Most Valuable Walter Payton Cards
Every Walter Payton card in the catalog, ranked by market value, with live prices, trends and real sold comps.
Walter Payton Cards417
Market Value (PSA 10)$231,223
Market Value (Raw NM)$46,808
Avg 30d Change+3.02%
Top CardWalter Payton
#CardConditionPriceRaw Price30d %RarityTrend
1Walter Payton #1481976 Topps FootballPSA 10$54,111$210——2
Walter Payton #3601977 Topps FootballPSA 10$24,400$17——3
Walter Payton #4801979 Topps FootballPSA 10$16,767$7——4
Walter Payton #2281984 Topps FootballPSA 10$15,075$4——5Walter Payton #12025 Panini Prizm Black Football MangaPSA 10$14,500———6
Walter Payton #4001981 Topps FootballPSA 10$6,487$5——7
Walter Payton #WP1999 Upper Deck Retro Inkredible FootballNear Mint$6,000$6,000——8
Walter Payton #AL-41997 Upper Deck Legends FootballPSA 10$5,809$4,259——9
Walter Payton #3601977 Topps Mexican FootballSGC 7$5,600$617——10
Walter Payton #TECMO-42025 Topps Chrome Football TecmoPSA 10$5,288$1,800——11
Walter Payton #1601980 Topps FootballPSA 10$5,179$5——12Walter Payton #112025 Panini Prizm Black Football PrizmaniaPSA 10$4,250———13
Walter Payton #2021981 Topps FootballPSA 10$3,880$3——14
Walter Payton #DT-132021 Donruss Football DowntownPSA 10$3,625$900——15
Walter Payton #21978 Topps Holsum FootballPSA 10$3,440$235——16
Walter Payton #DT-282020 Panini Donruss Optic Downtown FootballPSA 10$3,400$1,160——17
Walter Payton #111986 Topps FootballPSA 10$3,306$4——18
Walter Payton #31978 Topps FootballPSA 10$3,095$4——19
Walter Payton #361983 Topps FootballPSA 10$2,709$4——20
Walter Payton #IS-12025 Topps Chrome Sapphire Infinite FootballPSA 10$2,705$586——21
Walter Payton #2001978 Topps FootballPSA 10$2,520$7——22
Walter Payton #1052016 Panini Flawless FootballNear Mint$2,500$2,500——23
Walter Payton #1492013 Panini Select FootballNear Mint$2,500$2,500——24
Walter Payton #3021982 Topps FootballPSA 10$2,471$6——25
Walter Payton #D-282020 Panini Donruss Downtown FootballPSA 10$2,352———26
Walter Payton #172017 Panini Donruss Optic Aka FootballPSA 10$2,159$120——27
Walter Payton #N1985 Topps Box Bottoms FootballPSA 9$1,865$27——28
Walter Payton #3031982 Topps FootballPSA 10$1,865$3——29Walter Payton (Autograph) #271992 Upper Deck Football HeroesNear Mint$1,850$1,850——30
Walter Payton #61985 Topps FootballPSA 10$1,825$2——31
Walter Payton #4022025 Topps Chrome FootballNear Mint$1,825$1,825——32
Walter Payton #41981 Topps Red Border Stickers FootballPSA 10$1,787$20——33Walter Payton #MYST-282024 Finest Football Mystery FinestPSA 9.5$1,649$26——34
Walter Payton #1911981 Topps Stickers FootballPSA 10$1,600$7——35
Walter Payton #MYST-282024 Topps Finest Mystery Refractor FootballPSA 9$1,499$26——36
Walter Payton #232024 Topps Chrome FootballNear Mint$1,400$1,400——37
Walter Payton #331985 Topps FootballPSA 10$1,381$4——38
Walter Payton #NB-252024 Topps Midnight Football NightballNear Mint$1,380$1,380——39
Walter Payton #K352022 Panini Absolute Kaboom Vertical FootballPSA 10$1,367———40
Walter Payton #31986 Topps 1000 Yard Club FootballPSA 10$1,350$2——41
Walter Payton #31986 Topps Football 1,000 Yard ClubPSA 10$1,350$2——42
Walter Payton #342015 Panini Prizm FootballNear Mint$1,250$1,250——43
Walter Payton #1652021 Panini Prizm FootballPSA 10$1,250$1,163——44
Walter Payton #LY-52025 Topps Cosmic Chrome Light Years FootballPSA 10$1,223$256——45
Walter Payton #2131983 Topps Stickers FootballPSA 10$1,025$5——46
Walter Payton #DYN-192024 Finest Football DynamosNear Mint$1,000$1,000——47
Walter Payton #DYN-192024 Topps Finest Dynamos FootballNear Mint$1,000$1,000——48
Walter Payton #GG-112024 Topps Chrome Cosmic Football Galaxy GreatsPSA 10$1,000$421——49
Walter Payton #461987 Topps FootballPSA 10$1,000$3——50
Walter Payton #LT-142024 Topps Midnight Football Lunar TideNear Mint$899$899——51
Walter Payton #1652021 Panini Prizm No Huddle FootballPSA 9$850$662——52
Walter Payton #SS-272024 Topps Midnight Football Star StuddedNear Mint$811$811——53
Walter Payton #J1987 Topps Box Bottoms Hand Cut FootballPSA 9$797$51——54
Walter Payton #81985 Topps NFL Star SetPSA 10$788$11——55
Walter Payton #2612021 Panini Mosaic FootballPSA 10$754$167——56
Walter Payton #52012 Panini Prizm Football Decade DominancePSA 10$700$60——57
Walter Payton #722020 Panini Flawless FootballPSA 9$700$612——58
Walter Payton #301980 Topps Super FootballPSA 10$652$12——59
Walter Payton #71986 Topps FootballPSA 10$640$3——60
Walter Payton #3351979 Topps FootballPSA 10$591$3——61
Walter Payton #STN-142024 Topps Cosmic Chrome Stella Nova FootballPSA 10$572$147——62
Walter Payton #382022 Donruss Optic FootballPSA 10$563$200——63
Walter Payton #422021 Panini Mosaic FootballPSA 10$550$303——64
Walter Payton #2942025 Topps Finest FootballNear Mint$550$550——65
Walter Payton #101987 Topps American UK FootballPSA 10$535$45——66
Walter Payton #61979 Stop N Go FootballPSA 10$515$45——67
Walter Payton #31984 Topps Glossy Send In FootballPSA 10$512$6——68
Walter Payton #MG-262024 Topps Signature Class Football Monarchs of the GamePSA 10$475$84——69
Walter Payton #NM-WP2022 Panini Donruss Night Moves FootballPSA 10$464$203——70
Walter Payton #172024 Topps Resurgence FootballPSA 9.5$454$249——71
Walter Payton #201982 Topps Stickers FootballPSA 10$440$5——72
Walter Payton #1002015 Panini Flawless FootballNear Mint$410$410——73
Walter Payton #852022 Panini Flawless FootballPSA 10$400$335——74
Walter Payton #1312004 Leaf Certified Materials FootballNear Mint$400$400——75
Walter Payton (Photo Variation & Full Name-Walter Jerry Payton) #842022 Donruss FootballPSA 10$400$200——76
Walter Payton #842022 Donruss FootballPSA 10$400$200——77
Walter Payton #1451981 Topps Stickers FootballPSA 10$397$5——78
Walter Payton #UL-302025 Topps Chrome Football Urban LegendsPSA 10$388$121——79
Walter Payton #241983 Topps Football StickersPSA 10$376$3——80
Walter Payton #1012000 Upper Deck Legends FootballPSA 10$374$18——81
Walter Payton #802001 Topps Archives Reserve FootballPSA 10$369$28——82
Walter Payton #722021 Panini Flawless FootballNear Mint$368$368——83
Walter Payton #1772014 Panini National Treasures FootballNear Mint$366$366——84
Walter Payton #162024 Topps Chrome Cosmic FootballBGS 9.5$350$334——85
Walter Payton #271999 Upper Deck Retro FootballPSA 9$350$42——86
Walter Payton #632020 Panini Donruss FootballPSA 10$335$46——87
Walter Payton #71987 Topps Football 1,000 Yard ClubPSA 10$326$2——88
Walter Payton #2291984 Topps FootballPSA 10$325$2——89
Walter Payton #322008 Panini Donruss Classics Cuts FootballNear Mint$320$320——90
Walter Payton #2552008 Leaf Certified Materials FootballNear Mint$300$300——91
Walter Payton #61986 Topps Stickers FootballPSA 10$292$6——92
Walter Payton #141987 Topps Stickers FootballPSA 10$291$3——93
Walter Payton #CD-112024 Topps Cosmic Chrome Dust FootballPSA 10$275$83——94
Walter Payton #4022025 Topps Chrome Sapphire FootballNear Mint$263$263——95
Walter Payton #1561985 Topps Stickers FootballPSA 10$258$3——96
Walter Payton #1211981 Topps Stickers FootballPSA 10$255$5——97
Walter Payton #132024 Topps Finest FootballNear Mint$250$250——98
Walter Payton #61984 Topps Stickers FootballPSA 10$250$5——99
Walter Payton #662024 Panini Player Of The Day FootballNear Mint$250$250——100
Walter Payton #982017 Panini National Treasures FootballNear Mint$246$246——Sets with Walter Payton cards
Walter Payton appears in 335 sets. Open one for the most valuable cards in it.
- 2001 Topps Payton Reprint Football14 cards
- 2001 Topps Chrome Football Walter Payton Reprints Refractors13 cards
- 2001 Topps Football Walter Payton Reprints12 cards
- 1992 Upper Deck Football Heroes10 cards
- 1994 Ted Williams Co Sweetness Football8 cards
- 1999 Upper Deck Century Legends Football5 cards
- 1981 Topps Stickers Football3 cards
- 1983 Topps Stickers Football3 cards
- 1986 Topps Stickers Football3 cards
- 1978 Topps Football2 cards
- 1979 Topps Football2 cards
- 1981 Topps Football2 cards
- 1982 Topps Football2 cards
- 1983 Topps Football2 cards
- 1984 7 Eleven Discs Football2 cards
- 1984 Topps Football2 cards
- 1985 Topps Football2 cards
- 1986 Topps Football2 cards
- 1987 Topps Football2 cards
- 1997 Upper Deck Legends Football2 cards
- 1999 Upper Deck Ovation Center Stage Football2 cards
- 2001 Topps Archives Football2 cards
- 2003 Leaf Limited Threads Football2 cards
- 2008 Upper Deck Icons NFL Chronology2 cards
- 2014 Panini Absolute Football Tools of the Trade2 cards
- 2018 Panini Flawless Football2 cards
- 2019 Panini National Treasures Football Treasured Moments2 cards
- 2021 Panini Mosaic Football2 cards
- 2022 Donruss Football2 cards
- 1976 Topps Football1 card
- 1977 Topps Football1 card
- 1977 Topps Mexican Football1 card
- 1978 Topps Holsum Football1 card
- 1979 Stop N Go Football1 card
- 1980 Topps Football1 card
- 1980 Topps Super Football1 card
- 1981 Topps Red Border Stickers Football1 card
- 1982 Topps Stickers Football1 card
- 1983 Topps Football Stickers1 card
- 1984 Topps Glossy Send In Football1 card