Most Valuable Don Mattingly Cards
Every Don Mattingly card in the catalog, ranked by market value, with live prices, trends and real sold comps.
Don Mattingly Cards1000
Market Value (PSA 10)$40,045
Market Value (Raw NM)$18,720
Avg 30d Change+11.12%
Top CardDon Mattingly
#CardConditionPriceRaw Price30d %RarityTrend
1Don Mattingly #81984 O-Pee-Chee BaseballPSA 10$3,924$40——2
Don Mattingly #BKA-DM2024 Topps Tier One Bat Knob Autograph BaseballNear Mint$2,000$2,000——3
Don Mattingly #1801986 Topps Tiffany BaseballPSA 10$1,832$31——4
Don Mattingly #6651985 Topps Tiffany BaseballPSA 10$1,472$52——5
Don Mattingly #1311984 Fleer BaseballPSA 10$1,300$15——6
Don Mattingly #981993 Finest BaseballPSA 10$1,272$7——7
Don Mattingly #IVA-DMA2026 Topps Chrome Black Baseball Ivory AutographsNear Mint$1,175$1,175——8
Don Mattingly #CLA-DM2025 Topps Chrome Update Legends Autograph BaseballPSA 10$1,000$605——9
Don Mattingly #4792023 Topps Chrome Platinum Anniversary BaseballNear Mint$900$900——10
Don Mattingly #1901990 Donruss Aqueous Test BaseballPSA 9$852———11
Don Mattingly #7121986 Topps Tiffany BaseballPSA 10$824$10——12
Don Mattingly #2081993 Pacific Spanish BaseballPSA 10$796$21——13
Don Mattingly #75YA-DM2026 Topps Baseball 75 Years of Topps Die-Cut AutographsPSA 10$682$363——14
Don Mattingly #HK-DMA2023 Topps Luminaries Baseball Hit Kings AutographsNear Mint$600$600——15
Don Mattingly #ACC-DMA2025 Topps Diamond Icons Chrome Autograph BaseballPSA 10$559$199——16
Don Mattingly #93A-DM2024 Topps Finest Protoypes Autograph BaseballPSA 10$535$335——17
Don Mattingly #T1LL-DMA2024 Topps Tier One Baseball Limited LumberNear Mint$500$500——18
Don Mattingly #DM2014 Topps Heritage Real One Autographs BaseballPSA 10$451$259——19
Don Mattingly #1021996 Score Dugout Collection BaseballPSA 10$428$10——20
Don Mattingly #90BLA-DM2024 Topps Archives Baseball 1990 Topps Batting Leaders AutographsPSA 10$419$111——21
Don Mattingly #90AU-DM2025 Topps 1990 Autograph BaseballPSA 10$411$225——22
Don Mattingly #90CA-DM2025 Topps 1990 Chrome Autograph BaseballPSA 10$400$140——23
Don Mattingly #52001 Fleer Platinum Baseball 20th Anniversary ReprintsPSA 10$389$5——24
Don Mattingly #72012 Panini Cooperstown Baseball Famous Moments SignaturesPSA 10$380$118——25
Don Mattingly #21990 Score Natwest Yankees BaseballPSA 10$376$8——26
Don Mattingly #5001987 Topps Tiffany BaseballPSA 10$366$12——27
Don Mattingly #BC2-DM2018 Topps Brooklyn Collection Autographs BaseballPSA 10$355$225——28
Don Mattingly #2951985 Donruss BaseballPSA 10$320$5——29
Don Mattingly #872024 Donruss BaseballNear Mint$313$313——30
Don Mattingly #181986 Quaker Oats BaseballPSA 10$305$2——31
Don Mattingly #AC-DMA2024 Topps Diamond Icons Baseball AutographsNear Mint$305$305——32
Don Mattingly #231993 Pinnacle BaseballPSA 10$305$1——33
Don Mattingly #841996 Pinnacle Starburst BaseballPSA 10$301$15——34
Don Mattingly #71985 Donruss BaseballAGS 10$300$2——35
Don Mattingly #US532026 Topps Update Golden Mirror Legend Variation BaseballNear Mint$300$300——36
Don Mattingly #CV732013 Panini Pinnacle Clear Vision BaseballNear Mint$300$300——37Don Mattingly #ARRCR-DM2020 Topps Chrome Baseball Retro Rookie Relic Autograph RefractorNear Mint$300$300——38Don Mattingly #RIP-862014 Topps Allen & Ginter Baseball Rip CardsNear Mint$300$300——39Don Mattingly #CCR-132014 Topps Museum Collection Baseball Canvas CollectionNear Mint$300$300——40
Don Mattingly #1331985 Fleer BaseballPSA 10$271$3——41
Don Mattingly #2291987 O Pee Chee BaseballPSA 10$270$2——42
Don Mattingly #FSS-DM2024 Topps Five Star Baseball SignaturesPSA 10$269$73——43
Don Mattingly #3101985 Topps Stickers BaseballPSA 10$268$3——44
Don Mattingly #251994 Sp Holoview Red BaseballPSA 10$267$51——45
Don Mattingly #2001995 Stadium Club Baseball Virtual RealityPSA 10$258$2——46Don Mattingly #86A-DM2021 Topps 1986 Topps Baseball AutographsNear Mint$252$252——47
Don Mattingly #TN131993 Upper Deck Baseball Then and NowPSA 10$250$2——48
Don Mattingly #LG-152023 Topps Baseball Legends of the GameNear Mint$250$250——49
Don Mattingly #FFADM2012 Topps Archives Fan Favorite Autographs BaseballNear Mint$250$250——50
Don Mattingly #1762008 Topps Sterling BaseballNear Mint$250$250——51
Don Mattingly #HLAU-DM2024 Topps Update Heavy Lumber Autograph BaseballNear Mint$248$248——52
Don Mattingly #89ASA-DMA2024 Topps 1989 All Star Autograph BaseballPSA 10$247$150——53
Don Mattingly #TA-DM2024 Topps Tribute Baseball AutographsPSA 10$242$116——54
Don Mattingly #AC-DM2025 Topps Diamond Icons Autograph BaseballNear Mint$240$240——55
Don Mattingly #141990 King B Discs BaseballPSA 10$234$5——56
Don Mattingly #87BA-DM2022 Topps 1987 Topps Baseball AutographsPSA 10$232$140——57
Don Mattingly #SCCA-DM2024 Stadium Club Baseball Chrome AutographsNear Mint$231$231——58
Don Mattingly #1541996 Upper Deck BaseballPSA 10$230$2——59
Don Mattingly #FSA-DM2022 Topps Five Star Baseball AutographsPSA 10$229$166——60
Don Mattingly #PTGA-DM2024 Topps Tribute Baseball Pillars Of The Game AutographsNear Mint$226$226——61
Don Mattingly #81996 Score Dugout Collection BaseballPSA 10$218$7——62
Don Mattingly #3921994 Finest BaseballPSA 9$218$38——63
Don Mattingly #502004 Playoff Prime Cuts BaseballPSA 10$216$15——64
Don Mattingly #721986 Fleer Star Stickers BaseballPSA 10$213$2——65
Don Mattingly #M-21996 Pacific Crown Milestones BaseballPSA 10$213$4——66
Don Mattingly #11987 Fleer All Stars BaseballPSA 10$210$1——67
Don Mattingly #201985 Fleer Limited Edition BaseballPSA 10$209$2——68
Don Mattingly #1921996 Pinnacle Starburst BaseballPSA 10$203$18——69
Don Mattingly #91994 Donruss Triple Play BaseballPSA 10$200———70
Don Mattingly #1521988 Classic Travel Update I BaseballPSA 10$200$1——71
Don Mattingly #792018 Topps Triple Threads BaseballNear Mint$200$200——72Don Mattingly #452014 Topps Allen & Ginter Baseball Mini MetalNear Mint$200$200——73
Don Mattingly #2961986 O Pee Chee Stickers BaseballPSA 10$192$7——74
Don Mattingly #3001988 O-Pee-Chee BaseballPSA 10$190$1——75
Don Mattingly #1001991 Topps Tiffany BaseballPSA 10$180$13——76
Don Mattingly #251989 Fleer League Leaders BaseballPSA 10$180$1——77
Don Mattingly #231994 Score BaseballPSA 10$177$2——78
Don Mattingly #GG-DM2024 Topps Five Star Golden Graph BaseballNear Mint$175$175——79
Don Mattingly #88ASA-DM2023 Topps 1988 Topps Baseball All-Star AutographsNear Mint$173$173——80
Don Mattingly #PC-222004 Playoff Honors Players Collection Jersey BaseballPSA 10$173$48——81
Don Mattingly #FA-DM2018 Topps Gold Label Baseball Framed AutographsNear Mint$170$170——82
Don Mattingly #51986 True Value Perforated BaseballPSA 10$169———83
Don Mattingly #2441993 Ultra BaseballPSA 10$169$1——84
Don Mattingly #11988 Score Glossy BaseballPSA 10$165$8——85
Don Mattingly #251994 Sp Holoview Blue BaseballPSA 10$163$2——86
Don Mattingly #271985 Topps All Star Glossy Set Of 40 BaseballPSA 10$162$1——87
Don Mattingly #HL-562023 Topps Update Baseball Heavy LumberPSA 10$160$40——88
Don Mattingly #3001988 Topps Tiffany BaseballPSA 10$160$8——89
Don Mattingly #1772008 Topps Sterling BaseballPSA 10$159$20——90
Don Mattingly #DIA-DM2022 Topps Diamond Icons Baseball Diamond Icons AutographsNear Mint$158$158——91
Don Mattingly #241990 Topps Mini League Leaders BaseballPSA 10$154$2——92Don Mattingly #68E2024 Topps Spotlight Autograph BaseballNear Mint$154$154——93
Don Mattingly #DCFA-DM2022 Topps Definitive Collection Baseball Framed AutographsNear Mint$153$153——94
Don Mattingly #251988 Star Gold Edition BaseballPSA 10$153$1——95
Don Mattingly #82024 Topps Black & White BaseballNear Mint$151$151——96
Don Mattingly #301988 Star Gold Edition BaseballPSA 10$150$1——97
Don Mattingly #462021 Topps Project70 BaseballNear Mint$150$150——98
Don Mattingly #6271986 Fleer BaseballPSA 10$150$2——99
Don Mattingly #392024 Topps Throwback Thursday BaseballNear Mint$150$150——100
Don Mattingly #1761989 Bowman Tiffany BaseballPSA 10$149$4——Sets with Don Mattingly cards
Don Mattingly appears in 875 sets. Open one for the most valuable cards in it.
- 1988 Star Platinum Edition Baseball9 cards
- 1990 Star Silver Edition Baseball9 cards
- 1988 Star Gold Edition Baseball8 cards
- 1990 Star Gold Edition Baseball8 cards
- 1990 Star Nova Edition Baseball8 cards
- 2024 Topps Spotlight Autograph Baseball7 cards
- 1990 Star Platinum Edition Baseball6 cards
- 2008 Upper Deck Baseball Yankee Stadium Legacy6 cards
- 1986 Broder Baseball5 cards
- 1988 Cmc Don Mattingly Baseball Card Kit5 cards
- 2016 Topps Dynasty Baseball Autographed Dual Relic Greats5 cards
- 2021 Topps Project70 Baseball4 cards
- 1987 Indiana Blue Sox Baseball3 cards
- 1988 Action Superstars Baseball3 cards
- 2002 Donruss Originals Baseball Recollection Collection Notation3 cards
- 2010 Topps Cards Your Mother Threw Out Baseball3 cards
- 2021 Topps Dynasty Baseball Autographed Dual Relic3 cards
- 1985 Donruss Baseball2 cards
- 1986 Topps Tiffany Baseball2 cards
- 1986 True Value Perforated Baseball2 cards
- 1988 Action Superstars 38 Baseball2 cards
- 1988 Score Glossy Baseball2 cards
- 1988 Topps Tiffany Baseball2 cards
- 1989 Golden Superstars Baseball2 cards
- 1989 Major League Superstars Baseball2 cards
- 1989 Pacific Cards & Comics Action Superstars Baseball2 cards
- 1989 Topps Stickercards Blank Back Baseball2 cards
- 1990 Fleer Canadian Baseball2 cards
- 1991 Playball USA Baseball2 cards
- 1993 Ultra Baseball2 cards
- 1994 Donruss Triple Play Baseball2 cards
- 1995 Score Hall Of Gold Baseball2 cards
- 1996 Pinnacle Starburst Baseball2 cards
- 1996 Score Dugout Collection Baseball2 cards
- 2005 Donruss Baseball Recollection Collection Autographs2 cards
- 2007 Upper Deck Sweet Spot Classic Classic Memorabilia Baseball2 cards
- 2008 Topps Sterling Baseball2 cards
- 2010 Topps Sterling Baseball Legendary Leather Five Relic Autographs2 cards
- 2010 Topps Sterling Baseball Legendary Leather Quad Relic Autographs2 cards
- 2010 Topps Sterling Baseball Legendary Leather Relics Quad2 cards