Most Valuable Matthew Schaefer Cards
Every Matthew Schaefer card in the catalog, ranked by market value, with live prices, trends and real sold comps.
Matthew Schaefer Cards253
Market Value (PSA 10)$216,485
Market Value (Raw NM)$133,422
Avg 30d Change-11.51%
Top CardMatthew Schaefer
#CardConditionPriceRaw Price30d %RarityTrend
1Matthew Schaefer #52025-26 Upper Deck Star Rookies HockeyPSA 10$21,464$4,890——2Matthew Schaefer #F-MS2025-26 SPx Hockey Blue Autograph Parallel - RookiesNear Mint$18,500$18,500——3
Matthew Schaefer #1682025-26 SP Authentic HockeyPSA 10$15,363$6,456——4
Matthew Schaefer #R-MS2025-26 O-Pee-Chee Platinum Hockey Rookie AutographsPSA 10$14,411$7,077——5
Matthew Schaefer #CC-MS2025-26 Upper Deck Clear Cut Hockey AutographsNear Mint$10,000$10,000——6
Matthew Schaefer (Oversized Young Guns) #4512025-26 Upper Deck HockeyPSA 10$7,937$7,800——7
Matthew Schaefer #4512025 Upper Deck Series 2 HockeyPSA 10$7,921$5,499——8
Matthew Schaefer #2682025-26 O-Pee-Chee Platinum HockeyPSA 10$7,000$1,270——9
Matthew Schaefer (Mixed Media Variants) #2682025-26 O-Pee-Chee Platinum HockeyPSA 10$7,000$1,270——10
Matthew Schaefer #DZ-572025-26 Upper Deck Hockey DazzlersPSA 10$6,287$1,418——11
Matthew Schaefer #DZ-572025 Upper Deck Series 2 Dazzlers HockeyPSA 10$6,287$1,418——12
Matthew Schaefer #AR-MS2025 Upper Deck Allure HockeyPSA 10$5,801$1,435——13
Matthew Schaefer #DDM-MS2025-26 SP Game Used Hockey Draft Day MarksPSA 10$5,184$1,184——14
Matthew Schaefer #DTA-MS2025-26 Upper Deck Credentials Hockey Debut Ticket Access AutographsPSA 10$4,824$1,059——15
Matthew Schaefer #5922025-26 O-Pee-Chee HockeyPSA 10$4,800$440——16Matthew Schaefer #ADT-MS2025-26 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection Hockey Debut Threads Autograph PatchNear Mint$4,659$4,659——17
Matthew Schaefer #RGS-MS2025-26 Upper Deck Black Diamond Hockey Rookie Gems SignaturesPSA 10$4,072$1,975——18
Matthew Schaefer #I2025 Upper Deck Artifacts Autograph Rookie Redemption HockeyPSA 10$3,697$847——19
Matthew Schaefer #IRS-MS2025-26 SP Game Used Hockey Inked Rookie SweatersPSA 10$3,396$774——20
Matthew Schaefer #JRP-MS2025-26 SP Game Used Hockey Rookie Jumbo PatchPSA 10$3,300$755——21
Matthew Schaefer #FST-82025-26 Fleer Ultra Hockey Ultra Future StarsPSA 10$3,244$734——22
Matthew Schaefer #F-MS2025 Spx Autograph Rookie HockeyPSA 10$3,122$682——23
Matthew Schaefer #HPA-MS2026 Upper Deck Nscc Hot Prospect Autograph HockeyPSA 10$3,091$650——24
Matthew Schaefer #DA-MS2025-26 Upper Deck Clear Cut Hockey Dazzlers AutographsNear Mint$2,900$2,900——25
Matthew Schaefer #52025-26 Upper Deck Star Rookies Hockey Base Star Rookies AutographsLightly Played$2,878$10——26
Matthew Schaefer #AR-MS2025-26 SP Game Used Hockey Authentic RookiesPSA 10$2,870$1,903——27
Matthew Schaefer #1642025-26 Fleer Ultra HockeyPSA 10$2,785$633——28
Matthew Schaefer #SMA-MS2025-26 Upper Deck Clear Cut Hockey 2005-06 Upper Deck Stars in the MakingPSA 10$2,676$1,238——29
Matthew Schaefer #PC-372025 Upper Deck Series 2 Population Count HockeyNear Mint$2,540$2,540——30
Matthew Schaefer #1112025-26 SP HockeyPSA 10$2,485$1,038——31
Matthew Schaefer #1212025-26 Upper Deck Credentials HockeyPSA 10$2,288$500——32
Matthew Schaefer #PP-42025 Skybox Metal Universe Premium Prospects Autograph HockeyPSA 10$2,281$500——33
Matthew Schaefer #P-72025 Sp Authentic Pageantry Autograph HockeyPSA 10$2,243$477——34
Matthew Schaefer #SOTTR-SR2025-26 SP Authentic Hockey Sign of the Times RookiesPSA 10$2,108$436——35
Matthew Schaefer #BDR-MS2025 Upper Deck Black Diamond Rookie Relic HockeyNear Mint$2,052$2,052——36
Matthew Schaefer #RS-212025-26 Fleer Ultra Hockey Rising StarsPSA 10$2,022$458——37
Matthew Schaefer #3622023 Upper Deck Chl HockeyPSA 10$2,000$237——38
Matthew Schaefer #R-962025-26 O-Pee-Chee Platinum Hockey RetroPSA 10$1,973$425——39
Matthew Schaefer #CF-MS2025 Upper Deck Allure Color Flow HockeyPSA 10$1,863$700——40
Matthew Schaefer #1942025-26 Flair HockeyPSA 10$1,822$500——41
Matthew Schaefer #SR-162025 Upper Deck Extended Series Synergy Rookie HockeyPSA 10$1,814$387——42Matthew Schaefer #F-262025-26 Upper Deck Hockey FluorescencePSA 10$1,772$1,176——43
Matthew Schaefer #F-262025 Upper Deck Series 2 Fluorescence HockeyPSA 10$1,772$1,176——44
Matthew Schaefer #2112025-26 Parkhurst HockeyNear Mint$1,637$1,637——45
Matthew Schaefer #RTL-MS2025-26 Upper Deck Black Diamond Hockey Rookie Team Logo Jumbo Patch AutoNear Mint$1,525$1,525——46
Matthew Schaefer #3D-MS2025-26 O-Pee-Chee Hockey 3D Marquee RookiePSA 10$1,468$335——47
Matthew Schaefer #852024 Upper Deck Team Canada Juniors HockeyPSA 9$1,425$700——48
Matthew Schaefer #1132025-26 SkyBox Metal Universe HockeyPSA 10$1,358$565——49
Matthew Schaefer #692024 Upper Deck Team Canada Juniors HockeyPSA 10$1,347$306——50
Matthew Schaefer #382025 Upper Deck Team Canada Juniors HockeyPSA 10$1,347$570——51
Matthew Schaefer #MS-202025-26 Fleer Ultra Hockey Mise en ScenePSA 10$1,330$299——52
Matthew Schaefer #SY-12025 Upper Deck Credentials Sensational Youth Autograph HockeyPSA 10$1,296$280——53
Matthew Schaefer #2182025 Upper Deck Artifacts Rookie Redemption HockeyPSA 10$1,293$288——54
Matthew Schaefer #AR-MS2025-26 Upper Deck Allure Hockey Base Extended RookiesNear Mint$1,250$1,250——55Matthew Schaefer #PC-372025-26 Upper Deck Hockey Population CountNear Mint$1,222$1,222——56
Matthew Schaefer #252024 Upper Deck Team Canada Juniors HockeyPSA 10$1,152$338——57
Matthew Schaefer #1092025-26 SPx HockeyPSA 10$1,097$236——58
Matthew Schaefer #PP-152025-26 SkyBox Metal Universe Hockey Platinum PortraitsNear Mint$1,000$1,000——59Matthew Schaefer #INC-52025-26 Upper Deck Hockey IncarnationsNear Mint$993$993——60
Matthew Schaefer #RTL-MS2025-26 Upper Deck Black Diamond Hockey Rookie Team Logo Jumbo Puzzle PatchPSA 10$962$239——61
Matthew Schaefer #R-MS2025-26 Upper Deck Black Diamond Hockey Exquisite RookiesPSA 10$961$411——62
Matthew Schaefer #7462025 Upper Deck Extended Series HockeyPSA 10$952$200——63
Matthew Schaefer #C-3652025 Upper Deck Extended Series UD Canvas HockeyPSA 10$903$375——64
Matthew Schaefer #UI-MS2025 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection Introductions Auto HockeyNear Mint$870$870——65
Matthew Schaefer #DTAA-MS2025-26 Upper Deck Credentials Hockey Acetate Debut Ticket AccessNear Mint$852$852-26.78%—66
Matthew Schaefer #RS-MS2025-26 SP Game Used Hockey Rookie SweatersPSA 10$842$187——67
Matthew Schaefer #CD-MS2025-26 Upper Deck Clear Cut Hockey Canvas Rookie DebutsPSA 10$824$166——68
Matthew Schaefer #BDB-MS2025-26 Upper Deck Black Diamond HockeyNear Mint$818$818——69
Matthew Schaefer #202025 Fleer Ultra Team HockeyPSA 10$818$181——70
Matthew Schaefer #UP-MS2025-26 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection Hockey Ultimate Phenoms AutographsNear Mint$811$811——71
Matthew Schaefer #4512025-26 Upper Deck Hockey Young Guns AcetatePSA 10$810$175——72
Matthew Schaefer #CF-MS2025-26 Upper Deck Allure Hockey Color Flow Extended RookiesNear Mint$800$800——73
Matthew Schaefer #RR-182025 Upper Deck Extended Series Rookie Reflections HockeyPSA 10$778$163——74
Matthew Schaefer #RR-182025-26 Upper Deck Hockey Rookie ReflectionsPSA 10$778$163——75
Matthew Schaefer #RG-MS2025-26 Upper Deck Black Diamond Hockey Rookie GemsPSA 10$750$455——76
Matthew Schaefer #DM-22025-26 SkyBox Metal Universe Hockey Dark MatterPSA 10$748$323——77
Matthew Schaefer #E-1492025 Upper Deck Series 2 Encore HockeyPSA 10$733$160——78
Matthew Schaefer #EST-MS2025 Parkhurst 1951 Autograph HockeyNear Mint$650$650——79
Matthew Schaefer #T-312025 Upper Deck Extended Trilogy Rookie Premieres HockeyPSA 10$649$135——80
Matthew Schaefer #P-922025 O Pee Chee Premier HockeyPSA 10$639$142——81
Matthew Schaefer #SP12025 Upper Deck Artifacts Horizontal Rookie Redemption HockeyPSA 10$619$136——82
Matthew Schaefer #BL-162026 Upper Deck Team Canada Blueliners Autograph HockeyNear Mint$610$610——83
Matthew Schaefer #RA-MS2025 Upper Deck Clear Cut Retro Autograph HockeyNear Mint$604$604——84
Matthew Schaefer #822024 Upper Deck Chl HockeyPSA 10$603$153——85
Matthew Schaefer #EST-MS2025-26 Parkhurst Hockey Est. 1951 AutographsNear Mint$600$600——86
Matthew Schaefer #C-2592025 Upper Deck Series 2 UD Canvas HockeyPSA 10$573$124——87
Matthew Schaefer #RA-MS2025-26 Upper Deck Clear Cut Hockey Retro AutosNear Mint$558$558——88
Matthew Schaefer #182025 Skybox Metal Universe Copperheads HockeyNear Mint$550$550——89
Matthew Schaefer #SSR-MS2025-26 SPx Hockey Rookie SuperScriptsLightly Played$516$505——90
Matthew Schaefer #PP-102025 Upper Deck Extended Series Pros And Prospects HockeyPSA 10$498$102——91
Matthew Schaefer #BC-22025-26 Upper Deck Credentials Hockey Bright CellysNear Mint$488$488——92
Matthew Schaefer #PWR-MS2025-26 Parkhurst Hockey Penworks RookiesNear Mint$480$480——93
Matthew Schaefer #1092025 Upper Deck Premier HockeyNear Mint$480$480——94
Matthew Schaefer #BCR-MS2025-26 Upper Deck Black Diamond Hockey Band of Color RookiesNear Mint$468$468——95
Matthew Schaefer #I2025 Upper Deck Artifacts Rookie Relic HockeyPSA 10$463$100——96
Matthew Schaefer #182025 Skybox Metal Universe A Cut Above HockeyPSA 10$445$92——97
Matthew Schaefer #USR-MS2025-26 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection Hockey Ultimate Signatures RookiesNear Mint$442$442——98
Matthew Schaefer #P-322025 Upper Deck Series 2 UD Portraits HockeyPSA 10$437$388——99
Matthew Schaefer #P-322025-26 Upper Deck Hockey UD PortraitsPSA 10$437$388——100
Matthew Schaefer #WF-92025-26 Flair Hockey Wave of the FuturePSA 10$430$97——Sets with Matthew Schaefer cards
Matthew Schaefer appears in 240 sets. Open one for the most valuable cards in it.
- 2025 Upper Deck Game Dated Moments Hockey5 cards
- 2024 Upper Deck Team Canada Juniors Hockey4 cards
- 2025 Upper Deck Team Canada Juniors Hockey3 cards
- 2025-26 Upper Deck Hockey3 cards
- 2025-26 O-Pee-Chee Platinum Hockey2 cards
- 2025-26 SPx Hockey2 cards
- 2023 Upper Deck Chl First Draft Hockey1 card
- 2023 Upper Deck Chl Hockey1 card
- 2024 Upper Deck Chl Hockey1 card
- 2024 Upper Deck Team Canada Juniors Future Stardom Hockey1 card
- 2024 Upper Deck Team Canada Juniors Prospectus Momentous Autograph Hockey1 card
- 2024 Upper Deck Team Canada Juniors Prospectus Momentous Hockey1 card
- 2025 Fleer Ultra Team Gold Gold Autograph Hockey1 card
- 2025 Fleer Ultra Team Hockey1 card
- 2025 O Pee Chee Platinum Retro Red Autograph Hockey1 card
- 2025 O Pee Chee Premier Hockey1 card
- 2025 O Pee Chee Premier Jumbo Hockey1 card
- 2025 Parkhurst 1951 Autograph Hockey1 card
- 2025 Skybox Metal Universe A Cut Above Hockey1 card
- 2025 Skybox Metal Universe Copperheads Hockey1 card
- 2025 Skybox Metal Universe Fresh Foundation Autograph Hockey1 card
- 2025 Skybox Metal Universe Premium Prospects Autograph Hockey1 card
- 2025 Sp Authentic Pageantry Autograph Hockey1 card
- 2025 Spx Autograph Rookie Hockey1 card
- 2025 Upper Deck Allure Color Flow Hockey1 card
- 2025 Upper Deck Allure Hockey1 card
- 2025 Upper Deck Artifacts Autograph Rookie Redemption Hockey1 card
- 2025 Upper Deck Artifacts Autograph Rookie Relic Hockey1 card
- 2025 Upper Deck Artifacts Horizontal Autograph Rookie Redemption Hockey1 card
- 2025 Upper Deck Artifacts Horizontal Rookie Redemption Hockey1 card
- 2025 Upper Deck Artifacts Rookie Redemption Hockey1 card
- 2025 Upper Deck Artifacts Rookie Relic Hockey1 card
- 2025 Upper Deck Black Diamond Rookie Relic Hockey1 card
- 2025 Upper Deck Clear Cut Dazzlers Hockey1 card
- 2025 Upper Deck Clear Cut Hockey1 card
- 2025 Upper Deck Clear Cut Retro Autograph Hockey1 card
- 2025 Upper Deck Clear Cut Rookie Tribute Autograph Hockey1 card
- 2025 Upper Deck Credentials Sensational Youth Autograph Hockey1 card
- 2025 Upper Deck Credentials Vip Black Ticket Access Achievements Hockey1 card
- 2025 Upper Deck Dc X Fanimation Hockey1 card