Most Valuable Jim O'Toole Cards
Every Jim O'Toole card in the catalog, ranked by market value, with live prices, trends and real sold comps.
Jim O'Toole Cards33
Market Value (PSA 10)$6,908
Market Value (Raw NM)$221
Avg 30d Change—
Top CardJim O'Toole
#CardConditionPriceRaw Price30d %RarityTrend
1Jim O'Toole #3891966 Topps BaseballPSA 10$1,560$2——2
Jim O'Toole #4501962 Topps BaseballPSA 10$993$6——3
Jim O'Toole #4671967 Topps BaseballPSA 10$885$6——4
Jim O'Toole #3251960 Topps BaseballPSA 10$828$4——5
Jim O'Toole #1361959 Topps BaseballPSA 10$753$4——6
Jim O'Toole #1851964 Topps BaseballPSA 10$452$2——7
Jim O'Toole #701963 Topps BaseballPSA 10$424$2——8
Jim O'Toole #601965 Topps BaseballPSA 10$415$2——9
Jim O'Toole #3281961 Topps BaseballPSA 10$389$2——10
Jim O'Toole #851964 Topps Coins BaseballPSA 9$180$1——11
Jim O'Toole #61965 Bazooka BaseballPSA 10$171$26——12
Jim O'Toole #1891961 Post Cereal BaseballPSA 9$78$28——13
Jim O'Toole #1361959 Venezuela Topps BaseballNear Mint$45$45——14
Jim O'Toole #1851964 Topps Venezuelan BaseballNear Mint$41$41——15
Jim O'Toole #ROA-JOT2016 Topps Heritage Baseball Real One AutographsPSA 10$40$18——16
Jim O'Toole #601965 O-Pee-Chee BaseballPSA 8$21$6——17
Jim O'Toole #1261962 Jell O BaseballNear Mint$8$8——18
Jim O'Toole #1261962 Post Canadian BaseballNear Mint$6$6——19
Jim O'Toole #1851964 Venezuela Topps BaseballNear Mint$6$6——20
Jim O'Toole #1261962 Post Cereal BaseballNear Mint$4$4——21
Jim O'Toole #1361963 Post Cereal BaseballNear Mint$1$1——22
Jim O'Toole #1471989 Pacific Legends BaseballNear Mint$1$1——23Jim O'Toole #212010 Topps Heritage Baseball Framed Buyback StampsRaw————24Jim O'Toole #281980 Tcma 1961 Cincinnati Reds BaseballRaw————25Jim O'Toole #4502011 Topps Heritage Baseball 50th Anniversary BuybacksRaw————26Jim O'Toole #1361959 Topps Venezuelan BaseballRaw————27Sets with Jim O'Toole cards
Jim O'Toole appears in 33 sets. Open one for the most valuable cards in it.
- 1959 Topps Baseball1 card
- 1959 Topps Venezuelan Baseball1 card
- 1959 Venezuela Topps Baseball1 card
- 1960 Topps Baseball1 card
- 1961 Post Cereal Baseball1 card
- 1961 Topps Baseball1 card
- 1962 Jell O Baseball1 card
- 1962 Post Canadian Baseball1 card
- 1962 Post Cereal Baseball1 card
- 1962 Topps Baseball1 card
- 1963 Post Cereal Baseball1 card
- 1963 Topps Baseball1 card
- 1964 Topps Baseball1 card
- 1964 Topps Coins Baseball1 card
- 1964 Topps Venezuelan Baseball1 card
- 1964 Venezuela Topps Baseball1 card
- 1965 Bazooka Baseball1 card
- 1965 O-Pee-Chee Baseball1 card
- 1965 Topps Baseball1 card
- 1966 Topps Baseball1 card
- 1967 Topps Baseball1 card
- 1980 Tcma 1961 Cincinnati Reds Baseball1 card
- 1989 Pacific Legends Baseball1 card
- 2009 Topps Heritage Baseball 50th Anniversary Buybacks1 card
- 2010 Topps Heritage Baseball 50th Anniversary Buybacks1 card
- 2010 Topps Heritage Baseball Framed Buyback Stamps1 card
- 2011 Topps Heritage Baseball 50th Anniversary Buybacks1 card
- 2011 Topps Heritage Baseball Framed 1962 Stamps Buybacks1 card
- 2012 Leaf Cut Signature History of Baseball1 card
- 2012 Topps Heritage 1963 Original Buybacks Baseball1 card
- 2012 Topps Heritage Baseball 50th Anniversary Buybacks1 card
- 2013 Topps Heritage Baseball 1964 Topps Bazooka Stamps Buybacks1 card
- 2016 Topps Heritage Baseball Real One Autographs1 card