Most Valuable Jim McMahon Cards
Every Jim McMahon card in the catalog, ranked by market value, with live prices, trends and real sold comps.
Jim McMahon Cards275
Market Value (PSA 10)$9,297
Market Value (Raw NM)$5,686
Avg 30d Change-17.29%
Top CardJim McMahon
#CardConditionPriceRaw Price30d %RarityTrend
1Jim McMahon #332016 Panini Preferred FootballPSA 10$1,235———2
Jim McMahon #311985 Topps FootballPSA 10$1,225$2——3
Jim McMahon #331983 Topps FootballPSA 10$997$7——4
Jim McMahon #101986 Topps FootballPSA 10$965$2——5
Jim McMahon #SBCS-JM2026 Topps Flagship Football Super Bowl Champion SignaturesPSA 10$521$100——6
Jim McMahon #1322013 Panini Select FootballNear Mint$400$400——7
Jim McMahon #762023 Panini Flawless FootballNear Mint$350$350——8
Jim McMahon #12019 Panini Flawless Football Flawless SignaturesNear Mint$350$350——9
Jim McMahon #TRI-JM2025 Topps Resurgence Thermal Red Ink Autograph FootballPSA 10$305$56——10
Jim McMahon #82023 Panini Illusions Football FunkadelicNear Mint$263$263——11
Jim McMahon #1961983 Topps Stickers FootballPSA 10$234$3——12
Jim McMahon #1402024 Panini Photogenic FootballNear Mint$225$225——13
Jim McMahon #3312023 Panini One FootballPSA 10$216$115——14
Jim McMahon #4821993 Topps FootballPSA 10$200$3——15
Jim McMahon #441987 Topps FootballPSA 10$192$1——16
Jim McMahon #1962016 Panini Classics FootballNear Mint$175$175——17
Jim McMahon #32025 Panini Silhouette Football Framed SignaturesPSA 10$163$59——18
Jim McMahon #BCV-62024 Topps Signature Class Chrome Variation FootballPSA 10$163$18——19
Jim McMahon #TCA-JM2023 Topps Composite Chrome Autograph FootballPSA 10$150$45——20
Jim McMahon #901994 Topps Finest FootballPSA 10$150$17——21
Jim McMahon #552024 Panini Prestige FootballNear Mint$150$150——22
Jim McMahon #FBA-JM2024 Topps Finest Flashback Autograph FootballPSA 10$138$85——23
Jim McMahon #SF-922025 Topps Cosmic Chrome Starfractor FootballPSA 10$132$22——24
Jim McMahon #CJPAH-JM2023 Topps Composite Jumbo Swatch Autograph Horizontal FootballNear Mint$122$122——25
Jim McMahon #RS-JM2024 Topps Resurgence Football Resurgence SignaturesPSA 10$119$40——26
Jim McMahon #AM-JM2023 Panini Mosaic Football AutographsPSA 10$117$41——27
Jim McMahon #2402023 Panini Prestige FootballNear Mint$115$115——28
Jim McMahon #1372017 Panini Classics FootballNear Mint$114$114——29
Jim McMahon #202024 Panini Prizm Draft Picks FootballPSA 10$110$39——30Jim McMahon #392017 Score Football InscriptionsNear Mint$103$103——31
Jim McMahon #441989 Pro Set FootballPSA 10$100$1——32
Jim McMahon #SL192020 Panini Illusions Stadium Legends Autographs FootballNear Mint$100$100——33
Jim McMahon #1952020 Panini Prizm FootballNear Mint$100$100——34
Jim McMahon #RB-492024 Pro Set Metal Retro Base FootballNear Mint$100$100——35
Jim McMahon #LOG-52025 Topps Chrome Football Legends of the GridironPSA 10$97$15——36
Jim McMahon #3101990 Fleer FootballPSA 10$97$1——37
Jim McMahon #352023 Panini Donruss Optic FootballPSA 10$92$83——38
Jim McMahon #3241993 Stadium Club FootballPSA 10$91$12——39
Jim McMahon #6101990 Pro Set FootballPSA 10$88$1——40
Jim McMahon #2271984 Topps FootballPSA 10$86$2——41
Jim McMahon #3182023 Panini Select FootballPSA 10$82$68——42
Jim McMahon #1862012 Panini Certified FootballNear Mint$82$82——43
Jim McMahon #RA-JM2023 Topps Composite Resurgence Signature FootballNear Mint$81$81——44
Jim McMahon #522024 Panini Score FootballNear Mint$80$80——45
Jim McMahon #CJPAV-JM2023 Topps Composite Jumbo Swatch Autograph Vertical FootballNear Mint$78$78——46
Jim McMahon #2422007 Leaf Certified Materials FootballNear Mint$75$75——47
Jim McMahon #902023 Topps Composite FootballNear Mint$75$75——48
Jim McMahon #3291994 Ultra FootballPSA 10$71$1——49
Jim McMahon #VA-JM12025 Leaf Vivid Football Vivid Memories AutographsNear Mint$70$70——50
Jim McMahon #122023 Panini Immaculate All Time Greats Signature FootballNear Mint$62$62——51
Jim McMahon #BA-JMC2024 Topps Chrome Football AutographsNear Mint$60$60——52
Jim McMahon #FF-92023 Panini Phoenix Fire Forged FootballPSA 10$59$18——53
Jim McMahon #4781989 Pro Set FootballPSA 10$56$2——54
Jim McMahon #CCA-JM2023 Topps Motif Canvas Champions Autograph FootballNear Mint$56$56——55
Jim McMahon #542005 Topps All American FootballNear Mint$55$55——56
Jim McMahon #SSA-JMC2024 Panini Photogenic Snapshots Autograph FootballNear Mint$52$52——57
Jim McMahon #353S1989 Panini Score Supplemental FootballPSA 10$50$1——58
Jim McMahon #612016 Panini Spectra FootballNear Mint$50$50——59
Jim McMahon (Var) #612016 Panini Spectra FootballNear Mint$50$50——60
Jim McMahon #1002012 Panini Totally Certified FootballNear Mint$50$50——61
Jim McMahon #LIO-202024 Topps Chrome Cosmic Football Launched Into OrbitPSA 10$49$19——62
Jim McMahon #L-122024 Topps Inception Football LaunchPSA 10$46$5——63
Jim McMahon #1452019 Score Football 1989-2019 Score Buyback CardsPSA 10$46$1——64
Jim McMahon #U-161990 Fleer Update FootballPSA 10$45$1——65
Jim McMahon #ME-JM2023 Topps Motif Endorsements FootballNear Mint$45$45——66
Jim McMahon #182024 Topps Chrome FootballNear Mint$45$45——67
Jim McMahon #522024 Score FootballPSA 9$45$10——68
Jim McMahon #62024 Topps Signature Class FootballNear Mint$45$45——69
Jim McMahon #442023 Topps Composite FootballPSA 10$42$30——70
Jim McMahon #162024 Topps Inception FootballPSA 10$42$35——71
Jim McMahon #2282008 Upper Deck Heroes FootballPSA 10$42$2——72
Jim McMahon #LL-JMN2024 Panini Prestige Football Living LegendsPSA 10$40$20——73Jim McMahon #RA-JM2023 Topps Composite Football Resurgence Signatures SetNear Mint$40$40——74
Jim McMahon #97T1989 Topps Traded FootballPSA 10$40$2——75
Jim McMahon #272012 Upper Deck FootballNear Mint$40$40——76
Jim McMahon #AA-JM2023 Topps Motif Aquarelle Autograph FootballNear Mint$40$40——77
Jim McMahon #142025 Panini Revolution FootballNear Mint$38$38——78
Jim McMahon #1451989 Panini Score FootballPSA 10$38$1——79
Jim McMahon #2062024 Finest FootballPSA 10$37$13——80
Jim McMahon #691988 Topps FootballPSA 10$37$2——81
Jim McMahon #RIRPA-JM2023 Topps Composite Resurgence Ignite Swatch Autograph FootballNear Mint$37$37——82
Jim McMahon #3112023 Topps Composite FootballPSA 10$36$2——83
Jim McMahon #CAE-32023 Topps Composite Chrome All Etch FootballPSA 10$35$22——84
Jim McMahon #621989 Topps FootballPSA 10$35$2——85
Jim McMahon #SS-32023 Topps Composite Spotless Spans FootballPSA 10$35$1——86
Jim McMahon #FF-22023 Topps Composite Flashbacks FootballPSA 10$35$1——87
Jim McMahon #892025 Leaf Metal FootballPSA 10$34$1——88
Jim McMahon #111T1990 Topps Traded FootballPSA 10$34$2——89
Jim McMahon #A-JMC2005 Topps All American Autograph FootballNear Mint$34$34——90
Jim McMahon #22016 Panini Prestige Football Super Bowl HeroesPSA 9$31$7——91
Jim McMahon #GU-282025 Leaf Glory Of The Game Used FootballNear Mint$30$30——92
Jim McMahon #142024 Topps Resurgence FootballNear Mint$29$29——93
Jim McMahon #1162002 Panini Donruss Classics FootballNear Mint$29$29——94
Jim McMahon #1272007 Panini Donruss Classics FootballNear Mint$28$28——95
Jim McMahon #2062024 Topps Finest FootballNear Mint$28$28——96
Jim McMahon #LS-MC2005 Upper Deck Legends Legendary Signatures FootballNear Mint$27$27——97
Jim McMahon #MYST-22024 Topps Finest Mystery Refractor FootballNear Mint$26$26——98
Jim McMahon #152024 Topps Chrome Cosmic FootballNear Mint$25$25——99
Jim McMahon #522024 Score-A-Treat FootballNear Mint$23$23——100
Jim McMahon #522024 Panini Score A Treat FootballNear Mint$23$23——Sets with Jim McMahon cards
Jim McMahon appears in 258 sets. Open one for the most valuable cards in it.
- 1989 Pro Set Football5 cards
- 2018 Panini Honors Recollection Football4 cards
- 2023 Topps Composite Football4 cards
- 1996 Playoff Absolute Football2 cards
- 2007 Donruss Classics Football2 cards
- 2016 Panini Preferred Football2 cards
- 2016 Panini Spectra Football2 cards
- 2019 Score Football 1989-2019 Score Buyback Cards2 cards
- 2024 Score Football2 cards
- 2025 Leaf Metal Football2 cards
- 1983 Topps Football1 card
- 1983 Topps Stickers Football1 card
- 1984 Topps Football1 card
- 1985 Topps Football1 card
- 1986 Topps Football1 card
- 1987 Topps Football1 card
- 1988 Panini Sticker Football1 card
- 1988 Topps Football1 card
- 1989 Panini Score Football1 card
- 1989 Panini Score Supplemental Football1 card
- 1989 Panini Sticker Football1 card
- 1989 Score Football1 card
- 1989 Score Supplemental Football1 card
- 1989 Topps Football1 card
- 1989 Topps Traded Football1 card
- 1990 Action Packed Football1 card
- 1990 Action Packed Rookie Update Football1 card
- 1990 Fleer Football1 card
- 1990 Fleer Update Football1 card
- 1990 Panini Sticker Football1 card
- 1990 Pro Set Football1 card
- 1990 Topps Traded Football1 card
- 1991 Action Packed All Madden Football1 card
- 1991 Pacific Football1 card
- 1991 Pinnacle Football1 card
- 1991 Pro Set Football1 card
- 1991 Pro Set Platinum Football1 card
- 1991 Proline Portraits Football1 card
- 1991 Ultra Update Football1 card
- 1993 Action Packed All Madden Football1 card