Most Valuable Payton Tolle Cards
Every Payton Tolle card in the catalog, ranked by market value, with live prices, trends and real sold comps.
Payton Tolle Cards152
Market Value (PSA 10)$32,736
Market Value (Raw NM)$16,318
Avg 30d Change—
Top CardPayton Tolle
#CardConditionPriceRaw Price30d %RarityTrend
1Payton Tolle #RR-PT2026 Topps Chrome Baseball Radiating Rookies AutographsPSA 10$2,750$575——2
Payton Tolle #AA-192026 Topps Series 2 All Aces BaseballPSA 10$2,571$550——3
Payton Tolle #PRV-PT2026 Bowman Paper Rookie & Veteran Autograph BaseballPSA 10$2,024$437——5
Payton Tolle #RA-PT2026 Topps Chrome LogoFractor Baseball LogoFractor Rookie AutographsPSA 10$1,681$345——6
Payton Tolle #1422026 Topps Finest BaseballPSA 10$1,671$350——7
Payton Tolle #ROA-PT2026 Topps Heritage Baseball Real One AutographsPSA 10$1,658$368——8
Payton Tolle #RA-PT2026 Topps Chrome Baseball Chrome Rookie AutographsPSA 10$1,564$1,283——9
Payton Tolle #CPA-PT2024 Bowman Draft Baseball Chrome Prospect AutographsPSA 10$1,440$692——10
Payton Tolle #BDC-632024 Bowman Draft Chrome BaseballPSA 10$1,228$300——11
Payton Tolle #RPA-PT2026 Topps Finest Rookie Patch Autograph BaseballPSA 10$1,141$618——12
Payton Tolle #152026 Topps BaseballPSA 10$1,061$210——13
Payton Tolle #LIA-PT2026 Topps Tribute Baseball League Inauguration AutographsPSA 10$886$180——14
Payton Tolle #262026 Topps Chrome Black BaseballPSA 10$860$250——15
Payton Tolle #BOA-PT2026 Topps Tier One Baseball Break Out AutographsPSA 10$818$252——16
Payton Tolle #TA-PT2026 Topps Tribute Baseball Tribute AutographsPSA 10$729$189——18
Payton Tolle #PA-PT2026 Topps Pristine Baseball Pristine AutographsNear Mint$599$599——19
Payton Tolle #1772026 Topps Chrome BaseballPSA 10$562$408——20
Payton Tolle #882026 Topps Flagship Collection BaseballNear Mint$550$550——21
Payton Tolle #91C2-312026 Topps Series 2 1991 Chrome BaseballPSA 10$523$160——23
Payton Tolle #BCA-PT2026 Topps Tier One Baseball AutographsPSA 10$520$105——24
Payton Tolle #BSA-PT2026 Topps Baseball Stars AutographsPSA 10$508$325——25
Payton Tolle #152026 Topps Flagship Real One Autograph BaseballPSA 10$506$500——26
Payton Tolle #BSA2-PT2026 Topps Series 2 Baseball Stars AutographPSA 10$493$300——28
Payton Tolle #MLM2-PT2026 Topps Series 2 Major League Materials Autograph BaseballPSA 10$412$125——29
Payton Tolle #MLM2-PT2026 Topps Series 2 Major League Materials BaseballPSA 10$397$80——30
Payton Tolle #3862026 Topps Heritage BaseballPSA 10$367$76——31
Payton Tolle #91B2-PT2026 Topps Update 1991 Autograph BaseballNear Mint$350$350——32
Payton Tolle #432026 Topps Pristine BaseballNear Mint$338$338——33
Payton Tolle #42026 Topps Tribute BaseballNear Mint$330$330——34
Payton Tolle #BD-632024 Bowman Draft BaseballNear Mint$283$283——35
Payton Tolle #6262025 Topps Now BaseballNear Mint$255$255——36
Payton Tolle #NOC-142026 Topps Chrome Black Baseball NocturnalPSA 10$250$65——37
Payton Tolle #152026 Topps BaseballPSA 9$250$78——38
Payton Tolle #DAM-302026 Topps Chrome Black Baseball DamascusPSA 10$220$63——40
Payton Tolle #152026 Topps BaseballNear Mint$200$200——41
Payton Tolle #BA-PT12025 Leaf Metal Autograph BaseballPSA 10$199$49——42
Payton Tolle #BDC-632024 Bowman Draft Sapphire Edition BaseballPSA 10$163$20——43
Payton Tolle #152026 Topps Celebration BaseballPSA 10$156$29——44
Payton Tolle #162026 Donruss Elite Baseball Full ThrottleNear Mint$150$150——48
Payton Tolle #LGR-PT12025 Leaf Metal 1992 Rookies Autograph BaseballPSA 10$150$99——49
Payton Tolle #OD-152026 Topps Now Road to Opening Day BaseballPSA 10$140$80——50
Payton Tolle #932026 Topps Tier One BaseballPSA 10$139$100——51
Payton Tolle #1752026 Topps Allen & Ginter BaseballNear Mint$125$125——52
Payton Tolle #91R2-PT2026 Topps Series 2 1991 Relic BaseballPSA 10$122$120——53
Payton Tolle #DR-PT12025 Leaf Metal Baseball Diamond in the RoughNear Mint$100$100——54
Payton Tolle #802024 Panini Prospect Edition BaseballNear Mint$100$100——55Payton Tolle #LGR-PT12025 Leaf Metal Baseball 92 Leaf LGRNear Mint$99$99——56
Payton Tolle #BA-PT12024 Leaf Trinity Autograph BaseballPSA 10$97$70——57
Payton Tolle #42025 Panini Impeccable Baseball Indelible InkNear Mint$96$96——58
Payton Tolle #SMLB-342026 Topps Stars of MLBNear Mint$85$85——60
Payton Tolle #1422026 Finest BaseballNear Mint$80$80——61
Payton Tolle #5302026 Topps Now BaseballNear Mint$80$80——62
Payton Tolle #NB-822025 Leaf Baseball Nation New DawnPSA 10$77$12——63
Payton Tolle #302026 Donruss Baseball Diamond KingsPSA 10$71$9——64
Payton Tolle #942026 Donruss Baseball OpticNear Mint$64$64——66
Payton Tolle #372024 Panini Prospect Edition Baseball Future Legends SignaturesNear Mint$60$60——67
Payton Tolle #262026 Bowman BaseballNear Mint$53$53——68Payton Tolle #BA-PT12025 Leaf Metal Baseball Base AutographNear Mint$50$50——69Payton Tolle #NA-PT12025 Leaf Baseball Nation New Dawn AutographsNear Mint$45$45——70
Payton Tolle #412026 Topps Series 2 The Flagship Collection BaseballPSA 10$44$11——71
Payton Tolle #1552024 Leaf Trinity BaseballPSA 10$40$20——72Payton Tolle #PA-PT12024 Leaf Trinity Baseball Patch AutographNear Mint$39$39——73
Payton Tolle #BA-PT12024 Leaf Vivid Autograph BaseballNear Mint$35$35——74
Payton Tolle #22026 Panini Immaculate Brilliance Memorabilia BaseballNear Mint$28$28——75
Payton Tolle #JK-PT2026 Panini Donruss Jersey Kings BaseballNear Mint$27$27——76
Payton Tolle #942026 Panini Donruss BaseballNear Mint$26$26——77
Payton Tolle #132026 Donruss Baseball Elite SeriesNear Mint$25$25——78
Payton Tolle #132026 Panini Donruss Elite Series BaseballNear Mint$24$24——79
Payton Tolle #1772026 Topps Chrome Sapphire BaseballNear Mint$20$20——80
Payton Tolle #262026 Topps Chrome Black BaseballCGC 10$20$10——81
Payton Tolle #112024 Panini Prospect Edition Baseball AcesNear Mint$19$19——83
Payton Tolle #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100Near Mint$18$18——84
Payton Tolle #MLMU-PT2026 Topps Update Major League Material BaseballNear Mint$14$14——86
Payton Tolle #91RU-PT2026 Topps Update 1991 Relic BaseballNear Mint$13$13——87
Payton Tolle #US1332026 Topps Update BaseballNear Mint$10$10——89
Payton Tolle #282026 Panini Immaculate BaseballNear Mint$10$10——90
Payton Tolle #302026 Panini Donruss Diamond Kings BaseballNear Mint$9$9——91
Payton Tolle #1772026 Topps Chrome BaseballNear Mint$9$9——92
Payton Tolle #1442025 Leaf Metal BaseballNear Mint$9$9——93
Payton Tolle #942026 Donruss BaseballNear Mint$8$8——94
Payton Tolle #542026 Panini Donruss Elite BaseballNear Mint$7$7——95
Payton Tolle #U91-212026 Topps Update 1991 BaseballNear Mint$6$6——96
Payton Tolle #162026 Panini Donruss Elite Full Throttle BaseballNear Mint$5$5——98
Payton Tolle #1772026 Topps Chrome Logofractor BaseballNear Mint$1$1——Sets with Payton Tolle cards
Payton Tolle appears in 137 sets. Open one for the most valuable cards in it.
- 2026 Topps Baseball8 cards
- 2025 Leaf Metal Baseball2 cards
- 2026 Bowman Baseball2 cards
- 2026 Pulse X Big League Chew Grand Slam Grape Baseball2 cards
- 2026 Topps Baseball Stars Autographs2 cards
- 2026 Topps Chrome Baseball2 cards
- 2026 Topps Chrome Black Baseball2 cards
- 2026 Topps Now Baseball2 cards
- 2026 Topps Update Baseball2 cards
- 2024 Bowman Draft Baseball1 card
- 2024 Bowman Draft Baseball Chrome Prospect Autographs1 card
- 2024 Bowman Draft Chrome Baseball1 card
- 2024 Bowman Draft Sapphire Edition Baseball1 card
- 2024 Leaf Trinity Autograph Baseball1 card
- 2024 Leaf Trinity Baseball1 card
- 2024 Leaf Trinity Baseball Base Autograph1 card
- 2024 Leaf Trinity Baseball Clear Autographs1 card
- 2024 Leaf Trinity Baseball Divinity1 card
- 2024 Leaf Trinity Baseball Logo Autograph1 card
- 2024 Leaf Trinity Baseball Patch Autograph1 card
- 2024 Leaf Trinity Baseball Steel1 card
- 2024 Leaf Trinity Baseball The Cycle Double1 card
- 2024 Leaf Trinity Baseball The Cycle Home Run1 card
- 2024 Leaf Trinity Baseball The Cycle Single1 card
- 2024 Leaf Trinity Baseball The Cycle Triple1 card
- 2024 Leaf Trinity Mega Box Baseball Rookie Relic1 card
- 2024 Leaf Vivid Autograph Baseball1 card
- 2024 Leaf Vivid Baseball Base Autograph1 card
- 2024 Leaf Vivid Baseball Technicolor1 card
- 2024 Panini Prospect Edition Baseball1 card
- 2024 Panini Prospect Edition Baseball Aces1 card
- 2024 Panini Prospect Edition Baseball Future Legends Signatures1 card
- 2025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 1001 card
- 2025 Leaf Baseball Nation New Dawn1 card
- 2025 Leaf Baseball Nation New Dawn Autographs1 card
- 2025 Leaf Metal 1992 Rookies Autograph Baseball1 card
- 2025 Leaf Metal Autograph Baseball1 card
- 2025 Leaf Metal Baseball 92 Leaf LGR1 card
- 2025 Leaf Metal Baseball Base Autograph1 card
- 2025 Leaf Metal Baseball Diamond in the Rough1 card