-card Panel Box ToppersNear Mint$24$24——55
Cy Young #42002 Fleer Greats of the Game BaseballPSA 9$22$2——56
Cy Young #UH1982009 Topps Updates & Highlights BaseballPSA 10$21$10——57
Cy Young #71994 Ted Williams BaseballPSA 10$20$0——58
Cy Young #1001990 Swell Baseball GreatsPSA 10$20$2——59
Cy Young #111980 Laughlin 300400500 BaseballPSA 10$19$1——60
Cy Young #232023 Panini National Treasures Baseball Treasured StatsNear Mint$12$12——61
Cy Young #22011 Topps Tribute BaseballNear Mint$12$12——62
Cy Young #SB-162023 Topps Archives Baseball 1997 Season's BestNear Mint$12$12——63
Cy Young #BT32001 Topps Before Topps BaseballPSA 9$11$2——64Cy Young #72014 Panini Hall of Fame 75th Year Anniversary BaseballNear Mint$10$10——65
Cy Young #1432009 Topps T206 BaseballNear Mint$10$10——66
Cy Young #1222010 Topps 206 BaseballNear Mint$9$9——67
Cy Young #291972 Laughlin Great Feats BaseballNear Mint$9$9——68
Cy Young #182010 Topps Baseball 1951 Topps Blue BacksNear Mint$8$8——69
Cy Young #12014 Panini Golden Age BaseballNear Mint$8$8——70
Cy Young #4771973 O Pee Chee BaseballNear Mint$7$7——71Cy Young #261963 Gad Fun Cards BaseballNear Mint$6$6——72
Cy Young #492013 Panini Cooperstown Baseball LumberjacksNear Mint$5$5——73
Cy Young #1822006 Sp Legendary Cuts BaseballNear Mint$5$5——74
Cy Young #502013 Panini Cooperstown Baseball LumberjacksNear Mint$5$5——75
Cy Young #141999 Upper Deck Century Legends BaseballNear Mint$4$4——76
Cy Young #22013 Panini Cooperstown BaseballNear Mint$4$4——77
Cy Young #512013 Panini Cooperstown Baseball LumberjacksNear Mint$4$4——78
Cy Young #GW32002 Upper Deck Piece of History Baseball 300 Game WinnersNear Mint$4$40%—79
Cy Young #12013 Panini Cooperstown Baseball Numbers GameNear Mint$4$4——80Cy Young #1511994 Upper Deck Diamond Collection BaseballNear Mint$4$4——81
Cy Young #CS-CY2020 Topps Dynasty Baseball Cut SignaturesNear Mint$3$3——82
Cy Young #301980 Laughlin Famous Feats BaseballNear Mint$3$3——83
Cy Young #152005 Sp Legendary Cuts BaseballNear Mint$3$3——84
Cy Young #622010 Topps Triple Threads BaseballNear Mint$2$2——85
Cy Young #G92001 Upper Deck Hall Of Famers Gallery BaseballNear Mint$2$2——86
Cy Young #PC92010 Topps Baseball Legends Platinum ChromeNear Mint$2$2——87
Cy Young #152005 Upper Deck Sweet Spot Classic BaseballNear Mint$2$2——88
Cy Young #172014 Panini Golden Age Darby Chocolate BaseballNear Mint$2$2——89
Cy Young #202012 Panini Cooperstown Baseball Famous MomentsNear Mint$2$2——90
Cy Young #LGU12009 Topps Legends Of The Game BaseballNear Mint$2$2——91
Cy Young #12012 Panini Cooperstown Baseball Famous MomentsNear Mint$2$2——92
Cy Young #BT32001 Topps Baseball Before There Was ToppsNear Mint$2$20%—93
Cy Young #BT32001 Topps Chrome Baseball Before there was ToppsNear Mint$2$2+8.17%—94
Cy Young #1432009 Topps 206 BaseballNear Mint$2$2——95
Cy Young #242001 Upper Deck Legends BaseballNear Mint$2$2+7.69%—96
Cy Young #VLC232010 Topps Baseball Vintage Legends CollectionNear Mint$2$2——97
Cy Young #142013 Panini Cooperstown Baseball Numbers GameNear Mint$2$2——98
Cy Young #CR-292026 Onit Athlete Gravity Career 250 BaseballNear Mint$2$2——99
Cy Young #LG12009 Topps Baseball Legends of the GameNear Mint$2$2——100
Cy Young #NNO1987 Hygrade All Time Greats BaseballNear Mint$2$2——Sets with Cy Young cards
Cy Young appears in 240 sets. Open one for the most valuable cards in it.
- 2009 Topps Baseball Legends of the Game Nickname Letter Patch7 cards
- 2009 Topps Updates & Highlights Baseball Legends of the Game Team Letter Name Patch7 cards
- 2009 Topps Baseball Legendary Letters Commemorative Patch5 cards
- 1909 T206 Baseball3 cards
- 1994 Upper Deck All-Time Heroes Baseball3 cards
- 2001 Upper Deck Hall of Famers Baseball3 cards
- 2010 Topps National Chicle Baseball3 cards
- 2013 Panini Cooperstown Baseball Lumberjacks3 cards
- 2002 Topps 206 Baseball2 cards
- 2007 Sp Legendary Cuts Baseball2 cards
- 2009 Topps 206 Baseball2 cards
- 2009 Topps Updates & Highlights Baseball2 cards
- 2010 Topps Tribute Baseball2 cards
- 2012 Panini Cooperstown Baseball Famous Moments2 cards
- 2013 Panini Cooperstown Baseball Numbers Game2 cards
- 2025 Topps Diamond Icons Immortal Cut Signature Baseball2 cards
- 2026 Onit Athlete Gravity Career 250 Baseball2 cards
- 1911 Turkey Red Cabinets T3 & T9 Baseball1 card
- 1948 Topps Magic Photo Baseball Hall Of Fame1 card
- 1960 Fleer Baseball1 card
- 1960 Fleer Baseball Greats1 card
- 1961 Fleer Baseball1 card
- 1961 Fleer Baseball Greats1 card
- 1961 Golden Press Baseball1 card
- 1963 Bazooka All Time Greats Baseball1 card
- 1963 Gad Fun Cards Baseball1 card
- 1967 Topps Venezuelan Baseball1 card
- 1967 Venezuela Topps Baseball1 card
- 1970 Rold Gold Pretzels Baseball1 card
- 1972 Fleer Famous Feats Baseball1 card
- 1972 Laughlin Great Feats Baseball1 card
- 1973 O Pee Chee Baseball1 card
- 1975 Fleer Pioneers Of Baseball1 card
- 1980 Baseball Immortals1 card
- 1980 Laughlin 300400500 Baseball1 card
- 1980 Laughlin Famous Feats Baseball1 card
- 1980 Perez Steele HOF Postcard Baseball1 card
- 1982 Tcma Greatest Pitchers Baseball1 card
- 1983 Cramer Legends Baseball1 card
- 1983 Donruss Hall Of Fame Heroes Baseball1 card