Most Valuable Jay Cutler Cards
Every Jay Cutler card in the catalog, ranked by market value, with live prices, trends and real sold comps.
Jay Cutler Cards557
Market Value (PSA 10)$5,020
Market Value (Raw NM)$17,487
Avg 30d Change+0.12%
Top CardJay Cutler
#CardConditionPriceRaw Price30d %RarityTrend
1Jay Cutler #352012 Panini Prizm FootballNear Mint$12,107$12,107——2
Jay Cutler #702013 Panini Select FootballNear Mint$404$404——3
Jay Cutler #172010 Panini Classics Significant Signatures FootballNear Mint$399$399——4
Jay Cutler #1622006 Panini Donruss Elite FootballPSA 9$306$35——5
Jay Cutler #2222006 Bowman Chrome FootballPSA 10$278$55——6
Jay Cutler #262010 Playoff National Treasures FootballPSA 10$241$44——7
Jay Cutler #192007 Topps Finest FootballPSA 10$170$37——8
Jay Cutler #102013 Panini Prizm Football Monday Night HeroesPSA 10$160$100——9Jay Cutler #142015 Panini National Treasures NFL Captains PatchNear Mint$143$143——10
Jay Cutler #1672016 Panini Prizm FootballPSA 10$135$57——11
Jay Cutler #2292006 Topps Chrome FootballPSA 10$135$77——12
Jay Cutler #62015 Panini Prizm FootballNear Mint$128$128——13
Jay Cutler #92015 Panini Flawless FootballNear Mint$124$124——14
Jay Cutler #1022013 Panini Prizm FootballPSA 10$120$40——15
Jay Cutler #342013 Score FootballNear Mint$120$120——16
Jay Cutler #342013 Panini Score FootballNear Mint$120$120——17
Jay Cutler #172016 Panini Donruss Optic FootballNear Mint$111$111——18
Jay Cutler #AM122014 Panini Prizm Football Air MarshalsPSA 9$106$2——19
Jay Cutler #BC1702007 Bowman Chrome FootballNear Mint$100$100——20Jay Cutler #TA-JC2006 Topps Football Signature SeriesNear Mint$100$100——21
Jay Cutler #2002006 Leaf Certified Materials FootballNear Mint$100$100——22
Jay Cutler #172014 Panini Totally Certified FootballPSA 10$98$23——23
Jay Cutler #TC1022009 Topps Chrome FootballPSA 10$96$4——24
Jay Cutler #1592006 Spx FootballNear Mint$95$95——25
Jay Cutler #112006 Topps Football EA Sports Madden 07PSA 9$89$2——26
Jay Cutler #1522006 Playoff Contenders FootballPSA 10$81$41——27
Jay Cutler #1712009 Topps Magic FootballNear Mint$80$80——28
Jay Cutler #862014 Panini Prizm FootballPSA 10$77$22——29
Jay Cutler #582014 Topps Chrome Mini FootballNear Mint$76$76——30
Jay Cutler #1302013 Topps Chrome FootballPSA 10$70$20——31
Jay Cutler #62014 Panini National Treasures FootballNear Mint$67$67——32
Jay Cutler #512012 Panini Absolute FootballNear Mint$63$63——33
Jay Cutler #NCP-JC2012 Topps NFL Captains PatchPSA 10$61$10——34
Jay Cutler #772015 Topps Chrome FootballPSA 10$60$2——35
Jay Cutler #832017 Panini Contenders Optic FootballNear Mint$59$59——36
Jay Cutler #332016 Panini Playoff FootballNear Mint$56$56——37
Jay Cutler #THC642006 Topps Heritage Football ChromeNear Mint$52$52——38
Jay Cutler #582014 Topps Chrome FootballPSA 10$50$30——39
Jay Cutler #2592016 Panini Select FootballNear Mint$50$50——40
Jay Cutler #102014 Topps Finest FootballNear Mint$50$50——41
Jay Cutler #TC72008 Topps Chrome FootballPSA 9$50$4——42
Jay Cutler #592014 Bowman Chrome FootballPSA 10$50$20——43
Jay Cutler #732014 Panini Crown Royale FootballNear Mint$50$50——44
Jay Cutler #832017 Panini Select FootballNear Mint$49$49——45
Jay Cutler #72012 Topps Chrome FootballPSA 9$49$25——46
Jay Cutler #WM-CU2008 Spx Winning Materials FootballPSA 10$48$3——47
Jay Cutler #1732006 Topps Draft Picks & Prospects FootballPSA 10$45$18——48
Jay Cutler #1412011 Topps Chrome FootballPSA 10$44$3——49
Jay Cutler #352016 Donruss Football Gridiron KingsNear Mint$43$43——50
Jay Cutler #2062006 Ultra FootballNear Mint$42$42——51
Jay Cutler #NFL82006 Topps NFL 8306PSA 10$42$1——52
Jay Cutler #IC-JC2009 Upper Deck Icons NFLPSA 10$42$2——53
Jay Cutler #792016 Panini Unparalleled FootballNear Mint$40$40——54
Jay Cutler #142008 Topps Finest FootballNear Mint$40$40——55
Jay Cutler #22015 Panini National Treasures FootballNear Mint$40$40——56
Jay Cutler #502017 Panini National Treasures FootballNear Mint$40$40——57
Jay Cutler #892007 Panini Donruss Gridiron Gear FootballPSA 10$40$2——58
Jay Cutler #T-JC2006 Topps Football AutographsNear Mint$40$40——59
Jay Cutler #172011 Panini Donruss Elite FootballNear Mint$40$40——60
Jay Cutler #1462006 Fleer FootballPSA 10$40$5——61
Jay Cutler #742011 Panini Gold Standard FootballPSA 10$37$2——62
Jay Cutler #22013 Topps Finest FootballPSA 9$36$11——63
Jay Cutler #42014 Panini Contenders FootballNear Mint$36$36——64
Jay Cutler #202016 Panini Certified FootballPSA 10$36$24——65
Jay Cutler #372014 Panini Score FootballNear Mint$35$35——66
Jay Cutler #162016 Panini National Treasures FootballNear Mint$35$35——67
Jay Cutler #1572006 Panini Donruss Gridiron Gear FootballPSA 9$35$13——68
Jay Cutler #542016 Panini Score FootballPSA 10$35$12——69
Jay Cutler #1902006 Topps Turkey Red FootballNear Mint$35$35——70
Jay Cutler #212016 Panini Donruss Elite FootballNear Mint$34$34——71
Jay Cutler #302007 Spx FootballPSA 10$31$1——72
Jay Cutler #302009 Panini Donruss Rookies & Stars FootballPSA 10$31$3——73
Jay Cutler #162010 Playoff Contenders FootballPSA 10$30$0——74
Jay Cutler #742006 Playoff NFL PlayoffsPSA 10$30$24——75
Jay Cutler #452015 Panini Prizm Collegiate Draft Picks FootballNear Mint$30$30——76
Jay Cutler #2292006 Upper Deck Rookie Debut FootballPSA 10$30$10——77
Jay Cutler #832014 Panini Absolute FootballNear Mint$30$30——78
Jay Cutler #NFL82006 Topps Chrome NFL 8306PSA 10$30$4——79
Jay Cutler #1002016 Panini Spectra FootballNear Mint$30$30——80
Jay Cutler #242012 Panini National Treasures FootballNear Mint$30$30——81
Jay Cutler #172015 Topps Finest FootballNear Mint$30$30——82Jay Cutler #HCA-JC2006 Topps Heritage Football In the CardsNear Mint$29$29——83
Jay Cutler #1142006 Bowman FootballNear Mint$26$26——84
Jay Cutler #172014 Panini Certified FootballLightly Played$26$11——85
Jay Cutler #42006 Topps Football Super BowlCGC 10$25$8——86
Jay Cutler #262007 Topps Performance FootballNear Mint$25$25——87
Jay Cutler #3092014 Panini Score FootballNear Mint$25$25——88
Jay Cutler #622015 Panini Certified FootballNear Mint$25$25——89
Jay Cutler #242016 Panini Classics FootballNear Mint$25$25——90
Jay Cutler #1262014 Panini Prestige FootballNear Mint$25$25——91
Jay Cutler #TC42007 Topps Chrome FootballPSA 9$25$10——92
Jay Cutler #112013 Panini Select Football SignaturesPSA 10$24$3——93
Jay Cutler #172013 Panini Spectra FootballPSA 9$24$20——94
Jay Cutler #1252006 Topps Heritage FootballPSA 10$23$2——95
Jay Cutler #C922010 Topps Chrome FootballNear Mint$23$23——96
Jay Cutler #172013 Panini National Treasures FootballNear Mint$22$22——97
Jay Cutler #22015 Donruss FootballNear Mint$22$22——98
Jay Cutler #1402011 Topps FootballPSA 10$22$2——99
Jay Cutler #752013 Panini Certified FootballNear Mint$22$22——100
Jay Cutler #812015 Panini Prestige FootballNear Mint$21$21——Sets with Jay Cutler cards
Jay Cutler appears in 527 sets. Open one for the most valuable cards in it.
- 2007 Topps Football Generation Now4 cards
- 2006 Sage Game Exclusives Football3 cards
- 2013 Panini Score Football3 cards
- 2013 Score Football3 cards
- 2014 Topps Triple Threads Football Relics3 cards
- 2006 Bowman Chrome Football2 cards
- 2006 Bowman Football2 cards
- 2006 Press Pass Football2 cards
- 2006 Sage Aspire Football2 cards
- 2007 Donruss Classics Football2 cards
- 2007 Leaf Rookies & Stars Football2 cards
- 2007 Leaf Rookies & Stars Longevity Football2 cards
- 2009 Topps Football2 cards
- 2010 Panini Classics Football2 cards
- 2012 Panini Totally Certified Football2 cards
- 2013 Panini Totally Certified Football2 cards
- 2014 Panini Absolute Football2 cards
- 2014 Panini Absolute Football Tools of the Trade2 cards
- 2014 Panini Crown Royale Football Knights of the Round Table Materials2 cards
- 2014 Panini Score Football2 cards
- 2014 Score Football2 cards
- 2014 Topps Football2 cards
- 2015 Donruss Signature Series Football2 cards
- 2016 Panini Football2 cards
- 2000 Playoff Prestige Draft Picks Football1 card
- 2006 Bowman Chrome Football FeltBack Flashback1 card
- 2006 Etopps Football1 card
- 2006 Flair Showcase Football1 card
- 2006 Flair Showcase Stitches Rookies Football1 card
- 2006 Flair Showcase Wave Of The Future Football1 card
- 2006 Fleer Football1 card
- 2006 Fleer Fresh Faces Football1 card
- 2006 Leaf Certified Materials Football1 card
- 2006 Leaf Rookies & Stars 1948 Blue Football1 card
- 2006 Leaf Rookies & Stars Football1 card
- 2006 Panini Donruss Classics Football1 card
- 2006 Panini Donruss Elite Football1 card
- 2006 Panini Donruss Gridiron Gear Football1 card
- 2006 Panini Score Football1 card
- 2006 Panini Score Hot Rookie Football1 card