
Most Valuable Jay Payton Cards
Every Jay Payton card in the catalog, ranked by market value, with live prices, trends and real sold comps.
Jay Payton Cards207
Market Value (PSA 10)$153
Market Value (Raw NM)$385
Avg 30d Change-1.29%
Top CardJay Payton
#CardConditionPriceRaw Price30d %RarityTrend
1
Jay Payton #2401995 Bowman Gold Foil BaseballPSA 10$70$1——2
Jay Payton #982003 Donruss Diamond Kings BaseballPSA 10$32$3——3
Jay Payton #1702005 Donruss BaseballNear Mint$30$30——4
Jay Payton #2932001 Topps BaseballPSA 10$29$1——5
Jay Payton #3501996 Topps BaseballPSA 9$27$2——6
Jay Payton #1642005 Leaf BaseballNear Mint$24$24——7
Jay Payton #4431995 Topps BaseballPSA 10$22$1——8
Jay Payton #1892009 Topps BaseballNear Mint$20$20——9Jay Payton #CP382001 Topps Heritage Baseball ChromeNear Mint$20$20——10
Jay Payton #6162005 Topps BaseballNear Mint$20$20——11
Jay Payton #1411996 Topps Chrome BaseballNear Mint$13$13——12
Jay Payton #742001 SPx BaseballNear Mint$9$9——13
Jay Payton #2291999 SkyBox Thunder BaseballNear Mint$7$7——14
Jay Payton #232004 Topps Chrome BaseballNear Mint$7$7——15
Jay Payton #2582004 Donruss BaseballNear Mint$6$6——16
Jay Payton #932000 Pacific Private Stock BaseballNear Mint$6$6——17
Jay Payton #1111996 Bowman's Best BaseballNear Mint$6$6——18Jay Payton #1612004 Playoff Honors BaseballNear Mint$6$6——19
Jay Payton #2012003 Topps 205 BaseballNear Mint$6$6——20
Jay Payton #992005 Topps Cracker Jack BaseballNear Mint$6$6——21
Jay Payton #2752001 Pacific BaseballNear Mint$6$6——22
Jay Payton #621995 Bowman's Best Baseball Base Set BlueNear Mint$6$6——23
Jay Payton #912000 Pacific Crown Royale BaseballNear Mint$5$5——24
Jay Payton #35361994 Fleer ProCards BaseballNear Mint$4$4——25
Jay Payton #2401995 Bowman BaseballNear Mint$4$4——26
Jay Payton #1632004 Donruss Throwback Threads BaseballNear Mint$4$4——27
Jay Payton #3122001 Topps Heritage BaseballNear Mint$4$40%—28
Jay Payton #SS-JP2001 Upper Deck Baseball Subway Series Game JerseysNear Mint$4$40%—29
Jay Payton #4762003 Topps BaseballNear Mint$4$4-5.70%—30
Jay Payton #492005 Donruss Studio Private Signings BaseballNear Mint$4$4——31
Jay Payton #71996 Fleer Excel Baseball ClimbingNear Mint$4$4——32
Jay Payton #T892002 Topps Traded & Rookies BaseballNear Mint$4$4——33
Jay Payton #3412003 Donruss BaseballNear Mint$4$4——34
Jay Payton #4012002 Upper Deck Victory BaseballNear Mint$4$40%—35
Jay Payton #6022003 Topps Total BaseballNear Mint$4$4——36
Jay Payton #1352001 Donruss BaseballNear Mint$4$4——37
Jay Payton #2152001 Fleer Platinum BaseballNear Mint$3$3——38
Jay Payton #2382002 Upper Deck MVP BaseballNear Mint$3$3——39
Jay Payton #5682007 Upper Deck BaseballNear Mint$3$3——40
Jay Payton #1842007 Upper Deck BaseballNear Mint$3$3——41
Jay Payton #452001 Topps Gold Label BaseballNear Mint$3$3——42
Jay Payton #1222004 Upper Deck Vintage BaseballNear Mint$3$3——43
Jay Payton #312007 Topps BaseballNear Mint$3$30%—44
Jay Payton #57-U2000 Pacific Paramount Update BaseballNear Mint$3$3——45
Jay Payton #4382008 Topps BaseballNear Mint$3$3——46
Jay Payton #1112002 Fleer BaseballNear Mint$3$3——47
Jay Payton #2632005 Donruss Team Heroes BaseballNear Mint$3$3——48
Jay Payton #1012001 Fleer Futures BaseballNear Mint$3$30%—49
Jay Payton #3972003 Topps Heritage BaseballNear Mint$3$3——50
Jay Payton #432004 Fleer Authentix BaseballNear Mint$2$2——51
Jay Payton #1212005 Topps Rookie Cup BaseballNear Mint$2$2——52Jay Payton #281994 Signature Rookies Draft Picks Baseball SignaturesNear Mint$2$2——53
Jay Payton #U2692002 Fleer Tradition Update BaseballNear Mint$2$2——54Jay Payton #362006 Fleer BaseballNear Mint$2$2——55
Jay Payton #2562002 Topps Heritage BaseballNear Mint$2$2——56
Jay Payton #JP2001 Finest Autographs BaseballNear Mint$2$2——57
Jay Payton #232004 Topps BaseballNear Mint$2$2——58
Jay Payton #2822001 MLB Showdown 1st EditionNear Mint$2$2——59
Jay Payton #T212004 Topps Traded & Rookies BaseballModerately Played$2$2——60
Jay Payton #1162003 Playoff Prestige BaseballNear Mint$2$2——61
Jay Payton #252007 Topps Allen & Ginter BaseballNear Mint$2$20%—62
Jay Payton #2531999 Fleer Tradition BaseballNear Mint$2$20%—63
Jay Payton #1371997 Select BaseballNear Mint$2$20%—64
Jay Payton #442005 Topps Heritage BaseballNear Mint$2$2+11.61%—65Jay Payton #912000 Pacific Crown Royale Baseball RookiesNear Mint$2$20%—66
Jay Payton #452001 Bowman Chrome BaseballNear Mint$2$2——67
Jay Payton #1091998 Donruss Elite BaseballNear Mint$2$2+3.78%—68
Jay Payton #3812001 Upper Deck Vintage BaseballNear Mint$2$20%—69
Jay Payton #3282005 Topps Total BaseballNear Mint$2$2——70
Jay Payton #2411996 Bowman BaseballNear Mint$2$2——71
Jay Payton #752002 Fleer Platinum BaseballNear Mint$2$2——72
Jay Payton #5002003 Upper Deck BaseballNear Mint$2$2——73
Jay Payton #1022001 Fleer Premium BaseballNear Mint$2$20%—74
Jay Payton #RF42001 Bowman's Best Baseball Rookie FeverNear Mint$2$2-4.46%—75
Jay Payton #1492002 Fleer Premium BaseballNear Mint$2$2+3.07%—76
Jay Payton #4662006 Topps BaseballNear Mint$2$2-41.62%—77
Jay Payton #3421997 Topps BaseballNear Mint$2$2-6.04%—78
Jay Payton #2772004 Fleer Tradition BaseballNear Mint$1$1——79
Jay Payton #T212004 Topps Traded BaseballNear Mint$1$1——80
Jay Payton #2232002 Upper Deck Vintage BaseballNear Mint$1$1——81
Jay Payton #3052003 Topps Chrome BaseballNear Mint$1$1——82
Jay Payton #FM62001 Finest Baseball Finest MomentsNear Mint$1$1-2.35%—83
Jay Payton #TP142007 Topps Baseball Trading PlacesNear Mint$1$1-8.21%—84
Jay Payton #3782002 Topps BaseballNear Mint$1$1-22.78%—85
Jay Payton #3782002 Topps Chrome BaseballNear Mint$1$1——86
Jay Payton #LS-JP2003 Upper Deck Baseball Leading SwatchesNear Mint$1$1——87
Jay Payton #1262001 Topps Stars BaseballNear Mint$1$1——88
Jay Payton #1872001 Fleer Focus BaseballNear Mint$1$1——89
Jay Payton #1172007 Fleer BaseballNear Mint$1$1——90
Jay Payton #U201998 Fleer Update BaseballNear Mint$1$1——91
Jay Payton #2292001 Topps Chrome BaseballNear Mint$1$1——92
Jay Payton #342005 Donruss Champions BaseballNear Mint$1$1——93
Jay Payton #1652005 Upper Deck BaseballNear Mint$1$1——94
Jay Payton #1951995 Upper Deck Minor League BaseballNear Mint$1$1——95
Jay Payton #841995 Best BaseballNear Mint$1$1-3.95%—96
Jay Payton #1511997 Bowman BaseballNear Mint$0$0+16.91%—97Jay Payton #2152001 Fleer Tradition BaseballNear Mint$0$0——98
Jay Payton #1352001 Playoff Absolute Memorabilia BaseballNear Mint$0$0+28.16%—99
Jay Payton #902001 Topps Gallery BaseballNear Mint$0$0——100
Jay Payton #3212001 Bowman Heritage BaseballNear Mint$0$00%—Sets with Jay Payton cards
Jay Payton appears in 201 sets. Open one for the most valuable cards in it.
- 1995 Best Baseball2 cards
- 1995 Sp Top Prospects Baseball2 cards
- 1998 Donruss Collection Baseball2 cards
- 2001 Upper Deck Vintage Baseball2 cards
- 2002 Fleer Premium Baseball2 cards
- 2007 Upper Deck Baseball2 cards
- 1994 Collector Baseball1 card
- 1994 Fleer ProCards Baseball1 card
- 1994 Signature Rookies Draft Picks Baseball1 card
- 1994 Signature Rookies Draft Picks Baseball Signatures1 card
- 1994 Stadium Club Draft Picks Baseball1 card
- 1994 Upper Deck Top Prospects Baseball1 card
- 1995 Best Baseball Autographs1 card
- 1995 Bowman Baseball1 card
- 1995 Bowman Gold Foil Baseball1 card
- 1995 Bowman's Best Baseball Base Set Blue1 card
- 1995 Classic Five Sport Baseball1 card
- 1995 Topps Baseball1 card
- 1995 Upper Deck Minor League Baseball1 card
- 1996 Best Baseball Autographs1 card
- 1996 Bowman Baseball1 card
- 1996 Bowman's Best Baseball1 card
- 1996 Classic Assets Basketball1 card
- 1996 Fleer Excel Baseball1 card
- 1996 Fleer Excel Baseball All-Stars1 card
- 1996 Fleer Excel Baseball Climbing1 card
- 1996 Panini Score Board All Sport Ppf Football1 card
- 1996 Score Board Autograph Collection Baseball1 card
- 1996 Topps Baseball1 card
- 1996 Topps Chrome Baseball1 card
- 1997 Best Baseball Autographs1 card
- 1997 Best Baseball Prospect Autographs1 card
- 1997 Bowman Baseball1 card
- 1997 Bowman Baseball Certified Autographs1 card
- 1997 Collector's Choice Baseball1 card
- 1997 Donruss Signature Series Baseball Signature Series Autographs1 card
- 1997 Donruss Signature Series Baseball Signature Series Century Marks Autographs1 card
- 1997 Donruss Signature Series Baseball Signature Series Millennium Marks Autographs1 card
- 1997 Score Board Players Club Basketball1 card
- 1997 Select Baseball1 card
