Most Valuable Paul O'Neill Cards
Every Paul O'Neill card in the catalog, ranked by market value, with live prices, trends and real sold comps.
Paul O'Neill Cards873
Market Value (PSA 10)$11,791
Market Value (Raw NM)$9,265
Avg 30d Change+1.87%
Top CardPaul O'Neill
#CardConditionPriceRaw Price30d %RarityTrend
1Paul O'Neill #171999 SkyBox Premium BaseballPSA 6$761$2——2
Paul O'Neill #CBA-PO2026 Topps Chrome Black Baseball AutographsNear Mint$750$750——3
Paul O'Neill #CLA-PO2026 Topps Chrome Baseball Chrome Legend AutographsPSA 10$602$145——4
Paul O'Neill #1141996 Topps Chrome BaseballPSA 10$584$20——5
Paul O'Neill #SCBA-PO2024 Stadium Club Baseball AutographsNear Mint$499$499——6
Paul O'Neill #WSCA-PO2026 Topps Chrome Baseball World Series Champions AutographsPSA 10$475$92——7
Paul O'Neill #CBA-PO2023 Topps Chrome Black Baseball AutographsNear Mint$450$450——8
Paul O'Neill #95CA-PO2025 Topps Archives Baseball 1995 Topps Cyberstats AutographsNear Mint$425$425——9
Paul O'Neill #89BA-PO2024 Topps 1989 Autograph BaseballNear Mint$400$400——10
Paul O'Neill #PO1999 Sp Signature Autographs BaseballPSA 10$400$34——11
Paul O'Neill #1701993 Finest BaseballPSA 10$392$76——12
Paul O'Neill #1211997 Flair Showcase Legacy Collection BaseballPSA 10$350$53——13
Paul O'Neill #81TG1999 Fleer Brilliants BaseballNear Mint$313$313——14
Paul O'Neill #1172002 Topps Chrome BaseballPSA 10$305$18——15
Paul O'Neill #731999 Topps Gold Label BaseballNear Mint$300$300——16Paul O'Neill #712001 Topps Stars Baseball EliminationPSA 6$300$30——17
Paul O'Neill #2411998 Bowman Chrome BaseballPSA 10$280$2——18
Paul O'Neill #PA-PO2025 Topps Pristine Autograph BaseballNear Mint$250$250——19
Paul O'Neill #932023 Topps Chrome Platinum Anniversary BaseballNear Mint$250$250——20
Paul O'Neill #MA-PO2024 Topps Allen & Ginter Mini Baseball AutographNear Mint$215$215——21
Paul O'Neill #TA-PO2026 Topps Tribute Baseball Tribute AutographsPSA 10$207$38——22
Paul O'Neill #TA-PO2024 Topps Tribute Baseball AutographsNear Mint$200$200——23
Paul O'Neill #2081995 Upper Deck BaseballPSA 10$194$5——24
Paul O'Neill #1262012 Panini Prizm BaseballPSA 10$176$5——25
Paul O'Neill #PA-PO2026 Topps Pristine Baseball Pristine AutographsPSA 10$171$56——26
Paul O'Neill #3221998 Topps Chrome BaseballPSA 9$170$20——27
Paul O'Neill #II-PO2024 Panini Flawless Baseball Iconic InkPSA 10$165$36——28
Paul O'Neill #371986 Donruss BaseballPSA 10$161$2——29
Paul O'Neill #3162025 Topps Chrome Platinum BaseballPSA 10$157$40——30
Paul O'Neill #TSS-PO2025 Topps Tier One Top Shelf Signature BaseballPSA 10$154$39——31
Paul O'Neill #331998 Topps Gold Label BaseballPSA 10$150$150——33
Paul O'Neill #SS102024 Topps Black & White Baseball Shutter SpeedPSA 10$150$50——34
Paul O'Neill #212001 Topps Chrome BaseballPSA 9$150$2——35
Paul O'Neill #1221991 Topps Desert Shield BaseballPSA 10$141$12——36
Paul O'Neill #SPTRA-PO2025 Topps Museum Collection Single Player Signature Swatch Triple Relic Autograph BaseballPSA 10$138$25——37Paul O'Neill #TAR-PO2011 Topps Tribute Baseball Autograph RelicsNear Mint$132$132——38
Paul O'Neill #PO2001 Sp Game Bat Piece Of The Game BaseballPSA 10$128$6——39
Paul O'Neill #BA-PO12025 Leaf A Bronx Legacy Autograph BaseballPSA 10$126$24——40
Paul O'Neill #101999 Skybox Molten Metal Xplosion BaseballPSA 10$125$4——41
Paul O'Neill #BSA2-PO2025 Topps Baseball Stars AutographsPSA 10$125$65——42
Paul O'Neill #201995 Stadium Club Baseball Ring LeadersPSA 10$122$3——43
Paul O'Neill #772016 Topps Tribute BaseballNear Mint$120$120——44
Paul O'Neill #2271991 Score BaseballSGC AUTHENTIC$120$0——45
Paul O'Neill #2411998 Bowman Chrome Golden Anniversary BaseballNear Mint$120$120——46
Paul O'Neill #2761993 Topps BaseballSGC AUTHENTIC$120$1——47
Paul O'Neill #TA-PO2016 Topps Tribute Baseball AutographsNear Mint$117$117——48
Paul O'Neill #371998 Topps Tek BaseballNear Mint$115$115——49
Paul O'Neill #HT-PO2014 Topps High Tek BaseballNear Mint$115$115——50
Paul O'Neill #201999 Bowman Chrome International BaseballPSA 9$110$1——51
Paul O'Neill #201999 Bowman Chrome Gold BaseballPSA 9$105———52
Paul O'Neill #PPA-PO2024 Topps Tier One Baseball Prime Performers AutographsPSA 10$103$30——53
Paul O'Neill #AA-PO2024 Topps Museum Collection Baseball Archival AutographsPSA 10$101$21——54
Paul O'Neill #US312011 Topps Update BaseballPSA 10$100$15——55
Paul O'Neill #87TBA-PO2022 Topps Clearly Authentic 1987 Topps Baseball AutographsPSA 10$100$50——56
Paul O'Neill #1661999 Pacific Omega BaseballPSA 10$99$7——57
Paul O'Neill #491990 Bowman BaseballPSA 9$99$2——58
Paul O'Neill #491996 Select Certified BaseballPSA 9$99$23——59
Paul O'Neill #PA-PO2021 Topps Chrome Platinum Anniversary Baseball AutographsNear Mint$93$93——60
Paul O'Neill #1211997 Flair Showcase BaseballPSA 10$92$3——61
Paul O'Neill #68AA-PO2024 Topps Archives Baseball 1968 Topps Action All-Stars AutographsPSA 10$91$23——62
Paul O'Neill #221995 Stadium Club Clear Cut BaseballPSA 10$89$2——63
Paul O'Neill #6041989 Topps BaseballPSA 10$89$1——64
Paul O'Neill #511999 Finest BaseballNear Mint$87$87——65
Paul O'Neill #171996 Circa Baseball BossPSA 10$86$2——66
Paul O'Neill #DK-71995 Donruss Baseball Diamond KingsPSA 10$86$2——67
Paul O'Neill #821997 Bowman Chrome BaseballPSA 9$85$9——68
Paul O'Neill #42024 Panini Prizm Baseball Throwback SignaturesPSA 9.5$83$60——69
Paul O'Neill #171987 Sportflics Rookies BaseballPSA 10$80$1——70
Paul O'Neill #181998 Topps Stars BaseballNear Mint$80$80——71
Paul O'Neill #261995 Topps Diii BaseballPSA 10$76$1——72
Paul O'Neill #501995 Panini Donruss Elite BaseballPSA 10$75$10——73
Paul O'Neill #4271990 Fleer BaseballPSA 10$74$1——74
Paul O'Neill #SCBA-PO2022 Stadium Club Baseball AutographsPSA 10$73$56——75
Paul O'Neill #101999 SkyBox Molten Metal BaseballPSA 10$72$2——76
Paul O'Neill #921996 E Motion XL BaseballPSA 10$72$1——77
Paul O'Neill #2761993 Topps Gold BaseballPSA 10$69$2——78
Paul O'Neill #FSA-PO2022 Topps Five Star Baseball AutographsPSA 10$67$49——79
Paul O'Neill #3062000 MLB ShowdownPSA 10$66$2——80
Paul O'Neill #1441998 Metal Universe BaseballPSA 10$64$1——81
Paul O'Neill #8992026 Topps Living BaseballPSA 10$63$7——82
Paul O'Neill #PO2014 Topps Heritage Real One Autographs BaseballNear Mint$63$63——83
Paul O'Neill #211982 Tcma Cedar Rapids Reds BaseballPSA 9$60———84
Paul O'Neill #1221991 Topps BaseballPSA 10$60$15——85
Paul O'Neill #771995 Summit BaseballPSA 10$60$2——86
Paul O'Neill #302001 Topps BaseballPSA 10$59$15——87
Paul O'Neill #7961993 Upper Deck BaseballPSA 10$59$2——88
Paul O'Neill #5831991 Donruss BaseballPSA 10$59$1——89Paul O'Neill #2301999 Skybox Metal Universe BaseballNear Mint$58$58——90
Paul O'Neill #2041988 Topps BaseballPSA 10$57$1——91
Paul O'Neill #2471997 Topps BaseballPSA 10$56$1——92
Paul O'Neill #6041989 Topps Tiffany BaseballPSA 10$55$2——93
Paul O'Neill #7171993 Stadium Club 1st Day Production BaseballPSA 10$55$5——95
Paul O'Neill #2421996 Finest BaseballPSA 9$54$4——96
Paul O'Neill #2422021 Topps Project 70 BaseballNear Mint$54$54——97
Paul O'Neill #3221998 Topps BaseballPSA 10$52$2——98
Paul O'Neill #1221991 Topps Tiffany BaseballPSA 10$52$2——99
Paul O'Neill #1301999 Flair Showcase BaseballPSA 10$51$3——100
Paul O'Neill #MA-PO2024 Topps Allen & Ginter X Framed Mini Baseball AutographsNear Mint$50$50——Sets with Paul O'Neill cards
Paul O'Neill appears in 753 sets. Open one for the most valuable cards in it.
- 2008 Upper Deck Baseball Yankee Stadium Legacy75 cards
- 1998 Donruss Collection Baseball5 cards
- 2000 SP Authentic Baseball Buybacks Autographs5 cards
- 1996 Finest Baseball3 cards
- 1998 Ultra Baseball3 cards
- 2001 Topps Heritage Baseball3 cards
- 2011 Topps Triple Threads Baseball Relic Autographs3 cards
- 2012 Topps Tribute Baseball Autographs3 cards
- 2012 Topps Triple Threads Baseball Relic Autographs3 cards
- 2013 Topps Museum Collection Baseball Momentous Material Jumbo Relic Autographs3 cards
- 1991 Stadium Club Baseball2 cards
- 1994 Bowman Baseball2 cards
- 1994 Pinnacle Baseball2 cards
- 1995 Stadium Club Baseball2 cards
- 1996 Stadium Club Baseball2 cards
- 1999 Fleer Brilliants Baseball2 cards
- 1999 Upper Deck Baseball2 cards
- 2000 Fleer Baseball2 cards
- 2000 Topps Baseball2 cards
- 2000 Upper Deck Baseball Game Jersey Autographs2 cards
- 2000 Upper Deck HoloGrFX Baseball A Piece of the World Series Autographed2 cards
- 2002 Fleer Fall Classic Baseball2 cards
- 2002 Upper Deck Piece of History Baseball Batting Champs Memorabilia2 cards
- 2008 Upper Deck Yankee Stadium Legacy Baseball2 cards
- 2011 Topps Tribute Baseball Autograph Relics2 cards
- 2011 Topps Update Baseball2 cards
- 2012 Topps Baseball Golden Moments Autograph Relics2 cards
- 2012 Topps Baseball Golden Moments Autographs2 cards
- 2012 Topps Triple Threads Baseball Unity Relics2 cards
- 2016 Topps Baseball Pressed Into Service Relics2 cards
- 2021 Topps Project 70 Baseball2 cards
- 2021 Topps Project70 Baseball2 cards
- 2022 Topps X Aaron Judge Baseball2 cards
- 2022 Topps X Steve Aoki Baseball2 cards
- 1982 Tcma Cedar Rapids Reds Baseball1 card
- 1986 Donruss Baseball1 card
- 1987 Fleer Update Baseball1 card
- 1987 Fleer Update Glossy Baseball1 card
- 1987 Sportflics Rookies Baseball1 card
- 1988 Donruss Baseball1 card