Most Valuable Gary Carter Cards
Every Gary Carter card in the catalog, ranked by market value, with live prices, trends and real sold comps.
Gary Carter Cards1000
Market Value (PSA 10)$31,825
Market Value (Raw NM)$8,482
Avg 30d Change+2.19%
Top CardGary Carter
#CardConditionPriceRaw Price30d %RarityTrend
1Gary Carter #4411976 O-Pee-Chee BaseballPSA 10$3,363$33——2
Gary Carter #5201979 Topps BaseballPSA 10$2,125$2——3
Gary Carter #4411976 Topps BaseballPSA 10$1,755$7——4
Gary Carter #451977 O-Pee-Chee BaseballPSA 10$1,284$16——5
Gary Carter #2951977 Topps BaseballPSA 10$950$2——6
Gary Carter #1201978 Topps BaseballPSA 10$856$2——7
Gary Carter #4822025 Topps Chrome Platinum BaseballPSA 10$841$175——8
Gary Carter #91987 Topps All Star 22 BaseballPSA 10$610$2——9
Gary Carter #3101991 Topps Desert Shield BaseballPSA 10$610$12——10
Gary Carter #CSR-GC2026 Topps Tier One Baseball Cut Signature RelicsNear Mint$600$600——11
Gary Carter #LC-192004 Donruss Leather & Lumber Cuts BaseballPSA 10$584$46——12
Gary Carter #371980 Topps O Pee Chee BaseballPSA 10$556$6——13
Gary Carter #371980 O-Pee-Chee BaseballPSA 10$549$6——14
Gary Carter #2301985 Topps Mini BaseballPSA 9$545———15
Gary Carter #7301982 Topps BaseballPSA 10$504$250——16
Gary Carter #1461978 Hostess BaseballPSA 10$500$20——17
Gary Carter #6601981 Topps BaseballPSA 10$483$2——18
Gary Carter #4872023 Topps Chrome Platinum Anniversary BaseballNear Mint$400$400——19
Gary Carter #952021 Topps Project 70 BaseballNear Mint$349$349——20
Gary Carter #T1CS-GC2025 Topps Tier One Cut Signature BaseballNear Mint$349$349——21
Gary Carter #1701986 Topps BaseballPSA 10$320$1——22
Gary Carter #621976 Hostess BaseballPSA 9$313$9——23
Gary Carter #1351978 O-Pee-Chee BaseballPSA 10$309$2——24
Gary Carter #1612022 Panini Select BaseballPSA 10$305$85——25
Gary Carter #61981 O-Pee-Chee BaseballPSA 10$302$4——26
Gary Carter #2301985 Topps Tiffany BaseballPSA 10$300$4——27
Gary Carter #932024 Panini Prizm BaseballNear Mint$300$300——28
Gary Carter #3441982 Topps BaseballNear Mint$255$255——29
Gary Carter #701980 Topps BaseballPSA 10$251$2——30
Gary Carter #372025 Topps Gilded Collection BaseballPSA 10$244$59——31
Gary Carter #1642025 Topps Pristine BaseballPSA 10$243$210——32
Gary Carter #S-GC2000 Upper Deck Legends Baseball Legendary SignaturesPSA 10$243$45——33
Gary Carter #551985 Donruss BaseballPSA 10$239$2——34
Gary Carter #1701986 Topps Tiffany BaseballPSA 10$235$5——35Gary Carter #LSB-GC2022 Panini National Treasures Baseball Legendary Signatures BookletsNear Mint$231$231——36
Gary Carter #761986 Fleer BaseballPSA 10$228$1——37
Gary Carter #731981 Fleer Star Stickers BaseballPSA 10$225$2——38
Gary Carter #201984 Topps All Star Glossy Set Of 22 BaseballPSA 10$225$0——39
Gary Carter #7081986 Topps Tiffany BaseballPSA 10$213$5——40
Gary Carter #91985 Topps All Star Glossy Set Of 22 BaseballPSA 10$210$3——41
Gary Carter #2132022 Topps Chrome Platinum Anniversary BaseballNear Mint$200$200——42
Gary Carter #3931984 Topps Tiffany BaseballPSA 10$200$6——43
Gary Carter #4501984 Topps Tiffany BaseballPSA 10$200$9——44
Gary Carter #81996 Danbury Mint 22kt Gold BaseballPSA 10$199$6——45
Gary Carter #2952012 Topps Archives Baseball ReprintsPSA 9$198$26——46
Gary Carter #21987 Fleer All Stars BaseballPSA 10$192$1——47
Gary Carter #451992 O-Pee-Chee BaseballPSA 8$175$3——48
Gary Carter #1452001 Topps Archives Autographs BaseballPSA 9$167$122——49
Gary Carter #6322021 Topps Chrome Platinum Anniversary BaseballPSA 9$165$18——50
Gary Carter #7901990 Topps Tiffany BaseballPSA 10$164$3——51
Gary Carter #231986 Fleer Star Stickers BaseballPSA 10$160$1——52
Gary Carter #682011 Topps Gypsy Queen BaseballPSA 9$155$2——53
Gary Carter #1831984 Topps Stickers BaseballPSA 10$152$2——54
Gary Carter #RCS-GC2024 Topps Allen & Ginter Relic Cut Signature BaseballNear Mint$150$150——55
Gary Carter #BNR-GC2017 Bowman Chrome National Convention BaseballNear Mint$150$150——56
Gary Carter #22T1992 Topps Traded BaseballPSA 10$150$2——57
Gary Carter #181984 Topps Super BaseballPSA 9$149$3——58
Gary Carter #3202015 Topps Gypsy Queen BaseballNear Mint$130$130——59
Gary Carter #3701983 O-Pee-Chee BaseballPSA 10$128$1——60
Gary Carter #1281982 Topps Stickers BaseballPSA 10$127$1——61
Gary Carter #942024 Panini Impeccable BaseballNear Mint$123$123——62
Gary Carter #1821991 Studio BaseballPSA 10$117$1——63
Gary Carter #3931989 Topps BaseballSGC 10$115$1——64
Gary Carter #U-191992 Panini Donruss Update BaseballPSA 10$115$32——65
Gary Carter #201987 Topps Mini League Leaders BaseballPSA 10$115$1——66
Gary Carter #3441982 O-Pee-Chee BaseballPSA 10$114$1——67
Gary Carter #411977 Hostess BaseballPSA 10$114$3——68
Gary Carter #1032000 Topps Stars BaseballPSA 10$112$2——69
Gary Carter #91987 Ralston Purina BaseballPSA 9$111$2——70
Gary Carter #1561988 Leaf BaseballPSA 10$111$2——71Gary Carter #952021 Topps Project70 BaseballNear Mint$110$110——72
Gary Carter #61990 Kaybee Kings BaseballPSA 10$109$1——73
Gary Carter #7191985 Topps Tiffany BaseballPSA 10$107$1——74
Gary Carter #191982 Squirt BaseballPSA 10$107$2——75
Gary Carter #ASGG-442025 Topps All Star Game Baseball All-Star Game GreatsPSA 10$106$49——76
Gary Carter #662025 Topps Shoebox Treasures BaseballPSA 10$105$43——77
Gary Carter #221987 Topps Stickers BaseballPSA 10$104$2——78
Gary Carter #2301985 O-Pee-Chee BaseballPSA 10$103$3——79
Gary Carter #1912023 Panini Donruss BaseballNear Mint$103$103——80
Gary Carter #5301988 Topps Tiffany BaseballPSA 10$101$2——81
Gary Carter #832024 Topps Spotlight BaseballNear Mint$100$100——82Gary Carter #732022 Panini Immaculate Collection BaseballNear Mint$100$100——83
Gary Carter #41986 Quaker Oats BaseballPSA 10$100$1——84
Gary Carter #54CV-282023 Topps Chrome Platinum Anniversary 1954 City Variation BaseballPSA 10$98$28——85
Gary Carter #1382019 Topps Allen & Ginter BaseballPSA 9$91$40——86
Gary Carter #6492020 Topps BaseballPSA 10$90$3——87
Gary Carter #SMB-GC2001 Upper Deck Legends Of Ny Legendary Bat Autograph BaseballNear Mint$90$90——88
Gary Carter #3241989 O-Pee-Chee BaseballPSA 10$90$2——89
Gary Carter #17T1985 Topps Traded Tiffany BaseballPSA 10$89$10——90
Gary Carter #8451992 Stadium Club BaseballPSA 10$88$1——91
Gary Carter #22013 Topps Archives BaseballPSA 10$88$7——92
Gary Carter #4392002 Topps 206 BaseballPSA 10$87$4——93
Gary Carter #OS-102022 Panini Prizm Baseball Old SchoolPSA 10$86$80——94Gary Carter #SA-GC2013 Topps Supreme BaseballNear Mint$85$85——95Gary Carter #TAR-GC12011 Topps Tribute Baseball Autograph RelicsNear Mint$85$85——96Gary Carter #142012 Playoff Prime Cuts Baseball Souvenir CutsNear Mint$85$85——97
Gary Carter #201987 O Pee Chee BaseballPSA 10$81$1——98
Gary Carter #111987 Boardwalk & BaseballPSA 10$80$1——99Gary Carter #TT-GC2002 Topps Baseball Team Topps Legends AutographsPSA 10$80———100
Gary Carter #2522019 Panini Prizm BaseballPSA 10$80$21——Sets with Gary Carter cards
Gary Carter appears in 874 sets. Open one for the most valuable cards in it.
- 1992 O-Pee-Chee Baseball5 cards
- 1987 Topps Stickers Baseball4 cards
- 2001 Upper Deck Legends of New York Baseball4 cards
- 2001 Upper Deck Legends Of Ny Baseball4 cards
- 2004 Leaf Certified Materials Fabric Of The Game Baseball4 cards
- 2009 Topps Tribute Baseball Autograph Relics4 cards
- 2013 Topps Tribute Baseball Tribute to the Stars Autographs4 cards
- 1985 Fleer Star Stickers Baseball3 cards
- 1989 Topps Baseball3 cards
- 1989 Topps Tiffany Baseball3 cards
- 2002 Donruss Originals Baseball Embossed3 cards
- 2002 Donruss Originals Baseball Embossed Notation3 cards
- 2003 Donruss Baseball Recollection Collection Autographs3 cards
- 2009 Topps Triple Threads Baseball Relic Autographs3 cards
- 2009 Topps Triple Threads Baseball Relics3 cards
- 2010 Topps Baseball Hat Logo Patches3 cards
- 2010 Topps Triple Threads Baseball Autograph Relics3 cards
- 2012 Topps Tribute Baseball Tribute to the Stars Autographs3 cards
- 2021 Topps Espn Once Upon A Time In Queens Baseball3 cards
- 2022 Topps Luminaries Baseball Cut Signatures3 cards
- 1982 O Pee Chee Stickers Baseball2 cards
- 1982 Topps Baseball2 cards
- 1982 Topps Stickers Baseball2 cards
- 1983 O-Pee-Chee Baseball2 cards
- 1983 Topps Baseball2 cards
- 1983 Topps Stickers Baseball2 cards
- 1984 O Pee Chee Stickers Baseball2 cards
- 1984 Topps Baseball2 cards
- 1984 Topps Nestle Baseball2 cards
- 1984 Topps Stickers Baseball2 cards
- 1984 Topps Tiffany Baseball2 cards
- 1985 O Pee Chee Stickers Baseball2 cards
- 1985 Topps Baseball2 cards
- 1985 Topps Stickers Baseball2 cards
- 1985 Topps Tiffany Baseball2 cards
- 1986 Broder Baseball2 cards
- 1986 Topps Baseball2 cards
- 1986 Topps Tiffany Baseball2 cards
- 1987 Topps Baseball2 cards
- 1987 Topps Tiffany Baseball2 cards