Most Valuable Joe Theismann Cards
Every Joe Theismann card in the catalog, ranked by market value, with live prices, trends and real sold comps.
Joe Theismann Cards409
Market Value (PSA 10)$17,396
Market Value (Raw NM)$6,295
Avg 30d Change+17.99%
Top CardJoe Theismann
#CardConditionPriceRaw Price30d %RarityTrend
1Joe Theismann #131971 O Pee Chee Cfl FootballPSA 10$10,566$92——2
Joe Theismann #4161975 Topps FootballPSA 10$1,290$13——3
Joe Theismann #2842025 Panini Prizm Choice FootballNear Mint$760$760——4
Joe Theismann #2842025 Panini Prizm FootballNear Mint$550$550——5
Joe Theismann #2311976 Topps FootballPSA 10$400$3——6
Joe Theismann #1052025 Panini Mosaic FootballPSA 10$400$120——7
Joe Theismann #4161978 Topps FootballPSA 10$342$2——8
Joe Theismann #271972 O Pee Chee Cfl FootballPSA 9$311$42——9
Joe Theismann #132021 Donruss Optic Football Retro SeriesPSA 8$260$105——10
Joe Theismann #M-22012 Fleer Retro Metal FootballNear Mint$247$247——11
Joe Theismann #741977 Topps FootballPSA 10$246$2——12
Joe Theismann #1711986 Topps FootballPSA 10$236$2——13
Joe Theismann #22024 Panini Contenders Legendary Autograph FootballNear Mint$236$236——14
Joe Theismann #242024 Panini Eminence NFL Shield Autograph Silver BarNear Mint$226$226——15
Joe Theismann #1901985 Topps FootballPSA 10$220$2——16
Joe Theismann #1551979 Topps FootballPSA 10$188$3——17
Joe Theismann #972020 Panini One FootballNear Mint$180$180——18
Joe Theismann #3901984 Topps FootballPSA 10$169$1——19
Joe Theismann #1651981 Topps FootballPSA 10$169$1——20
Joe Theismann #2502023 Panini Mosaic FootballNear Mint$156$156——21
Joe Theismann #FC-462023 Panini Plates And Patches Full Coverage FootballNear Mint$150$150——22
Joe Theismann #1422012 Sp Authentic FootballPSA 10$150$8——23
Joe Theismann #DA-JTH2019 Panini Flawless Distinguished Patch Autograph FootballNear Mint$150$150——24
Joe Theismann #BA-JTH2024 Topps Chrome Football AutographsNear Mint$148$148——25
Joe Theismann #2172021 Panini Prizm FootballPSA 10$145$90——26
Joe Theismann #1991983 Topps FootballPSA 10$141$2——27
Joe Theismann #4751980 Topps FootballPSA 10$133$2——28
Joe Theismann #OA-JT12025 Leaf Optichrome Optimus Auto FootballPSA 10$129$25——29
Joe Theismann #FBA-JTN2024 Panini Prizm Football Flashback AutographsPSA 10$128$65——30
Joe Theismann #3322023 Panini One FootballPSA 10$127$54——31Joe Theismann #LSS-JT2022 Panini Encased Football Legendary Swatch SignaturesNear Mint$125$125——32
Joe Theismann #1852020 Panini Prizm FootballNear Mint$119$119——33
Joe Theismann #942020 Panini Flawless FootballPSA 10$104$72——34
Joe Theismann #AL-1741997 Upper Deck Legends FootballPSA 10$100$20——35
Joe Theismann #MS362023 Panini Certified Mirror Signatures FootballPSA 9$100$30——36
Joe Theismann #5211982 Topps FootballPSA 10$100$2——37
Joe Theismann #712025 Panini Phoenix FootballPSA 10$99$76——38
Joe Theismann #161980 Topps Super FootballPSA 9$90$2——39
Joe Theismann #41990 Notre Dame Collegiate Collection FootballPSA 10$90$1——40
Joe Theismann #291983 Topps Stickers Insert FootballPSA 10$88$1——41
Joe Theismann #SSH-JT2025 Panini Donruss Optic Signature Series Holo FootballPSA 10$87$12——42
Joe Theismann #HZS-JT2024 Topps Midnight Football Horizon SignaturesPSA 10$87$50——43
Joe Theismann #BA-JT32025 Leaf Optichrome Autograph FootballPSA 10$82$20——44
Joe Theismann #1002020 Panini Impeccable FootballNear Mint$81$81——45
Joe Theismann #FS-JT2004 Upper Deck Finite Signatures FootballPSA 10$80$8——46
Joe Theismann #622019 Panini Impeccable FootballNear Mint$80$80——47Joe Theismann #HR-JT2023 Panini Plates And Patches Highly Revered FootballNear Mint$80$80——48
Joe Theismann #422001 Topps Archives Reserve FootballPSA 10$72$2——49
Joe Theismann #24K-JTH2022 Panini Gold Standard Football 24K AutographsPSA 10$70$38——50
Joe Theismann #111995 Tombstone Pizza FootballPSA 10$68$1——51
Joe Theismann #3911984 Topps FootballPSA 10$68$2——52
Joe Theismann #62025 Panini Flawless Football Game Used MemorabiliaNear Mint$66$66——53
Joe Theismann #542018 Panini Immaculate Collection Football Nameplate NobilityNear Mint$65$65——54
Joe Theismann #DOD-112023 Panini Legacy Football Decade of DominancePSA 9$65$15——55
Joe Theismann #422001 Topps Archives FootballPSA 10$64$2——56
Joe Theismann #121984 Topps Glossy Send In FootballPSA 10$63$1——57
Joe Theismann #1262023 Panini Legacy FootballPSA 10$62$35——58
Joe Theismann #SBD-JTH2022 Panini Gold Standard Football Super Bowl Diamond SignaturesNear Mint$62$62——59
Joe Theismann #1882018 Panini Classics FootballNear Mint$60$60——60
Joe Theismann #RS-JTH2024 Topps Resurgence Football Resurgence SignaturesPSA 10$60$20——61
Joe Theismann #ET-JT2023 Donruss Elite Football Etched in Time SignaturesNear Mint$56$56——62
Joe Theismann #IJA-JT2022 Panini Illusions Football Immortalized Jersey AutographsNear Mint$55$55——63
Joe Theismann #2442024 Topps Finest FootballNear Mint$54$54——64
Joe Theismann #3532024 Panini One FootballNear Mint$50$50——65Joe Theismann #3322023 Panini One Football Once Upon a Time SignaturesNear Mint$50$50——66
Joe Theismann #1002023 Panini National Treasures FootballNear Mint$50$50——67
Joe Theismann #IEB-JTH2019 Panini Immaculate Collection Football Immaculate Eye BlackNear Mint$50$50——68
Joe Theismann #1472016 Panini Classics FootballNear Mint$50$50——69
Joe Theismann #142000 Fleer Greats Of The Game FootballPSA 10$49$1——70
Joe Theismann #1962024 Topps Chrome FootballNear Mint$48$48——71
Joe Theismann #2442024 Finest FootballNear Mint$47$47——72
Joe Theismann #1842015 Panini Gridiron Kings FootballNear Mint$45$45——73
Joe Theismann #322015 Panini Flawless FootballNear Mint$45$45——74
Joe Theismann #112018 Donruss Football Canton KingsNear Mint$44$44——75
Joe Theismann #151991 All World Cfl FootballPSA 10$42$1——76
Joe Theismann #4502023 Topps Composite FootballPSA 10$40$3——77
Joe Theismann #1292019 Panini Spectra FootballNear Mint$40$40——78
Joe Theismann #992024 Topps Resurgence FootballPSA 10$39$6——79
Joe Theismann #22024 Panini Contenders NFL Ink AutographNear Mint$35$35——80
Joe Theismann #722011 Upper Deck College Legends Autograph FootballPSA 10$35$19——81
Joe Theismann #741977 Topps Mexican FootballNear Mint$35$35——82
Joe Theismann #3002022 Panini Prestige FootballNear Mint$35$35——83
Joe Theismann #1861981 Topps Stickers FootballPSA 10$35$2——84
Joe Theismann #PP-JTN2024 Panini Encore Pacific Penmanship FootballNear Mint$34$34——85
Joe Theismann #222023 Panini Chronicles Draft Picks Illusions FootballPSA 10$33$23——86
Joe Theismann #RS-JT2021 Panini Donruss Optic Retro Series FootballPSA 10$33$20——87
Joe Theismann #US-JT2004 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection Signatures FootballNear Mint$31$31——88
Joe Theismann #1242021 Panini Playoff FootballPSA 10$31$24——89
Joe Theismann #1242021 Panini Playoff Football AutographsPSA 8$30———90Joe Theismann #XX1984 7 Eleven Discs FootballPSA 10$30———91
Joe Theismann #2172021 Panini Prizm No Huddle FootballNear Mint$30$30——92
Joe Theismann #1002024 Topps Midnight FootballNear Mint$30$30——93
Joe Theismann #GF-JT2024 Panini Gold Standard Gold Fingers FootballNear Mint$30$30——94
Joe Theismann #SS-JTH2021 Panini Elements Football Steel SignaturesNear Mint$29$29——95
Joe Theismann #91989 Pro Set Announcers FootballPSA 10$28$2——96
Joe Theismann #A-JT32025 Leaf Optichrome Aquatic Auto FootballNear Mint$27$27——97
Joe Theismann #XO-JT2016 Panini Playbook Football X's and O's SignaturesNear Mint$26$26——98
Joe Theismann #202024 Panini Immaculate Eye Black FootballNear Mint$25$25——99
Joe Theismann #ZG-JO2022 Zenith Football Z GraphsNear Mint$25$25——100
Joe Theismann #1172002 Panini Donruss Classics FootballNear Mint$24$24——Sets with Joe Theismann cards
Joe Theismann appears in 375 sets. Open one for the most valuable cards in it.
- 2018 Panini Honors Recollection Football15 cards
- 2008 SP Authentic Football By the Letter Autographs10 cards
- 1997 Upper Deck Legends Football3 cards
- 2006 Upper Deck Heroes Football3 cards
- 1983 Topps Stickers Football2 cards
- 1984 Topps Football2 cards
- 1997 Leaf Football Reproductions2 cards
- 2001 Topps Archives Football2 cards
- 2015 Donruss Signature Series Football2 cards
- 2016 Panini Honors Football Recollection Collection2 cards
- 2016 Panini Limited Football Limited Monikers2 cards
- 1971 O Pee Chee Cfl Football1 card
- 1972 O Pee Chee Cfl Football1 card
- 1975 Topps Football1 card
- 1976 Topps Football1 card
- 1977 Topps Football1 card
- 1977 Topps Mexican Football1 card
- 1978 Topps Football1 card
- 1979 Topps Football1 card
- 1980 Topps Football1 card
- 1980 Topps Super Football1 card
- 1981 Topps Coke Football1 card
- 1981 Topps Football1 card
- 1981 Topps Stickers Football1 card
- 1982 Topps Football1 card
- 1982 Topps Stickers Football1 card
- 1983 Topps Football1 card
- 1983 Topps Football Stickers1 card
- 1983 Topps Stickers Insert Football1 card
- 1984 7 Eleven Discs Football1 card
- 1984 Topps Glossy Send In Football1 card
- 1984 Topps Stickers Football1 card
- 1985 Topps Football1 card
- 1986 Topps Football1 card
- 1989 Pro Set Announcers Football1 card
- 1989 Pro Set Football Accouncers1 card
- 1990 Notre Dame Collegiate Collection Football1 card
- 1990 Pro Set Super Bowl 160 Football1 card
- 1991 All World Cfl Football1 card
- 1991 Proline Portraits Football1 card