Most Valuable Tyler Toffoli Cards
Every Tyler Toffoli card in the catalog, ranked by market value, with live prices, trends and real sold comps.
Tyler Toffoli Cards547
Market Value (PSA 10)$3,339
Market Value (Raw NM)$5,678
Avg 30d Change+0.80%
Top CardTyler Toffoli
#CardConditionPriceRaw Price30d %RarityTrend
1Tyler Toffoli #PC-42022-23 Upper Deck Hockey Population Count 1000Near Mint$1,185$1,185——2
Tyler Toffoli #682024 Ultimate Collection HockeyNear Mint$825$825——3
Tyler Toffoli #382024-25 Skybox Metal Universe HockeyNear Mint$350$350——4
Tyler Toffoli #1302025-26 Upper Deck Artifacts HockeyNear Mint$250$250——5
Tyler Toffoli #DZ-542025 Upper Deck Series 2 Dazzlers HockeyPSA 10$183$35——6
Tyler Toffoli #2202013-14 Panini National Treasures HockeyPSA 10$175$51——7
Tyler Toffoli #CMP-232025-26 Upper Deck Hockey CompositionsPSA 10$117$21——8
Tyler Toffoli #2742013-14 SP Authentic HockeyPSA 10$115$21——9
Tyler Toffoli #302024 Skybox Metal Universe On The Button HockeyPSA 10$105$20——10
Tyler Toffoli #1542025-26 O-Pee-Chee Platinum HockeyPSA 10$94$19——11
Tyler Toffoli #952025-26 SkyBox Metal Universe HockeyNear Mint$88$88——12
Tyler Toffoli #2902013-14 Panini Select HockeyNear Mint$85$85——13
Tyler Toffoli #PMP-LI2022 Upper Deck Premier Mega Patch HockeyNear Mint$83$83——14
Tyler Toffoli #PMP-TT2025 Upper Deck Premier Mega Patch HockeyNear Mint$76$76——15
Tyler Toffoli #MU-332013-14 Fleer Showcase Hockey Metal UniverseNear Mint$75$75——16
Tyler Toffoli #CS-TT2020-21 Upper Deck Clear Cut Hockey Canvas SignaturesNear Mint$72$72——17
Tyler Toffoli #2462013-14 Upper Deck HockeyNear Mint$71$71——18
Tyler Toffoli #2462013-14 Panini Prizm HockeyPSA 10$70$13——19
Tyler Toffoli #322024-25 Upper Deck Premier HockeyPSA 10$69$29——20
Tyler Toffoli #BC-212025-26 Upper Deck Credentials Hockey Bright CellysNear Mint$61$61——21
Tyler Toffoli #902025-26 SP Game Used HockeyPSA 10$61$55——22
Tyler Toffoli #E-TO2023 Sp Authentic Evolve Autograph HockeyPSA 10$61$8——23
Tyler Toffoli #E-1362025 Upper Deck Series 2 Encore HockeyPSA 10$58$7——24
Tyler Toffoli #302021 Ultra HockeyNear Mint$58$58——25
Tyler Toffoli #BF-222024 Skybox Metal Universe Blast Furnace Autograph HockeyPSA 10$57$11——26
Tyler Toffoli #2492013 Panini Contenders HockeyPSA 10$55$8——27
Tyler Toffoli #OL-342025-26 SkyBox Metal Universe Hockey Outer LimitsPSA 10$55$5——28
Tyler Toffoli #YGR-502024 Upper Deck Young Guns Renewed HockeyNear Mint$54$54——29
Tyler Toffoli #4892025-26 O-Pee-Chee HockeyPSA 10$51$10——30Tyler Toffoli #RS-TT2013-14 Panini Prime Hockey Rookie Showcase SwatchesNear Mint$50$50——31
Tyler Toffoli #LC-212025-26 SkyBox Metal Universe Hockey Lunar CyclePSA 10$49$4——32
Tyler Toffoli #GO-TT2024-25 Upper Deck Premier Hockey Grand Opus JerseyPSA 10$49$5——33
Tyler Toffoli #F-TT2021-22 Upper Deck The Cup Hockey Foundations Quad JerseyNear Mint$49$49——34
Tyler Toffoli #772022-23 Upper Deck Premier HockeyPSA 10$47$31——35
Tyler Toffoli #GSF-142024-25 SP Game Used Hockey 2024 Stadium Series FabricsPSA 10$46$8——36
Tyler Toffoli #732024-25 O-Pee-Chee Platinum HockeyNear Mint$46$46——37
Tyler Toffoli #1042025-26 Flair HockeyPSA 10$45$20——38
Tyler Toffoli #SS-222024-25 Skybox Metal Universe Hockey Silver ShotsPSA 10$45$5——39
Tyler Toffoli #1402025-26 Upper Deck HockeyPSA 10$44$23——40
Tyler Toffoli #PTS-TT2024 Ultimate Collection Personal Touch Signatures HockeyNear Mint$44$44——41
Tyler Toffoli #140-SSP2025 Upper Deck HockeyNear Mint$43$43——42
Tyler Toffoli #32025-26 SPx HockeyPSA 10$43$22——43
Tyler Toffoli #DS-262025-26 Upper Deck Credentials Hockey Defined SuccessPSA 10$42$10——44
Tyler Toffoli #FTD-162025-26 Flair Hockey Flair for the DramaticPSA 10$42$3——45
Tyler Toffoli #CB-182025-26 SkyBox Metal Universe Hockey Circle ButtonPSA 10$41$4——46
Tyler Toffoli #OG-332025 Upper Deck Series 2 O Pee Chee Glossy HockeyPSA 10$41$2——47
Tyler Toffoli #SS-TT2023-24 Upper Deck Artifacts Hockey Storied ScriptsNear Mint$40$40——48
Tyler Toffoli #3392018-19 Upper Deck HockeyNear Mint$40$40——49
Tyler Toffoli #DZ-1162024-25 Upper Deck Hockey DazzlersPSA 10$40$27——50
Tyler Toffoli #HL-82026 Upper Deck Team Canada History Of Leadership HockeyPSA 10$39$2——51
Tyler Toffoli #C-3252025 Upper Deck Extended Series UD Canvas HockeyPSA 10$39$2——52
Tyler Toffoli #CG-142025-26 SkyBox Metal Universe Hockey Championship GalaxyPSA 10$39$2——53
Tyler Toffoli #1322025-26 Parkhurst HockeyPSA 10$39$2——54
Tyler Toffoli #TT-TO2023-24 Upper Deck Artifacts Hockey Threads of TimePSA 10$39$13——55
Tyler Toffoli #142025-26 SP HockeyPSA 10$39$2——56
Tyler Toffoli #SR-692025 Upper Deck Series 2 Sizzle Reel HockeyPSA 10$39$4——57
Tyler Toffoli #6042024-25 Upper Deck HockeyPSA 10$39$29——59
Tyler Toffoli #82014-15 SP Authentic HockeyNear Mint$38$38——60
Tyler Toffoli #452024-25 Upper Deck The Cup HockeyPSA 10$38$13——61
Tyler Toffoli #P-152025 O Pee Chee Premier HockeyPSA 10$38$13——62
Tyler Toffoli #BDB-TT2023 Upper Deck Black Diamond Pure Black Autograph HockeyPSA 10$37$2——63
Tyler Toffoli #SPC-TT2022-23 SP Authentic Hockey SP Curated SignaturesPSA 10$37$3——64
Tyler Toffoli #C3252024-25 Upper Deck Hockey UD CanvasPSA 10$36$8——65
Tyler Toffoli #432025-26 Upper Deck MVP HockeyPSA 10$36$7——66
Tyler Toffoli #1122016-17 O-Pee-Chee Platinum HockeyNear Mint$36$36——67
Tyler Toffoli #782023-24 Upper Deck MVP HockeyNear Mint$35$35——68
Tyler Toffoli #E-142024-25 Upper Deck Hockey EncorePSA 10$35$3——69
Tyler Toffoli #E-122023-24 SP Authentic Hockey EvolvePSA 10$34$5——70
Tyler Toffoli #C112023-24 Upper Deck Hockey UD CanvasPSA 10$34$2——71
Tyler Toffoli #62024-25 Fleer Ultra Hockey Ultra TeamPSA 10$34$6——72
Tyler Toffoli #5982013 Panini Score HockeyPSA 10$34$2——73
Tyler Toffoli #652018-19 Upper Deck Artifacts HockeyPSA 10$34$4——74
Tyler Toffoli #SR-642023-24 Upper Deck Hockey Seeing RedPSA 10$34$3——75
Tyler Toffoli #SOTT-TO2021 Sp Authentic Sign Of The Times Autographs HockeyNear Mint$34$34——76
Tyler Toffoli #312022-23 Upper Deck HockeyNear Mint$34$34——77
Tyler Toffoli #142025-26 SP Authentic HockeyPSA 10$33$3——78
Tyler Toffoli #SZ-102023-24 Upper Deck Hockey Star ZonePSA 10$33$15——79
Tyler Toffoli #NR-TT2021-22 Upper Deck Artifacts NHL RemnantsPSA 10$32$4——80
Tyler Toffoli #782021-22 SkyBox Metal Universe HockeyNear Mint$30$30——81
Tyler Toffoli #5822023-24 Upper Deck HockeyNear Mint$29$29——82
Tyler Toffoli #LAM-TO2021 Sp Authentic Limited Auto Material HockeyNear Mint$29$29——83
Tyler Toffoli #T-112022-23 Upper Deck Hockey 2007-08 Upper Deck RetroNear Mint$28$28——84
Tyler Toffoli #2762023-24 Upper Deck HockeyNear Mint$25$25——85
Tyler Toffoli #PFAP-TO2022 Upper Deck Premier Focus Auto Patch HockeyNear Mint$25$25——86
Tyler Toffoli #WM-TT2021-22 SPx Hockey Winning MaterialsNear Mint$23$23——87
Tyler Toffoli #R-322016-17 O-Pee-Chee Platinum Hockey RetroNear Mint$22$22——88
Tyler Toffoli #992021-22 Upper Deck HockeyNear Mint$22$22——89
Tyler Toffoli #1282022-23 Parkhurst Champions HockeyNear Mint$22$22——90
Tyler Toffoli #DF-192023 Parkhurst Champions Daddy O Flows Autograph HockeyNear Mint$20$20——91
Tyler Toffoli #3192024-25 O-Pee-Chee HockeyNear Mint$20$20——92
Tyler Toffoli #1512019-20 Upper Deck HockeyNear Mint$20$20——93
Tyler Toffoli #612023-24 Upper Deck Ovation HockeyNear Mint$19$19——94
Tyler Toffoli #PFP-TO2024-25 Upper Deck Premier Hockey Premier Focus Auto PatchNear Mint$18$18——95
Tyler Toffoli #FTD-162025-26 Flair Hockey Flair for the Dramatic AutographsNear Mint$18$18——96
Tyler Toffoli #1972013-14 Upper Deck Trilogy HockeyPSA 10$18$9——97
Tyler Toffoli #902021-22 Upper Deck Artifacts HockeyNear Mint$18$18——98Tyler Toffoli #UE-TO2023-24 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection Hockey 2022 Update - Ultimate Emblems AutographNear Mint$18$18——99
Tyler Toffoli #972023-24 SPx HockeyNear Mint$17$17——100
Tyler Toffoli #RT-TO2020-21 Upper Deck Clear Cut Hockey Rookie Tribute AutographsNear Mint$17$17——Sets with Tyler Toffoli cards
Tyler Toffoli appears in 517 sets. Open one for the most valuable cards in it.
- 2014-15 Ultra Hockey Road to the Championship13 cards
- 2010-11 In The Game Heroes and Prospects Hockey Complete Letter Team Orr3 cards
- 2013-14 Upper Deck The Cup Hockey Trilogy Rookie Autograph Printing Plates Set3 cards
- 2013-14 Upper Deck Trilogy Hockey3 cards
- 2023-24 Upper Deck Hockey3 cards
- 2025-26 O-Pee-Chee Hockey3 cards
- 2013-14 Score Hockey2 cards
- 2013-14 SPx Hockey2 cards
- 2015-16 Upper Deck MVP Hockey2 cards
- 2017-18 SP Game Used Hockey Supreme Jumbo Relics2 cards
- 2019 Topps Now NHL Stickers2 cards
- 2024-25 O-Pee-Chee Hockey2 cards
- 2025-26 O-Pee-Chee Platinum Hockey2 cards
- 2025-26 Upper Deck Hockey2 cards
- 2010-11 In The Game Heroes and Prospects Hockey1 card
- 2010-11 In The Game Heroes and Prospects Hockey Autographs1 card
- 2010-11 In The Game Heroes and Prospects Hockey Top Prospects Game Used1 card
- 2012-13 Upper Deck Artifacts Hockey1 card
- 2012-13 Upper Deck Artifacts Hockey Rookie Autographs Redemptions1 card
- 2013 Panini Contenders Hockey1 card
- 2013 Panini Crown Royale Scratching The Surface Hockey1 card
- 2013 Panini Score Hockey1 card
- 2013-14 Fleer Showcase Hockey1 card
- 2013-14 Fleer Showcase Hockey Metal Universe1 card
- 2013-14 Fleer Showcase Hockey Red Glow1 card
- 2013-14 Fleer Showcase Hockey Ultra1 card
- 2013-14 Fleer Showcase Hockey White Hot1 card
- 2013-14 O-Pee-Chee Hockey1 card
- 2013-14 Panini Crown Royale Hockey1 card
- 2013-14 Panini Crown Royale Hockey Heirs to the Throne Materials1 card
- 2013-14 Panini Crown Royale Hockey Scratching the Surface Signatures1 card
- 2013-14 Panini Dominion Hockey1 card
- 2013-14 Panini Dominion Hockey Authentic Material1 card
- 2013-14 Panini Dominion Hockey Autograph Patches1 card
- 2013-14 Panini Dominion Hockey Complete Rookie Jerseys1 card
- 2013-14 Panini Dominion Hockey Fight Strap1 card
- 2013-14 Panini Dominion Hockey Ice1 card
- 2013-14 Panini Dominion Hockey Jerseys Brand Logo1 card
- 2013-14 Panini Dominion Hockey Mammoth Jerseys1 card
- 2013-14 Panini Dominion Hockey Mammoth Jerseys Patch1 card