Most Valuable John Elway Cards
Every John Elway card in the catalog, ranked by market value, with live prices, trends and real sold comps.
John Elway Cards1000
Market Value (PSA 10)$53,586
Market Value (Raw NM)$35,814
Avg 30d Change+3.43%
Top CardJohn Elway
#CardConditionPriceRaw Price30d %RarityTrend
1John Elway #TA-JE2025 Topps Chrome Football Tecmo AutographsPSA 10$20,342$4,530——2
John Elway #921999 Metal Universe FootballPSA 9$11,013$2,100——3
John Elway #2381985 Topps FootballPSA 10$7,930$3——4
John Elway #62024 Panini Flawless Football Signature Gems PlatinumNear Mint$4,305$4,305——5
John Elway #881997 Metal Universe FootballPSA 9$4,013$2,453——6
John Elway #2972022 Panini Mosaic FootballPSA 10$2,499$140——7
John Elway #391997 Skybox E X2000 FootballPSA 9$1,700$1,000——8
John Elway #691996 Select Certified FootballPSA 9$1,325$400——9
John Elway #22024 Panini Flawless Football Champions 2x SignaturesNear Mint$1,150$1,150——10
John Elway #62023 Panini Flawless Football Honored InkPSA 10$910$350——11
John Elway #91998 Leaf Rookies & Stars Football CrusadeNear Mint$881$881——12
John Elway #HZS-JE2024 Topps Midnight Football Horizon SignaturesPSA 10$875$150——13
John Elway #182024 Clearly Donruss Football UptownsPSA 10$850$208——14
John Elway #DT-242021 Panini Donruss Downtown FootballPSA 10$845$428——15
John Elway #42024 Panini Eminence HOF Patch Autograph FootballNear Mint$810$810——16
John Elway #T61999 Topps Finest Team FootballPSA 10$762$128——17
John Elway #71998 Flair Showcase Legacy Collection FootballPSA 10$735$118——18
John Elway #892024 Panini Prizm FootballNear Mint$700$700——19
John Elway #1821995 Topps Finest Boosters FootballPSA 10$700$29——20
John Elway #102022 Clearly Donruss Football Clearly Champions AutographsPSA 8$636$121——21
John Elway #PB-31995 Pacific Crown Royale Pro Bowl Die Cuts FootballPSA 10$628$20——22
John Elway #P3341997 Ultra FootballNear Mint$625$625——23John Elway #FSA-JE2014 Topps Five Star Football AutographsBGS 9$610———24
John Elway #71997 Donruss Preferred Precious Metals FootballNear Mint$608$608——25
John Elway #492025 Panini Prizm Black FootballPSA 10$595$400——26
John Elway #LY-12025 Topps Cosmic Chrome Light Years FootballPSA 10$506$94——27
John Elway #482021 Donruss Elite Football 2001 ElitePSA 9$500$200——28
John Elway #241998 Playoff Contenders Ticket FootballPSA 10$500$5——29
John Elway #72024 Panini Immaculate Nameplate Nobility Signature FootballNear Mint$472$472——30
John Elway #42025 Panini Flawless Football Patch AutographsNear Mint$450$450——31
John Elway #31985 Topps NFL Star SetPSA 10$435$3——32
John Elway #131982 Tcma Oneonta Yankees BaseballNear Mint$413$413——33
John Elway #BA-JEL2024 Topps Chrome Football AutographsNear Mint$400$400——34
John Elway #282024 Topps Chrome Cosmic FootballNear Mint$400$400——35
John Elway #SKS-JEL2022 Panini Spectra Football Sky High SignaturesNear Mint$378$378——36
John Elway #3602020 Panini One FootballNear Mint$372$372——37
John Elway #FFS-JE2024 Topps Chrome Cosmic Football First Flight SignaturesPSA 10$360$250——38
John Elway #601999 Topps Chrome FootballPSA 10$356$35——39
John Elway #602024 Panini Obsidian FootballNear Mint$350$350——40
John Elway #312020 Panini Chronicles FootballNear Mint$336$336——41
John Elway #272024 Panini Impeccable Silver USA Flag FootballNear Mint$335$335——42
John Elway #SS-JE2022 Panini Elements Football Steel SignaturesPSA 10$327$149——43
John Elway #92024 Clearly Donruss Retro 1994 Autograph FootballPSA 10$325———44
John Elway #141998 SPx FootballNear Mint$300$300——45
John Elway #3411998 Spx Finite FootballNear Mint$289$289——46
John Elway #202024 Panini Eminence Prominent Patch FootballNear Mint$270$270——47
John Elway #632010 Topps Football Anniversary ReprintsPSA 9$270$3——48
John Elway #HOCA-JE2025 Topps Chrome Sapphire Hall Of Chrome Autograph FootballNear Mint$255$255——49
John Elway #302023 Topps Motif FootballPSA 9$251$30——50
John Elway #11998 Topps Gold Label FootballPSA 9$250$114——51
John Elway #112024 Panini Contenders Optic Football All-Time Contenders AutographsNear Mint$248$248——52
John Elway #552023 Panini Donruss Optic FootballPSA 10$230$107——53
John Elway #1001989 Pro Set FootballPSA 10$230$4——54
John Elway #1972023 Panini Select Draft Picks FootballNear Mint$229$229——55
John Elway #1112000 Leaf Certified FootballNear Mint$228$228——56
John Elway #632022 Panini Donruss Optic FootballNear Mint$225$225——57
John Elway #212025 Panini Impeccable FootballNear Mint$225$225——58
John Elway #AEA-JE2024 Topps Chrome Football Chrome All-Etch AutographsPSA 10$224$101——59
John Elway #3001997 Topps Finest FootballPSA 9$220$24——60
John Elway #5401994 Topps FootballPSA 10$219$3——61
John Elway #FM32000 Topps Finest Moments FootballNear Mint$208$208——62
John Elway #672020 Panini Mosaic FootballBGS 9$200$123——63
John Elway #1301995 Pacific Crown Royale FootballPSA 10$200$8——64
John Elway #852020 Panini Flawless FootballNear Mint$190$190——65
John Elway #II-131995 Pro Line Series II FootballPSA 10$185$2——66
John Elway #61987 Topps American UK FootballPSA 10$182$8——67
John Elway #2461995 Pinnacle FootballPSA 10$175$8——68
John Elway #72023 Topps Composite Football Base Topps Chrome SetSGC 9$175$41——69
John Elway #231988 Topps FootballPSA 10$174$2——70
John Elway #902021 Panini Flawless FootballNear Mint$174$174——71
John Elway #92023 Panini Illusions Football FunkadelicPSA 10$164$115——72
John Elway #CTC-JEY2024 Panini Contenders Football Contenders to Canton AutographsNear Mint$160$160——73
John Elway #VCA-JE2024 Topps Signature Class Football Veterans Class AutographsNear Mint$160$160——74
John Elway #SBD-JEL2022 Panini Gold Standard Football Super Bowl Diamond SignaturesNear Mint$158$158——75
John Elway #CCA-JE2023 Topps Motif Canvas Champions Autograph FootballNear Mint$158$158——76
John Elway #241985 Topps Stickers FootballPSA 10$153$2——77
John Elway #631990 Action Packed FootballPSA 10$151$2——78
John Elway #1431998 Upper Deck Black Diamond FootballPSA 10$150$140——79
John Elway #C-162024 Topps Resurgence Football ConductorsNear Mint$150$150——80
John Elway #762022 Panini Flawless FootballNear Mint$147$147——81
John Elway #932022 Panini Prizm No Huddle FootballNear Mint$140$140——82
John Elway #161995 Summit FootballPSA 10$130$4——83
John Elway #E201997 Pinnacle Football EpixPSA 10$127$7——84
John Elway #292000 Playoff Contenders FootballPSA 9.5$126$35——85
John Elway #111999 Panini Donruss Preferred FootballPSA 10$125$13——86
John Elway #1001993 Topps FootballPSA 10$119$3——87
John Elway #321995 Panini Score FootballPSA 10$119$3——88
John Elway #MY-102021 Panini Donruss Optic Mythical FootballPSA 9$115$45——89
John Elway #321995 Pinnacle FootballPSA 10$115$20——90
John Elway #101993 Fleer Gameday FootballPSA 10$114$2——91
John Elway #361994 Pacific Prisms FootballPSA 10$113$11——92
John Elway #4861995 Ultra FootballPSA 10$106$2——93
John Elway #862015 Panini Flawless FootballPSA 9$103$70——94
John Elway #802021 Panini Playoff FootballNear Mint$102$102——95
John Elway #832022 Panini Score FootballNear Mint$101$101——96
John Elway #322021 Panini Gold Standard FootballNear Mint$100$100——97
John Elway #322024 Topps Resurgence FootballNear Mint$100$100——98
John Elway #DP-JE12024 Leaf Vivid Dazzling Performers Autograph FootballNear Mint$100$100——99
John Elway #AP-71995 Sp All Pro FootballPSA 10$100$3——100
John Elway #OF-JE12024 Press Pass Premium On Fire Autograph FootballNear Mint$100$100——Sets with John Elway cards
John Elway appears in 938 sets. Open one for the most valuable cards in it.
- 1995 Pinnacle Club Collection Football8 cards
- 2009 Topps Football Patch Relics5 cards
- 2023 Topps Composite Football5 cards
- 1998 Ultra Football4 cards
- 2019 Score Football Score Buyback Autographs4 cards
- 1995 Stadium Club Football3 cards
- 1995 Summit Football3 cards
- 1997 Ultra Football3 cards
- 1998 Spx Finite Football3 cards
- 2012 Topps Football Game Winning Drives Film Strips3 cards
- 2016 Panini Immaculate Collection Football Immaculate Moments Autographs3 cards
- 1991 Pro Set Football2 cards
- 1992 Pro Line Profiles Autographs Football2 cards
- 1992 Pro Line Profiles Football2 cards
- 1992 Skybox Primetime Football2 cards
- 1994 Sportflics Football2 cards
- 1995 Classic NFL Experience2 cards
- 1995 Pinnacle Football2 cards
- 1995 Sportflix Football2 cards
- 1996 Pacific Card Supial Football2 cards
- 1996 Pinnacle Football2 cards
- 1997 Pinnacle Mint Coins Football2 cards
- 1997 Score Football2 cards
- 1998 Upper Deck Black Diamond Football2 cards
- 1998 Upper Deck UD3 Football2 cards
- 1999 Panini Score Football2 cards
- 2000 Panini Donruss Preferred Football2 cards
- 2008 Sp Rookie Edition Football2 cards
- 2009 Topps Football Postseason Patches2 cards
- 2010 Panini Classics Football2 cards
- 2015 Donruss Signature Series Football2 cards
- 2015 Panini Gridiron Kings Football Royal Performances2 cards
- 2015 Topps Definitive Collection Football Definitive Patch2 cards
- 2015 Topps Definitive Collection Football Legendary Autograph2 cards
- 2015 Topps Dynasty Baseball Autographed Patches2 cards
- 2017 Panini Classics Football Recollection Collection2 cards
- 2017 Panini Impeccable Football Impeccable Victory2 cards
- 2018 Panini Plates & Patches Football Printing Plates Autographs2 cards
- 2021 Donruss Football2 cards
- 2022 Panini Legacy Football Dare to Tear2 cards