Most Valuable Peyton Manning Cards
Every Peyton Manning card in the catalog, ranked by market value, with live prices, trends and real sold comps.
Peyton Manning Cards1000
Market Value (PSA 10)$76,465
Market Value (Raw NM)$43,766
Avg 30d Change-3.43%
Top CardPeyton Manning
#CardConditionPriceRaw Price30d %RarityTrend
1Peyton Manning #2311998 SkyBox Premium FootballPSA 9$15,000$6,000——2
Peyton Manning #201P1998 Ultra FootballPSA 10$9,868———3
Peyton Manning #3511998 Spx Finite FootballPSA 10$6,812$28——4
Peyton Manning #2391998 Skybox Thunder FootballPSA 10$4,999$3,295——5
Peyton Manning #11998 Bowman Chrome FootballPSA 10$4,957$292——6
Peyton Manning #416P1998 Ultra FootballPSA 9$3,050———7
Peyton Manning #A101998 Topps Certified Autograph FootballNear Mint$2,795$2,795——8
Peyton Manning #FFS-PM2024 Topps Chrome Cosmic Football First Flight SignaturesNear Mint$2,550$2,550——9
Peyton Manning #A10B1998 Topps Football AutographsBGS 9.5$2,225———10
Peyton Manning #SS-132025 Topps Chrome Sapphire Selections FootballNear Mint$2,222$2,222——11
Peyton Manning #912020 Panini Prizm FootballPSA 10$1,853$656——12
Peyton Manning #416G1998 Ultra FootballNear Mint$1,722$1,722——13
Peyton Manning #262023 Clearly Donruss Football DowntownPSA 10$1,600$600——14
Peyton Manning #FMA-PM2025 Topps Finest Moments Autograph FootballPSA 10$1,595$350——15
Peyton Manning #1292022 Panini Prizm FootballPSA 9$1,500$407——16
Peyton Manning #11998 Playoff Prestige Draft Picks FootballPSA 10$1,500$30——17
Peyton Manning #SFS-PEM2025 Topps Cosmic Chrome Solar Flare Signatures FootballPSA 10$1,387$350——18
Peyton Manning #U201998 Topps Finest Undergrads FootballPSA 10$1,295$148——19
Peyton Manning #1282002 Topps Chrome FootballPSA 10$1,250$191——20
Peyton Manning #32008 Topps Finest FootballPSA 10$1,199$164——21
Peyton Manning #HOCA-PM2025 Topps Chrome Sapphire Hall Of Chrome Autograph FootballPSA 10$1,068$227——22
Peyton Manning #1122000 Bowman Chrome FootballPSA 10$1,053$149——23
Peyton Manning #DT-182021 Panini Donruss Downtown FootballPSA 10$1,025$640——24
Peyton Manning #602009 Topps Finest FootballPSA 10$1,016$223——25
Peyton Manning #11998 Metal Universe Quasars FootballPSA 10$998$22——26
Peyton Manning #11998 Upper Deck Encore FootballPSA 10$980$33——27
Peyton Manning #D-92023 Panini Donruss Downtown FootballPSA 10$964$427——28
Peyton Manning #292013 Panini Limited FootballBGS 9.5$960$3——29
Peyton Manning #2561998 Upper Deck UD Choice FootballPSA 9$825$40——30
Peyton Manning #911998 Upper Deck Black Diamond Rookies FootballPSA 10$825$94——31
Peyton Manning #SF-972025 Topps Cosmic Chrome Starfractor FootballPSA 10$786$163——32
Peyton Manning #LY-22025 Topps Cosmic Chrome Light Years FootballPSA 10$782$162——33
Peyton Manning #982001 Topps Chrome FootballPSA 10$772$103——34
Peyton Manning #951999 Bowman's Best FootballPSA 10$737$275——35
Peyton Manning #12024 Panini Eminence HOF Patch Autograph FootballNear Mint$725$725——36
Peyton Manning #662011 Panini Threads FootballPSA 10$682$7——37
Peyton Manning #201G1998 Ultra FootballPSA 10$670$72——38
Peyton Manning #PPS-PM2024 Topps Cosmic Chrome Planetary Pursuit FootballPSA 10$660$150——39
Peyton Manning #2871998 Spx Finite FootballPSA 10$643$250——40
Peyton Manning #SS-PMG2024 Panini Spectra Football Spectral SignaturesNear Mint$630$630——41
Peyton Manning #582014 Panini Prizm FootballPSA 10$629$256——42
Peyton Manning #442007 Donruss Classics FootballPSA 10$600$136——43
Peyton Manning #661998 Pinnacle Mint FootballPSA 10$599$8——44
Peyton Manning #22024 Panini Flawless Football Distinguished Patch AutographsNear Mint$568$568——45
Peyton Manning #3111998 Spx Finite FootballNear Mint$565$565——46
Peyton Manning #3412023 Panini Select FootballPSA 10$550$417——47
Peyton Manning #242014 Bowman Chrome FootballPSA 10$550$150——48
Peyton Manning #1202005 Topps Finest FootballPSA 9$550$300——49
Peyton Manning #BA-PM2024 Topps Chrome Football AutographsNear Mint$550$550——50
Peyton Manning #12024 Panini Flawless Football Hall of Fame AutographsNear Mint$510$510——51
Peyton Manning #802011 Topps Finest FootballPSA 10$508$150——52
Peyton Manning #PPU-PM2024 Topps Cosmic Chrome Planetary Pursuit FootballNear Mint$480$480——53
Peyton Manning #1122017 Panini Flawless FootballPSA 10$450$143——54
Peyton Manning #PPE-PM2024 Topps Cosmic Chrome Planetary Pursuit FootballPSA 9$440$375——55
Peyton Manning #15S1998 Skybox E X2001 Stardate FootballPSA 10$405$88——56
Peyton Manning #CS-PMA2022 Panini Black Capstones Autographs FootballNear Mint$400$400——57Peyton Manning #VM-PM2023 Topps Motif Virtuoso Marks FootballNear Mint$400$400——58
Peyton Manning #II-PM2026 Topps Flagship Football Island InkNear Mint$385$385——59
Peyton Manning #162022 Panini Score FootballNear Mint$381$381——60
Peyton Manning #SB50-PM2023 Panini Donruss Super Bowl Signatures FootballPSA 9$350$345——61
Peyton Manning #2872021 Panini Mosaic FootballPSA 10$350$257——62
Peyton Manning #11998 Upper Deck UD3 FootballPSA 10$347$40——63
Peyton Manning #TC962009 Topps Chrome FootballPSA 10$319$68——64
Peyton Manning #PPN-PM2024 Topps Cosmic Chrome Planetary Pursuit FootballPSA 9$310$25——65
Peyton Manning #2632021 Panini Mosaic FootballPSA 10$300$127——66
Peyton Manning #2972017 Panini Select FootballPSA 9$290$34——67
Peyton Manning #2011998 Ultra FootballPSA 10$276$20——68
Peyton Manning #GK-112002 Panini Donruss Gridiron Kings FootballPSA 9$275$10——69
Peyton Manning #12024 Panini National Treasures NFL Greatest SignaturesNear Mint$275$275——70
Peyton Manning #M-112019 Donruss Optic Football MythicalPSA 9$270$40——71
Peyton Manning #62025 Panini Silhouette Football VantaNear Mint$270$270——72
Peyton Manning #SF-PM2004 Upper Deck Foundations Signatures FootballPSA 9$253$164——73
Peyton Manning #202024 Topps Signature Class FootballNear Mint$251$251——74
Peyton Manning #1891998 Metal Universe FootballPSA 10$250$25——75
Peyton Manning #D402022 Panini Donruss Dominators FootballPSA 9$250$199——76
Peyton Manning #PPMR-PM2024 Topps Cosmic Chrome Planetary Pursuit FootballPSA 10$250$66——77
Peyton Manning #392004 Upper Deck Legends FootballNear Mint$250$250——78
Peyton Manning #K51998 Topps Action Flats FootballPSA 10$248$16——79
Peyton Manning #1802009 Bowman Sterling FootballNear Mint$245$245——80
Peyton Manning #PC-PM2004 Upper Deck Reflections Pro Cuts FootballPSA 10$236$17——81
Peyton Manning #PPM-PM2024 Topps Cosmic Chrome Planetary Pursuit FootballPSA 10$233$55——82
Peyton Manning #CD-52024 Topps Cosmic Chrome Dust FootballPSA 10$232$35——83
Peyton Manning #PR101998 Stadium Club Prime Rookies FootballPSA 10$227$14——84
Peyton Manning #22005 Bowman's Best FootballBGS 9.5$225$30——85
Peyton Manning #RS-PM2024 Topps Resurgence Football Resurgence SignaturesNear Mint$213$213——86
Peyton Manning #N100-PM2023 Panini Donruss NFL 100 SignaturesNear Mint$209$209——87
Peyton Manning #662015 Topps Finest FootballPSA 10$207$103——88
Peyton Manning #152023 Panini Impeccable Silver Hall Of Fame FootballNear Mint$205$205——89
Peyton Manning #672001 Bowman Chrome FootballPSA 9.5$204$160——90
Peyton Manning #202013 Fleer Retro Tradition FootballPSA 10$203$116——91
Peyton Manning #712010 Topps Magic FootballPSA 9$203$61——92
Peyton Manning #72013 Panini Rookies & Stars Football CrusadePSA 10$203$115——93Peyton Manning #BT202000 Stadium Club Football Beam TeamNear Mint$200$200——94Peyton Manning #PRO-PM2022 Panini Flawless Football Pro Bowl GemNear Mint$200$200——95
Peyton Manning #CT-82022 Panini Donruss Crunch Time FootballPSA 9$200$110——96
Peyton Manning #1962023 Topps Composite FootballPSA 10$199$53——97
Peyton Manning #DGA-PM2024 Topps Inception Football Dawn of Greatness AutographsNear Mint$199$199——98
Peyton Manning #PPV-PM2024 Topps Cosmic Chrome Planetary Pursuit FootballPSA 10$199$35——99
Peyton Manning #1811998 Upper Deck UD3 FootballPSA 10$197$12——100
Peyton Manning #62009 Topps Platinum FootballPSA 10$193$1——Sets with Peyton Manning cards
Peyton Manning appears in 821 sets. Open one for the most valuable cards in it.
- 2025 Wild Card Splat Balloon Football20 cards
- 2025 Wild Card Splat Classic Football20 cards
- 2025 Wild Card Splat Vintage Football20 cards
- 2023 Panini Donruss Elite Lombardibound Football15 cards
- 2023 Donruss Elite Football LombardiBound13 cards
- 2020 Panini Spectra Football Tribute7 cards
- 2024 Topps Cosmic Chrome Planetary Pursuit Football7 cards
- 2020 Panini Spectra Football Tribute Autographs Neon Green6 cards
- 2025 Wild Card Splat Auto Blue Football6 cards
- 2025 Wild Card Splat Auto Gold Football6 cards
- 2025 Wild Card Splat Auto Green Football6 cards
- 2025 Wild Card Splat Auto Orange Football6 cards
- 2025 Wild Card Splat Auto Rainbow Football6 cards
- 1998 Ultra Football5 cards
- 2016 Panini Immaculate Collection Football Immaculate Moments Autographs4 cards
- 1998 Spx Finite Football3 cards
- 2002 Score Football QBC Materials3 cards
- 2010 Topps Football Sketch Cards3 cards
- 2018 Panini Immaculate Collection Football Immaculate Moments Autographs3 cards
- 2018 Panini Plates & Patches Football Printing Plates Autographs3 cards
- 2019 Score Football Score Buyback Autographs3 cards
- 2021 Panini Donruss Elite Spellbound Football3 cards
- 2021 Panini One Football3 cards
- 2023 Topps Composite Football3 cards
- 1998 Pinnacle Mint Collection Minted Moments Football2 cards
- 1998 Upper Deck UD Choice Football2 cards
- 1998 Upper Deck UD3 Football2 cards
- 2000 Panini Donruss Preferred Football2 cards
- 2008 Upper Deck Masterpieces Football2 cards
- 2009 Topps Mayo Football2 cards
- 2009 Upper Deck Philadelphia Football2 cards
- 2014 Panini Crown Royale Football Crown Signatures2 cards
- 2014 Topps Prime Football2 cards
- 2015 Donruss Football2 cards
- 2015 Panini Clear Vision Football2 cards
- 2016 Panini Honors Football Recollection Collection2 cards
- 2018 Panini Classics Football Recollection Collection2 cards
- 2018 Panini Flawless Football2 cards
- 2018 Panini Impeccable Football Impeccable Accomplishments Autographs2 cards
- 2018 Panini Plates & Patches Football 2017 Classics Super Bowl Heroes Printing Plates2 cards