Most Valuable Gary Sheffield Cards
Every Gary Sheffield card in the catalog, ranked by market value, with live prices, trends and real sold comps.
Gary Sheffield Cards1000
Market Value (PSA 10)$7,865
Market Value (Raw NM)$6,462
Avg 30d Change+0.08%
Top CardGary Sheffield
#CardConditionPriceRaw Price30d %RarityTrend
1Gary Sheffield #BK-GSE2014 Topps Tier One Baseball Bat KnobsNear Mint$1,638$1,638——2
Gary Sheffield #131989 Upper Deck BaseballPSA 10$505$3——3
Gary Sheffield #PPAR-GS2025 Topps Pristine Pieces Autograph Relics BaseballNear Mint$450$450——4
Gary Sheffield #1912025 Topps Allen & Ginter BaseballPSA 10$449$200——5
Gary Sheffield #441997 Pinnacle Totally Certified BaseballPSA 9.5$431$132——6
Gary Sheffield #261998 Circa Thunder BaseballPSA 10$359$14——7
Gary Sheffield #101989 Score 100 Rising Stars BaseballPSA 10$285$1——8
Gary Sheffield #3431989 Topps Tiffany BaseballPSA 10$285$15——9
Gary Sheffield #51993 Ultra Baseball Ultra All-StarsPSA 10$275$2——10
Gary Sheffield #1091997 Finest Embossed BaseballPSA 10$270$56——11
Gary Sheffield #SS131997 Topps Baseball Sweet StrokesPSA 10$262$3——12
Gary Sheffield #TSAR-GS2025 Topps Sterling Splendor Jumbo Patch Autograph BaseballPSA 9$250$150——13
Gary Sheffield #75D-GS2026 Topps Chrome Baseball 75th Diamond AutographsPSA 10$244$45——14
Gary Sheffield #291998 Topps Tek BaseballPSA 10$200$49——15
Gary Sheffield #1691996 Metal Universe BaseballPSA 10$199$2——16
Gary Sheffield #FMA-GS2025 Topps Finest Moments Autograph BaseballPSA 10$188$40——17
Gary Sheffield #2511999 SkyBox Thunder BaseballNear Mint$168$168——18
Gary Sheffield #722022 Topps Pristine BaseballNear Mint$165$165——19
Gary Sheffield #681991 Topps BaseballPSA 9$163$24——20
Gary Sheffield #PPV-GS2024 Panini Flawless Baseball Prime Patch Autographs (Vertical)Near Mint$159$159——21Gary Sheffield #BNP-GSH2021 Topps Sterling Baseball Bat NameplatesNear Mint$158$158——22
Gary Sheffield #102007 Topps Allen & Ginter Baseball Dick Perez SketchesPSA 9$150$1——23
Gary Sheffield #90BLA-GS2024 Topps Archives Baseball 1990 Topps Batting Leaders AutographsPSA 10$145$45——24
Gary Sheffield #TCC-GS2026 Topps Tribute Baseball Crest CalligraphyPSA 10$128$44——25
Gary Sheffield #AJP-GS2025 Topps Diamond Icons Autographed Jumbo Patch BaseballNear Mint$128$128——26
Gary Sheffield #941997 Topps Chrome BaseballPSA 10$126$6——27
Gary Sheffield #141992 Ultra Baseball All-StarsPSA 10$113$2——28
Gary Sheffield #AC-GSH2024 Topps Brooklyn Collection Baseball AutographsNear Mint$113$113——29
Gary Sheffield #PPAR-GS2024 Topps Pristine Baseball Pieces Autograph RelicPSA 10$112$79——30
Gary Sheffield #2251994 Finest BaseballPSA 10$110$9——31
Gary Sheffield #FI-GS2026 Topps Finest Ink BaseballPSA 10$105$16——32
Gary Sheffield #241990 Topps Toys R US Rookies BaseballPSA 10$104$2——33
Gary Sheffield #901998 Topps Gold Label BaseballPSA 9$100$36——34
Gary Sheffield #602005 Bowman Chrome BaseballNear Mint$100$100——35Gary Sheffield #PG91997 Stadium Club Baseball Pure GoldPSA 6$100$8——36
Gary Sheffield #1711996 Pinnacle Starburst BaseballPSA 10$99$2——37
Gary Sheffield #111996 Pinnacle Baseball SkylinesNear Mint$97$97——38
Gary Sheffield #1571990 Upper Deck BaseballPSA 10$93$1——39
Gary Sheffield #2341992 Upper Deck BaseballPSA 10$92$2——40
Gary Sheffield #1502023 Panini Immaculate BaseballNear Mint$85$85——41
Gary Sheffield #7451992 Upper Deck BaseballPSA 10$83$1——42
Gary Sheffield #MA-GS2023 Topps Allen & Ginter Baseball Framed Mini AutographsPSA 10$82$39——43
Gary Sheffield #181993 Topps Baseball Black GoldPSA 10$81$1——44Gary Sheffield #901995 Topps Baseball Stadium Club First DayPSA 10$80$26——45
Gary Sheffield #ACC-GS2025 Topps Diamond Icons Chrome Autograph BaseballNear Mint$75$75——46
Gary Sheffield #PPR-GS2024 Topps Tier One Prodigious Patch BaseballNear Mint$75$75——47
Gary Sheffield #7181990 Topps Tiffany BaseballPSA 10$74$4——48
Gary Sheffield #T1R-GS2025 Topps Tier One Relic BaseballPSA 10$73$12——49
Gary Sheffield #181993 SP BaseballPSA 10$72$1——50
Gary Sheffield #251989 Score Young Superstars Series 1 BaseballNear Mint$70$70——51
Gary Sheffield #271996 SPx BaseballPSA 10$69$2——52
Gary Sheffield #ASR-GS2005 Topps Baseball All-Star Stitches RelicsPSA 10$67$3——53
Gary Sheffield #582001 Bowman BaseballPSA 10$67$0——54
Gary Sheffield #1211990 Donruss Best Al BaseballPSA 10$67$1——55
Gary Sheffield #LC-142006 Fleer Tradition Lumber Company BaseballPSA 10$66———56
Gary Sheffield #PPA-GS2022 Topps Tier One Baseball Prime Performers AutographsPSA 10$63$13——57Gary Sheffield #SCBA-GSH2025 Stadium Club Baseball Base AutographsNear Mint$60$60——58
Gary Sheffield #87BA-GS2022 Topps 1987 Topps Baseball AutographsPSA 10$60$50——59
Gary Sheffield #GOG-GS2025 Topps Gilded Collection Gallery Of Gold Autograph BaseballNear Mint$60$60——60
Gary Sheffield #781996 Topps Laser BaseballPSA 10$58$1——61
Gary Sheffield #3292023 Topps Allen & Ginter BaseballNear Mint$56$56——62
Gary Sheffield #51T1993 Topps Traded BaseballPSA 10$55$1——63
Gary Sheffield #642023 Panini National Treasures BaseballNear Mint$55$55——64
Gary Sheffield #211996 Zenith BaseballPSA 10$55$1——65
Gary Sheffield #642007 Topps Chrome BaseballPSA 10$54$3——66
Gary Sheffield #2042021 Topps Project 70 BaseballNear Mint$54$54——67
Gary Sheffield #MAT-GS2025 Panini Donruss Retro 1985 Materials BaseballPSA 10$51$40——68
Gary Sheffield #181994 Pinnacle The Naturals BaseballPSA 10$50$1——70
Gary Sheffield #31993 Fleer BaseballPSA 10$50$4——71
Gary Sheffield #61993 Hostess Twinkies BaseballPSA 10$50———72
Gary Sheffield #852002 Donruss Studio BaseballPSA 10$47$7——73
Gary Sheffield #142025 Panini Donruss Milestones BaseballPSA 10$46$30——74
Gary Sheffield #261997 Spx BaseballPSA 9$44$9——75
Gary Sheffield #322000 SPx BaseballNear Mint$43$43——76
Gary Sheffield #AGR-GS2024 Topps Allen & Ginter Relic BaseballPSA 10$40$3——77
Gary Sheffield #7181990 Topps BaseballPSA 10$40$2——78
Gary Sheffield #1091994 Leaf Limited BaseballPSA 9$40$1——79
Gary Sheffield #1091997 Finest BaseballPSA 9$40$34——80
Gary Sheffield #1321995 Emotion BaseballPSA 10$40$1——81
Gary Sheffield #RS-GS12008 Upper Deck Spectrum Retrospectrum Swatches BaseballPSA 10$40$1——82
Gary Sheffield #1332007 Topps BaseballPSA 10$38$17——83
Gary Sheffield #AGRB-GS2023 Topps Allen & Ginter Relics B BaseballPSA 10$37$3——84
Gary Sheffield #6951992 Topps Gold BaseballPSA 10$36$1——85
Gary Sheffield #972021 Topps Archives BaseballNear Mint$36$36——86
Gary Sheffield #201989 Topps Glossy Rookies BaseballPSA 9$36$2——87Gary Sheffield #351997 Bowman's Best BaseballNear Mint$35$35——88
Gary Sheffield #GA-GS12024 Leaf Lumber Grain Assault BaseballNear Mint$35$35——89
Gary Sheffield #GS1998 Sp Authentic Chirography BaseballPSA 9$35$20——90
Gary Sheffield #6402009 Upper Deck BaseballNear Mint$35$35——91
Gary Sheffield #SS-GS2023 Topps Museum Collection Baseball Superstar ShowpiecesNear Mint$35$35——92
Gary Sheffield #SS-GS2023 Topps Museum Collection Superstar Showpieces Autographs BaseballNear Mint$35$35——93Gary Sheffield #B-GS2002 Upper Deck MVP Baseball Game Souvenirs BatNear Mint$34$34——94
Gary Sheffield #1702002 Donruss Originals BaseballPSA 10$34$0——95
Gary Sheffield #1411993 Upper Deck Fun Pack BaseballPSA 10$34$0——96
Gary Sheffield #69T-242023 Topps Archives 1969 Single Player Foil BaseballPSA 10$33$1——97Gary Sheffield #EW91996 Stadium Club Baseball Extreme WinnersPSA 9$33$30——98
Gary Sheffield #1881992 Fleer BaseballPSA 10$31$1——99
Gary Sheffield #581997 Bowman Chrome International BaseballNear Mint$30$30——Sets with Gary Sheffield cards
Gary Sheffield appears in 913 sets. Open one for the most valuable cards in it.
- 2001 SP Authentic Baseball Autographed Buybacks6 cards
- 2002 Upper Deck Diamond Connection Baseball5 cards
- 2013 Topps Tribute Baseball Tribute to the Stars Autographs5 cards
- 2017 Topps Dynasty Baseball Autographed Patches5 cards
- 1997 Collector's Choice Baseball You Crash the Game4 cards
- 1997 SP Baseball Vintage Autographs4 cards
- 1996 Collector's Choice Baseball You Crash the Game3 cards
- 1996 Collector's Choice Baseball You Make the Play3 cards
- 1996 Finest Baseball3 cards
- 1998 Upper Deck Baseball A Piece of the Action3 cards
- 2001 Donruss Baseball Production Line3 cards
- 2002 Donruss Originals Baseball3 cards
- 2005 Donruss Diamond Kings Baseball3 cards
- 2010 Topps Tribute Baseball Autograph Relics3 cards
- 2017 Topps Triple Threads Baseball Single Jumbo Relic3 cards
- 1988 Star Silver Edition Baseball2 cards
- 1992 Upper Deck Baseball2 cards
- 1993 Fleer Baseball2 cards
- 1993 Stadium Club Baseball2 cards
- 1993 Upper Deck Fun Pack Baseball2 cards
- 1995 Pinnacle Baseball2 cards
- 1996 Pinnacle Baseball2 cards
- 1996 Pinnacle Starburst Baseball2 cards
- 1996 Sportflix Baseball2 cards
- 1996 Studio Baseball2 cards
- 1997 Donruss Baseball2 cards
- 1997 Donruss Preferred Baseball2 cards
- 1997 Fleer Baseball2 cards
- 1998 Fleer Tradition Baseball2 cards
- 1998 Fleer Tradition Baseball Classic '632 cards
- 1998 Pacific Online Baseball2 cards
- 2000 UD Ionix Baseball2 cards
- 2000 Upper Deck Black Diamond Baseball2 cards
- 2002 Fleer Platinum Baseball Clubhouse Collection2 cards
- 2002 Fleer Platinum Baseball Clubhouse Collection Memorabilia Combos2 cards
- 2002 Leaf Rookies & Stars Baseball BLC Homers2 cards
- 2003 Topps 205 Baseball2 cards
- 2004 Ultra Baseball2 cards
- 2004 Upper Deck Vintage Baseball2 cards
- 2005 Topps Baseball Hit Parade2 cards